從教育美學觀點探究整合STEAM學科的數學教育實踐

An Exploration for Practice of Mathematics Education Based on STEAM from Perspective of Educational Aesthetics

10.6423/HHHC.202311_(148).0006

林孟安(Meng-An Lin)

行動研究 ； 教育美學 ； 數學教育 ； STEAM教育 ； Action Research ； Educational Aesthetics ； Mathematics Education ； STEAM Education

學校行政

148期（2023 / 11 / 16）

136 - 161

繁體中文;英文

有鑑於整合科學、科技、工程、藝術與數學的STEAM教育研究對數學學習關注較為不足，數學教育的美感與價值亦具其深入研究的需要，本研究即統整STEAM教育與教育美學文獻，結合專業繪圖軟體「Adobe Illustrator」作教學設計之規劃，為一所國民中學27位九年級學生實施行動研究，以探索整合STEAM學科的數學教育之可能性與教學效果。研究發現美學導向的STEAM教育數學教學，其可能性反映在科技軟體、生活實例與藝術設計的有效整合，帶來增進學生數學觀念分析、應用、溝通，及提升學習興趣之效果；學生學習數學之詮釋的轉變反映在提升其對數學價值的態度，依據研究發現提出STEAM教育實踐的具體建議。

Since mathematics learning effectiveness has been less concerned from researches of STEAM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Art, Mathematics ) education, and there exist more requirements for investigation of aesthetics and values in mathematics education, an action research was implemented with "Adobe Illustrator" the drawing software for 27 9-grade students based on literature review for STEAM education and Educational Aesthetics to explore potential and effectiveness of mathematics education integrated with STEAM disciplines. Findings indicated that Aesthetics-oriented mathematics education based on STEAM has potential for integration of software, living examples and art-design; abilities for mathematics conception analysis, application, communication, and learning interests is enhanced; students' interpretation for mathematics learning reflect a change in sense of mathematics values. Recommendations based on research findings for STEAM education were proposed.

