租買選擇、貸款選擇、與世代組成：巢式LOGIT模型之應用

Tenure Choice, Mortgage Payment, and Household Composition of Generation: An Application of Nested Logit Model

10.6375/JHS.200506.0001

林祖嘉(Chu-Chia Lin)；陳建良(Chien-Liang Chen)

租買選擇 ； 貸款選擇 ； 世代組成 ； tenure choice ； mortgage payment ； composition of generation

住宅學報

14卷1期（2005 / 06 / 01）

1 - 20

繁體中文

租買選擇和家庭組成都是影響住宅需求的主要考慮。若一個家庭決定選擇購屋，則是否需要貸款，貸款多少，是另外一個必須同時決定的考量。雖然國內已有相關文獻分別探討租買選擇、貸款需求與世代組成對住宅需求的影響，但受限於資料，這些文獻一直都缺乏對上述這三個因素交互影響的聯合分析。本研究主要目的，是採用1996年台灣的家計收支調查資料，利用幾個不同層次的logit模型，同時分析這三個因素對住宅需求的交互影響關係。 本文先採用條件式logit模型與多項式logit模型來進行估計，然後再利用Hausman檢定來測試這二種模型的適當性。由於兩種模型的適用性都未通過檢驗，我們接著再建立一個巢式logit模型，並利用充分訊息最大概似法(FIML)進行估計，結果發現FIML的設定方式符合巢式logit模型的要求。在FIML的估計之下，我們發現家戶總所得、家戶組成、與所得組成對於租買選擇及貸款選擇都有顯著的影響。

Tenure choice and household composition are important factors in determining housing demand. If a household decides to own a dwelling unit, consequently, he has to consider whether and how much to borrow from a bank. Though there are some literatures in Taiwan considering the influence of tenure choice, household composition, and mortgage on housing demand, it is lack of a systematic analysis on the three factors. The purpose of this paper is using the 1996 Survey on Family Income and Expenditure of DGBAS and applying several levels of logit model to estimate the impacts of the above three factors on housing demand simultaneously. A conditional logit model and a multinomial logit model are estimated first and the Hausman tests are applied to check the effectiveness of the two logit models in describing the data. Since the ⅡA hypothese does not hold completely under the two types of specifications, we then extend to a nested logit model and apply the full information maximum likelihood (FIML) method to consider these three factors on housing demand. The results show that the model's requirement of the nested logit specification is fulfilled under the FIML estimation. Moreover, it is found that household income, composition of generation, and income earners composition all play significant roles on the behavior of tenure choice and housing loan demand.

