平衡閱讀教學在英語為第一語言和第二語言教室中實施之比較

A Comparison of the Implementation of Balanced Reading Instruction between the First and the Second Language Classrooms

10.6384/CIQ.200901.0205

柳雅梅(Yea-Mei Leou)

平衡閱讀教學 ； 第一語言 ； 第二語言 ； balanced reading instruction ； first language ； second language

課程與教學

12卷1期（2009 / 01 / 01）

205 - 227

繁體中文

近幾年來，美國和南澳洲的閱讀教學都趨向結合全語教學和字母拼讀法教學的平衡閱讀教學取向，國內九年一貫英語教學的目標也和平衡閱讀教學的理念一致。雖然國內外研究證實平衡閱讀教學對學生學習的正向影響，但是，鮮少研究探討其在英語為第一語言和第二語言教學現場的實施情形。因此，本研究之研究目的在於探究平衡閱讀教學在英語為第一語言和第二語言教室中實施之異同，研究對象為美國伊利諾州一所小學中的老師及其所教導之班級學生，以及臺灣一所小學之英語教師及其所教導之班級學生。藉著整理與分析教室觀察、訪談紀錄、學生作業、教師手札、兩位教師之教學錄影帶等資料，比較平衡閱讀教學在英語為第一語言的教室和英語為第二語言的教室中實施之異同。希望本研究能夠協助國內教師進一步了解平衡閱讀教學之教材選擇、教室佈置、課程安排與教學活動、教師角色和教師對實施平衡閱讀教學之看法等議題。

In recent years, there has been a tendency to implement balanced reading instruction in the U.S. and the South Australia. Likewise in Taiwan, the English teaching goals of the Nine-Year Integrated Curriculum also match the ideas of balanced reading instruction. Although many studies have proved its positive influences on students' learning, yet few have focused on the comparison of its implementation between the first-language and the second- language classrooms. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to explore the similarities and differences in balanced reading instruction between the first and the second language classrooms. The participants of this study were a teacher and her students at an elementary school in Illinois, U.S.A., and a teacher and her students at an elementary school in Taiwan. The comparisons were done by analyzing the data of classroom observations, interviews, students' assignments, teachers' journals, and video tapes gathered from the classrooms. It is hoped that the results of the study could help the teachers in Taiwan get a better understanding of the choices of teaching materials, classroom decorations, curriculum designs and teaching activities, teacher's roles, and teachers' opinions of balanced reading instruction.

1. 柳雅梅、黃秀霜(2007)。平衡閱讀教學對國小學童英文閱讀能力及閱讀動機之影響。師大學報，教育類，52(1)，133-157。
   連結：
2. 柳雅梅、黃秀霜(2006)。平衡閱讀教學之行動研究。國民教育研究集刊，15，161-178。
   連結：
3. 柳雅梅、黃秀霜(2006)。平衡閱讀教學在國小英語教學之運用。課程與教學季刊，9(3)，83-101。
   連結：
4. Armbruster, B. B.,Osborn, J. H.(2002).Reading instruction and assessment-Understanding the IRA standards.Boston:Alley and Bacon.
5. Teaching Exceptional Children Plus
6. Teaching reading: A balanced, comprehensive approach to teaching reading in prekindergarten through grade three
7. The Australian
8. Fountas, I. C.,Pinnell, G. S.(1996).Guided reading.Portsmouth, NH:Heinemann.
9. Harris, T. L.,Hodges, R. E.(Eds.)(1995).The literacy dictionary-The vocabulary of reading and writing.DE:International Reading Association, Inc..
10. Lincoln, Y. S.,Cuba, E. G.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.Newbury, CA:Sage.
11. Merriam, S. B.(1998).Qualitative research and case study applications in education.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
12. Pressley, M.(1998).Reading instruction that works-The case for balanced teaching.New York:The Guilford Press.
13. Ramirez, R.(2005).Baton Rouge, LA.,Louisiana State University.
14. Reutzel, D. R.,Cooter, Jr. R. B.(1999).Balanced reading strategies and practice.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Merrill Prentice Hall.
15. Smith, C. B.(2003).The use of "balanced instruction" in language arts curriculum.ERIC Topical Bibliography and Commentary. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 480636).
16. Stoicheve, M.(1999).Balanced reading instruction. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 435986).
17. Strickland, D. S.(1998).What's basic in beginning reading? Finding common ground.Educational Leadership,55(6),6-10.
18. Sutherland, Z.(1997).Children & books.New York:Addison-Wesley Educational Publishers Inc..
19. Williams, K. A.(1998).Balancing the books: Finding appropriate texts for information and instruction.Balanced Reading Instruction,5(1),44-45.
20. Williams, K. A.,S. M. Blair-Larsen(Eds.),K. A. Williams(Eds.)(1999).The balanced reading program-Helping all students achieve success.Delaware:International Reading Association.
21. Witherell, N. L.(2007).The guided reading classroom: How to keep all students working constructively.Portsmouth, NH:Heinemann Educational Books, Inc..
22. 王文科(2000)。質的教育研究法。臺北:師大師苑。
23. 沈添鉦(1999)。全語理念在小學英語教學的應用：省思與展望。跨世紀國小英語教學研討會，屏東市:
24. 九年一貫課程
25. 陳秋蘭主編、廖美玲主編(2001)。嶄新而實用的英語教學－國小國中英語學指引。臺北:敦煌書局。
26. 潘璿如(2007)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。嘉義縣，國立嘉義大學國民教育研究所。

1. 黃秀霜、柳雅梅、沈添鉦(2014)。引導閱讀對國中學生英文認字及閱讀動機之影響。國立虎尾科技大學學報，32(2)，69-80。