合作小組目標互賴與精緻互助行為關係研究

Exploring the Relationship between Goal Interdependence and Elaborated Mutual Helping Behavior within Cooperative Small Groups

10.6384/CIQ.202307_26(3).0004

黃永和(Yung-Ho Huang)

合作學習 ； 協助 ； 求助 ； 精緻互助行為 ； 目標互賴 ； cooperative learning ； help-giving ； help-seeking ； elaborated mutual-helping ； goal interdependence

課程與教學

26卷3期（2023 / 07 / 01）

91 - 124

繁體中文;英文

本研究目的乃在探討數學合作學習小組組內同儕目標互賴對對同儕精緻協助與求助行為的預測力，研究對象為具有數學合作學習經驗的六年級學生，施以小組學習精緻互助行為量表與目標互賴量表，收回有效問卷計832份。潛在變項迴歸分析結果顯示：（1）正向與負向目標互賴對精緻協助行為有正向預測力，無目標互賴則有負向預測力；（2）正向與負向目標互賴對精緻求助行為有正向預測力，無目標互賴則有負向預測力；（3）正向目標互賴顯著高於負向目標互賴，二者具有正相關且均能正向預測同儕精緻互助行為，顯示組內同儕具有合作為主的競合關係。研究建議指出：（1）合作關係最能促進同儕互助，競合關係能添加互助動力；（2）更具有解釋力的精緻求助行為徑路模型值得未來研究進一步探討。

This study aimed to investigate the predictive power of the relationship between goal interdependence and elaborated mutual helping behavior within cooperative small groups in a math course. The study subjects were 832 sixth-grade students with experiences in math cooperative learning, and were administered the Mutual Helping Behaviors Questionnaire and Goal Interdependence Relationship Scale. The results of latent variable regression analysis showed that: (1) positive and negative goal interdependence had a positive predictive value for help-giving behavior of high-level elaboration, while no goal interdependence had a negative predictive value; (2) positive and negative goal interdependence had a positive predictive value for help-seeking behavior of high-level elaboration, while no goal interdependence had a negative predictive value; (3) Positive goal interdependence was significantly higher than negative goal interdependence, and both were positively correlated, and can positively predict mutual helping behavior, indicating that there is competition in a cooperative relationship among peers in the group. The study suggests that: (1) cooperative relationships can promote mutual help among peers, and competitive relationships can add motivation for mutual help; (2) the elaborated help -seeking behavior pathway model, which has more explanatory power, is worthy of further investigation in future research.