1. 陳彥仲(1996)。住宅選擇之程序決策模式。住宅學報，5，37-49。
   連結：
2. 華昌宜(1994)。台灣應有的住宅目標。住宅學報，2，133-134。
   連結：
3. Bourassa, S. C.(1995).The Impacts of Borrowing Constraints on Home-Ownership in Australia.Urban Studies,32,1167-1173.
4. Di Salvo, D.,I. Ermisch(1997).Analysis of Housing Tenure Choice in Britain.Journal of Urban Economics,42,1-17.
5. Goodman, A. C.(2003).Following a Panel of Stayers: Length of Stay, Tenure Choice, and Housing Demand.Journal of Housing Economics,12,106-133.
6. Greene, W.(1997).Econometric Analysis.
7. Haurin D. R.,P. H. Herdershoot,D. Kim(1994).Housing Decisions of American Youth.Journal of Urban Economics,35,28-45.
8. Haurin, D. R.,P. H. Hendershott,S. M. Wachter(1997).Borrowing Constraints and the Tenure Choice of Young Households.Journal of Housing Research,8,137-154.
9. Hausman, J.,D. McFadden(1984).Specification Tests for the Multinomial Logit Model.Econometrica,52,1219-1240.
10. Hayashi, F.(1995).Is the Japanese Extended Family Altruistically Linked? A Test Based on Engel Curves.Journal of Political Economy,103(5),661-674.
11. Henderson, J. V.,Y. M. loannides(1986).Tenure Choice and the Demand for Housing.Economica,53(210),231-246.
12. Henderson, J. V.,Y. M. loannides(1983).A Model of Housing Tenure Choice.American Economic Review,73,98-113.
13. Kan, K.(2000).Dynamic Modeling of Housing Tenure Choice.Journal of Urban Eocnomics,48,46-69.
14. Li, M. M.(1997).A Logit Model of Homeownership.Econometrica,45,1081-1091.
15. Lin, C. C.,C. L. Chen,S. J. Lin(2001).Life Cycle, Mortgage Payment, and Forced Saving.International Real Estate Review,3(1),151-182.
16. Linneman, P.,I. F. Megbolugbe,M. Cho(1997).Borrowing Constraints Change U.S. Homeownership Rate?.Journal of Housing Economics,6,318-333.
17. Linneman, P.,S.M. Wachter(1989).The Impacts of Borrowing Constraints of Homeownership.Journal of the A men can Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,17,389-402.
18. Maddala, G. S.(1983).Limited-Dependent and Qualitative Variables in Econometrics.
19. McFadden, D.(1978).Modelling the Choice of Residential location.nstitute of Transportation Studies.
20. McFadden, D.(1978).Spatial Interaction Theory and Residential Lacation.
21. McFadden, D.(1981).Econometric Models of Probabilities and Structural Analysis of Discrete Data with Choice.Structural Analysis of Discrete Choice with Econometric Applications.
22. McFadden, D.(1974).Conditional Logit Analysis of Qualitative Choice Behavior.Institute of Urban and Regional Development.
23. McFadden, D.(1974).Conditional Logit Analysis of Qualitative Choice Behavior.Frontier in Econometrics.
24. McFadden, D.(1978).Modelling the Choice of Residential location.Spatial Interaction Theory and Residential Lacation.
25. McFadden, D.(1981).Econometric Models of Probabilities and Structural Analysis of Discrete Data with Choice.Structural Analysis of Discrete Choice with Econometric Applications
26. SAS/ETS Users Guide(2002).V8.2, SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC..
27. STATA(2001).V.7, Stata Corporation.
28. Tachibanaki, T.(1994).Housing and Saving in Japan.Housing Markets in the United States and Japan.
29. Tachibanaki, T.,K. Shimono(1986).Saving and Life-Cycle: A Cohort Analysis.Journal of Public Economics,31,1-24.
30. 林祖嘉(1994)。臺灣地區住宅需求與租買選擇之聯合估計。國立政治大學學報，68，183-200。
31. 林祖嘉(1992)。台灣地區房租與房價關係之研究。台銀季刊，43(1)，279-312。
32. 林祖嘉(1990)。反向巢型多項式Logit模型下的住屋需求與租買選擇。經濟論文，18(1)，137-158。
33. 林祖嘉(1996)。失業搜尋、在職搜尋、與工作轉換：巢式Logit模型的應用。經濟論文叢刊，24(2)，205-225。
34. 林祖嘉、林素菁(1996)。住宅需求、住宅價格、與貸款成數。台灣經濟學會年會論文集
35. 林祖嘉、陳建良(1998)。貸款支出與強迫儲蓄：台灣地區家計單位儲蓄行為再分析。台灣經濟學會年會論文集
36. 施鴻志、段良雄、凌瑞寬(1984)。都市交通計畫－理論、實際。台北:茂昌圖書公司。
37. 段良雄(1984)。巢式多項羅機(NMNL)運具選擇模式。運輸計畫季刊，13(3)，285-308。
38. 陳建良、伊慶春(2004)。夫妻間的權力分配以及家庭的決策機制－夫妻配對樣本的深入分析。2004年台灣經濟學會年會論文。
39. 陳建良、林祖嘉(2002)。住宅貸款選擇與住宅租擁選擇。2002年中華民國住宅學會第十一屆年會學術研討會論文集
40. 陳彥仲(1998)。對多項Logit模型參數指定方式之比較分析。交大管理學報，18(2)，171-185。
41. 馮正民(1986)。運輸使用者之效益衡量。運輸計畫季刊，15(4)，535-544。

1. 陳麗品(2016)。臺灣地區房屋標準單價表公平性之探討。臺中科技大學財政稅務系租稅管理與理財規劃碩士班學位論文。2016。1-83。