1. 左台益, T.-Y.,李健恆, K.-H.(2018)。素養導向數學教材設計。教育科學研究期刊，63(4)，29-58。
   連結：
2. 范斯淳, S.-C.,游光昭, K.-C.(2016)。科技教育融入 STEM 課程的核心價值與實踐。教育科學研究期刊，61(2)，153-183。
   連結：
3. 范靜媛, J.-Y.,葉建宏, J.-H.(2020)。設計自我效能、設計興趣和 STEM 學習表現之相關分析：以時尚設計為例。教育科學研究期刊，65(1)，221-246。
   連結：
4. 張基成, C.-C.,陳怡靜, Y.-C.(2018)。機器人跨領域 STEM 主題式統整課程與任務導向式教學的設計及評鑑。科學教育學刊，26(4)，305-331。
   連結：
5. 湯維玲, W.-L.(2019)。探究美國 STEM 與 STEAM 教育的發展。課程與教學，22(2)，49-77。
   連結：
6. 劉柏宏, P.-H.(2016)。從數學與文化的關係探討數學文化素養之內涵─理論與案例分析。臺灣數學教育期刊，3(1)，55-83。
   連結：
7. 盧秀琴, C.-C.,馬士茵, S.-Y.(2019)。設計 STEAM 課程培養國小學生的 STEAM 素養：以「動物模仿獸」為例。教育科學研究期刊，64(3)，85-118。
   連結：
8. 羅希哲, S.-J.,蔡慧音, H.-Y.,曾國鴻, K.-H.(2011)。高中女生 STEM 網路專題式合作學習之研究。高雄師大學報：自然科學與科技類，30，41-61。
   連結：
9. Adu-Agyem, J.,Enti, M.(2009).Learning: The role of aesthetics in education.Journal of Science and Technology,29(1)
10. Apps, L.,MacDonald, M.(2012).Classroom Aesthetics in Early Childhood Education.Journal of Education and Learning,1(1)
11. Baskerville, R. L.(1999).Investigating Information Systems with Action Research.Communications of the Association for Information Systems,2(19)
12. Bishop, A.,Seah, W. T.,Chin, C.(2011).Values in Mathematics Teaching-The Hidden Persuaders?.Second International Handbook of Mathematics Education
13. Black, M. (1944). Education as art and discipline. In I. Scheffler (Ed.), Philosophy and education (pp. 32‒38). Allyn and Bacon.
14. Boaler, J.(1993).Encouraging the transfer of ‘school’ mathematics to the ‘real world’ through the integration of process and content, context and culture.Educational Studies in Mathematics,25,341-373.
15. Bush, S. B.,Cox, R.,Cook, K. L.(2016).A critical focus on the M in STEAM.Teaching Children Mathematics,23(2),110-114.
16. Cavanaugh, S.(2014).Science Sublime: The Philosophy of the Sublime, Dewey’s Aesthetics, and Science Education.Education and Culture,30(1),57-77.
17. Daugherty, M. K.(2013).The Prospect of an "A" in STEM Education.Journal of STEM Education: Innovation and Research,14(2)
18. English, L.D.(2016).STEM education K-12: perspectives on integration.International Journal of STEM Education,3(1)
19. Fitzallen, N.(2015).STEM Education: What Does Mathematics Have to Offer?.Mathematics education in the margins (Proceedings of the 38th annual conference of the Mathematics Education Research Group of Australasia),Sunshine Coast:
20. Hansen, D. T.(2004).A poetics of teaching.Educational Theory,54(2),119-142.
21. Hefty, L. J.(2015).STEM Gives Meaning to Mathematics.Teaching Children Mathematics,21(7)
22. Holmlund, T. D.,Lesseig, K.,Slavit, D.(2018).Making sense of "STEM education" in K-12 contexts.International Journal of STEM Education,5
23. Huber, S. A.,Seidel, T.(2018).Comparing teacher and student perspectives on The interplay of cognitive and motivational affective student characteristics.PLoS ONE,13(8)
24. Keane, L.,Keane, M.(2016).STEAM by Design.Design and Technology Education,21(1),61-82.
25. Koul, L.(2013).Methodology of Educational Research.New Delhi:Vikas Publishing House Pvt Ltd..
26. Lavicza, Z.,Prodromou, T.,Fenyvesi, K.,Hohenwarter, M.,Juhos, I.,Koren, B.(2020).Integrating STEM-related Technologies into Mathematics Education at Large Scale.International Journal for Technology in Mathematics Education,27(1),3-12.
27. Li, Y.,Schoenfeld, A. H.(2019).Problematizing teaching and learning mathematics as "given" in STEM education.International Journal of STEM Education,6(44)
28. Maeda, J.(2013).STEM + Art = STEAM.The STEAM Journal,1(1)
29. Ng, O.-L.(2017).Exploring the use of 3D Computer-Aided Design and 3D Printing for STEAM Learning in Mathematics.Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education,3,257-263.
30. Quigley, C. F.,Herro, D.,Jamil, F. M.(2017).Developing a Conceptual Model of STEAM Teaching Practices.School Science and Mathematics,117(1?2),1-12.
31. Sinclair, N.(2009).Aesthetics as a liberating force in mathematics education?.ZDM Mathematics Education,41(45)
32. Sparrow, L.,Hurst, C.(2010).Effecting Affect: Developing a Positive Attitude to Primary Mathematics Learning.Australian Primary Mathematics Classroom,15(1)
33. Taylor, P. C.,Medina, M.(2013).Educational research paradigms- From positivism to multiparadigmatic.Journal for Meaning-Centered Education,1,1-16.
34. 王文科, W.-K.,王智弘, Z.-H.(2020).教育研究法.五南=Wu-Nan.
35. 林坤誼, K.-Y.(2021)。STEM 跨領域教學合作設計模式與有效失敗經驗設計之研究。人文社會科學研究：教育類，15(2)，1-18。
36. 林勇吉, Y.-C.,秦爾聰, E.-T.,段曉林, H.-L.(2014)。數學探究之意義初探與教學設計實例。臺灣數學教師，35(2)，1-18。
37. 林逢祺, F.-C.(2015).教育哲學：一個美學提案.五南=Wu-Nan.
38. 徐惠莉, H.-L.,曹友賓, Y.-P.(2019)。教育部教學實踐研究計畫教育部教學實踐研究計畫,新竹縣:中國科技大學=Center for General Education, China University of Technology。
39. 馬宜平, Y.-P.,荊溪昱, G.-C.(2021)。國小 S.T.E.M 教學設計：以手搖式手電筒的設計、製作為例。人文社會科學研究：教育類，15(2)，19-48。
40. 張民杰, M.-C.(2018)。運用問題導向學習設計與實施素養導向教學可行性之探究。課程研究，13(2)，43-58。
41. 蔡清田, C.-T.(2014).國民核心素養：十二年國教課程改革的 DNA.高等教育=Higher Education Press.
42. 盧秀琴, C.-C.,洪榮昭, J.-C.,陳芬芳, F.-F.(2019)。設計STEAM課程的協同教學─以「感控式綠建築」為例。教育學報，47(1)，113-133。

1. (2024).Research on STEAM Education Theses in Taiwan: Literature Analysis, Development Trends, and Future Prospects.教育資料與圖書館學,61(2),161-209.