1. 張虹雯,王麗斐(2015)。當事人為什麼不求助？求助態度、求助意圖、求助行為之研究回顧與整合。輔導季刊，51(2)，31-41。
   連結：
2. 張新仁,許桂英(2004)。國小數學領域採合作學習之教學成效。教育學刊，23，111-136。
   連結：
3. 張嘉容,張媛甯(2018)。國小教師文化與教師專業學習社群發展之個案研究。教育行政雙月刊，114，252-282。
   連結：
4. 陳嘉成(2006)。為什麼自我跛足？與數學能力知覺、測驗焦慮對學習行為組型的中介效果。測驗學刊，53(1)，49-77。
   連結：
5. 彭淑玲,王佩琪,林宏泰(2017)。你求助嗎？個人目標導向與適應／非適應課業求助／避助行為之關係。教育心理學報，49(2)，267-293。
   連結：
6. 彭淑玲,程炳林(2005)。四向度課室目標結構、個人目標導向與課業求助行為之關係。師大學報：教育類，50(2)，69-95。
   連結：
7. 黃永和(2022)。合作學習參與公平性影響因素的多層次分析。課程與教學季刊，25(3)，83-106。
   連結：
8. Armas, A.,Šniras, Š.(2013).Interdependence-based model of consistency among competition, cooperation and collaboration.Baltic Journal of Sport and Health Sciences,1(88),9-17.
9. Baloche, L.,Brody, C. M.(2017).Cooperative learning: exploring challenges, crafting innovations.Journal of Education for Teaching,43(3),274-283.
10. Bengtsson, M.,Kock, S.(2000)."Coopetition" in business networks-to cooperate and compete simultaneously.Industrial Marketing Management,29(11),411-426.
11. Bengtsson, M.,Kock, S.(2014).Coopetition-Quo vadis? Past accomplishments and future challenges.Industrial Marketing Management,43(2),180-188.
12. Brandenburger, A. M.,Nalebuff, B. J.(1996).Co-opetition.Currency Doubleday.
13. Chai, L.,Li, J.,Clauss, T.,Tangpong, C.(2019).The influences of interdependence, opportunism and technology uncertainty on interfirm coopetition.Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing,34(5),948-964.
14. Cohen J. E.(1988).Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences.Lawrence Erlbaum.
15. Daft, R. L.(2015).The leadership experience.Cengage Learning.
16. Deutsch, M.(Ed.),Coleman, P. T.(Ed.),Marcus, E. C.(Ed.)(2006).The handbook of conflict resolution: Theory and practice.Jossey-Bass.
17. Dumont, H.(Ed.),Istance, D.(Ed.),Benavides, F.(Ed.)(2010).The nature of learning: Using research to inspire practice.OECD.
18. Farivar, S.,Webb, N. M.(1994).Helping and getting help: Essential skills for effective group problem solving.The Arithmetic Teacher,41(9),521-525.
19. Festinger, L.(1954).A theory of social comparison processes.Human Relations,7(2),117-140.
20. Forsyth, D. R.(1999).Group dynamics.Wadsworth.
21. Garcia, S.,Tor, A.,Schiff, T.(2013).The psychology of competition: A social comparison perspective.Perspectives on Psychological Science,8,634-650.
22. Gillies, R. M.,Ashman, A. F.(1996).Teaching collaborative skills to primary school children in classroom-based work groups.Learning and Instruction,6(3),187-200.
23. Hair, J.,Hult, T.,Ringle, C.,Sarstedt, M.(2014).A Primer on Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM).Sage.
24. Hattie, J.(2009).Visible learning: A synthesis of over 800 meta-analyses relating to achievement.Routledge.
25. Hertz-Lazarowitz, R.(1989).Cooperation and helping in the classroom: A contextual approach.International Journal of Educational Research,13(1),113-119.
26. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.(1989).Cooperation and competition: Theory and research.Interaction Book Company.
27. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.(2005).New developments in social interdependence theory.Genetic, Social, and General Psychology Monographs,131(4),285-358.
28. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.(1999).Learning together and alone: Cooperative, competitive, and individualistic learning.Allyn and Bacon.
29. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.,Anderson, D.(1983).Social interdependence and classroom climate.The Journal of Psychology,114,135-142.
30. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.,Holubec, E. J.(1994).The nuts and bolts of cooperative learning.Interaction Book Company.
31. Karabenick, S. A.(Ed.),Newman, R. S.(Ed.)(2006).Help seeking in academic settings: Goals, groups, and contexts.Routledge.
32. Kohn, A.(1992).No contest: The case against competition.Houghton Mifflin.
33. Lavasani, M. G.,Khandan, F.(2011).The effect of cooperative learning on mathematics anxiety and help seeking behavior.Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences,15,271-276.
34. Levi, D.(2014).Group dynamics for teams.SAGE.
35. Lewin, K.(2008).Resolving social conflicts & field theory in social science.American Psychological Association.
36. Nadler, A.(2020).Social psychology of helping relations: Solidarity and hierarchy.John Wiley & Sons.
37. Nelson-Le Gall, S.(1981).Help-seeking: An understudied problem-solving skill in children.Developmental Review,1(3),224-246.
38. Noddings, N.(1992).The challenge to care in schools: An alternative approach to education.Teachers College.
39. Onwuegbuzie, A. J.,Collins, K. M. T.,Jiao, Q. G.(2009).Performance of cooperative learning groups in a postgraduate education research methodology course: The role of social interdependence.Active Learning in Higher Education,10(3),265-277.
40. Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development(2019).PISA 2018 results (volume III): What school life means for students’ lives.OECD.
41. Renard, D.,Davis, J. G.(2019).Social interdependence on crowdsourcing platforms.Journal of Business Research,103,186-194.
42. Ryan, A. M.,Pintrich, P. R.,Midgley, C.(2001).Avoiding Seeking Help in the Classroom: Who and Why?.Educational Psychology Review,13(2),93-114.
43. Schul, J. E.(2011).Revisiting an old friend: The practice and promise of cooperative learning for the twenty-first century.The Social Studies,102(2),88-93.
44. Sharan, Y.,Sharan, S.(1992).Expanding cooperative learning through group investigation.Teachers College.
45. Shields, D. L.,Bredemeier, B. L.(2009).True competition: A guide to pursuing excellence in sport and society.Human Kinetics.
46. Tjosvold, D.(1986).The dynamics of interdependence in organizations.Human Relations,39(6),517-540.
47. Tjosvold, D.,Johnson, D.(2000).Deutsch's theory of cooperation and competition.Work teams: Past, present and future
48. Triandis, H. C.(1994).Theoretical and methodological approaches to the study of collectivism and individualism.Individualism and collectivism: Theory, method and applications
49. Webb, N. M.(1989).Peer interaction and learning in small groups.International Journal of Educational Research,13(1),21-39.
50. Webb, N. M.(1991).Task-related verbal interaction and mathematics learning in small groups.Journal for research in mathematics education,22(5),366-389.
51. Webb, N. M.,Farivar, S. H.,Mastergeorge, A. M.(2002).Productive helping in cooperative groups.Theory into Practice,41(1),13-20.
52. 佐藤學(2012).學習的革命：從教室出發的改革.天下.
53. 吳明隆,涂金堂(2005).SPSS 與統計應用分析.五南.
54. 李致誠(2007)。國立台東大學。
55. 馬嫚娸(2022)。國立台中教育大學。
56. 張新仁（編）(2019).分組合作學習：自發、互動、共好的實踐.教育部國民及學前教育署.
57. 張新仁（編）(2013).分組合作學習教學手冊.教育部國民及學前教育署.
58. 張慧淳,林曉芳(2013)。合作學習教學策略對國小五年級學童數學學習成效之影響—以數與量為例。教師專業研究期刊，5，1-30。
59. 黃永和(2021)。科技部補助專題研究計畫成果報告科技部補助專題研究計畫成果報告,科技部。
60. 黃政傑（編）(1997).教學原理.師大書苑.
61. 歐用生(2013)。學習的革命：本土實踐的反思。新北市教育，學習共同體特刊，4-16。
62. 魏麗敏(1996)。國小學生學習動機、數學焦慮與數學成就之研究。國民教育研究集刊，4，133-155。