臺北市違章建築查報及後續處理決策因素

Determinants of Reporting Illegal Building Structures and Government Policy Response

林子欽(Tzu-Chin Lin)；朱永恩(Yung-En Chu)；吳文傑(Wen-Chieh Wu)

違建查報 ； 違建拆除 ； 公寓大廈管理委員會 ； illegal building structures ； residents' management committee ； board in charge of resolving disputes regarding illegal buildings

住宅學報

30卷2期（2021 / 12 / 01）

47 - 66

繁體中文

臺灣的違建現象具有重要社會意涵，然而至今少有實證研究。本文使用迴歸模型，檢視臺北市違章建築查報及後續處理之個體資料。我們發現違章建築查報及處理過程存在特定的規律。違建查報數量較多的里，並不在老舊行政區，而是較晚發展的行政區。政府對於重複違法的拆後重建違建及新違建，採取較積極的處理方式。相對地，既存違建為早期興建，若無重大公安影響，多納入分期分類計畫，採取較消極的處理方式。然而民眾和政府展現的經濟理性決策，並不能正當化違建的存在。公寓大廈管理委員會的合理運作，將是未來違建問題解決和預防的關鍵。

Illegal building structures pose societal problems and demand for policy actions. Despite this demand there have been only limited empirical studies into the topic. We here employ regression techniques to analyse micro data of reported individual illegal structures in Taipei City. A number of specific patterns are revealed with respect to both reporting of illegal structures and actions taken against them. Reported illegal structures are likely to occur in newly developed neighbourhoods instead of old downtown areas. Once illegal structures have been reported, new structures and those that were previously demolished and rebuilt are more likely to be torn down. All in all, both residents and the Taipei City government take actions in their own interest. In the future, residents' management committees could deter new illegality through collective decisions. In addition, the board in charge of resolving disputes regarding illegal buildings which has been set up in early 2020 should expedite the administrative process and increase its transparency.

1. 朱芳妮, F. N.(2012)。集合住宅使用衝突與管理維護績效關係之探討。住宅學報，21(1)，37-65。
   連結：
2. 曾鵬光, P. K.,江哲銘, C. M.,陳肇堯, C. Y.(2010)。違章建築現象分類與其對外部環境衝擊之研究—以臺南市為例。住宅學報，19(2)，59-80。
   連結：
3. 曾鵬光, P. K.,陳佳欣, C. H.(2012)。建蔽率與容積率管制誘發開發商建築違建現象之探討—臺南市新建透天住宅之實證分析。住宅學報，21(1)，19-36。
   連結：
4. 華昌宜, C. I.,王鴻楷, H. K.,林祖嘉Lin, C. C.,吳森田Wu, S. T.,陳小紅, H. H.,陳亮全, L. C.,張金鶚, C. O.,楊重信, C. H.,Hsueh, L. M.(1996)。台北市住宅政策總體檢問題與建議。住宅學報，4(1)，89-103。
   連結：
5. Ehrlich, I.,Becker, G.(1972).Market Insurance, Self-Insurance, and Self-Protection.Journal of Political Economy,80(4),623-648.
6. Evans, A. W.(2003).Shouting Very Loudly: Economics, Planning and Politics.Town Planning Review,74(2),195-212.
7. Gujarati, D.(2011).Econometrics by Examples.London:Palgrave MacMillan.
8. Ho, D. C. W.,Chau, K. W.,Yau, Y.(2008).Evaluating Unauthorized Appendages in Private Apartment Building.Building Research and Information,36(6),568-579.
9. Hoffman, T. K.(1990).Unauthorized Housing in Greece: A Response to High Costs and Land Scarcity.International Journal on World Peace,7(2),71-74.
10. Kapoor, M.,le Blanc, D.(2008).Measuring Risk on Investment in Informal (Illegal) Housing: Theory and Evidence from Pune, India.Regional Science and Urban Economics,38,311-329.
11. Lai, J. C.(2003).Perception of Environmental Hazards in Hong Kong Chinese.Risk Analysis,23(4),669-684.
12. Lai, L. W. C.,Ho, D. C.W.(2001).Unauthorised Structures in a High-rise High-density Environment-The Case of Hong Kong.Property Management,19(2),112-123.
13. Patton, C. V.,Sophoulis, C. M.(1989).Unauthorized Suburban Housing Production in Greece.Urban Geography,10(2),138-156.
14. Polyzos, S.,Minetos, D.(2007).Past and Present Patterns of Informal Housing in Greece: A Spatial Analysis, Discussion Paper Series, University of Thessaly.Greece,13(6),137-164.
15. Tanasescu, A.,Wing-tak, E. C.,Smart, A.(2010).Tops and Bottoms: State Tolerance of Illegal Housing in Hong Kong and Calgary.Habitat International,34(4),478-484.
16. Yau, Y.(2015).The Value of Building Safety: A Hedonic Price Approach.Urbani izziv,26(1),92-104.
17. Yiu, C. Y.(2005).Institutional Arrangement and Unauthorised Building Works in Hong Kong.Structural Survey,23(1),22-29.
18. Zanfi, F.(2013).The Città Abusiva in Contemporary Southern Italy: Illegal Building and Prospects for Change.Urban Studies,50(16),3428-3445.
19. 林庭毅, T. Y(2006)。國立臺灣科技大學設計學院建築研究所=Graduate School of Architecture, National Taiwan University of Science and Technology。
20. 康旻杰, M. J.(2015)。臺北市戰後都市及公共住宅發展的未竟之業。計劃城事：戰後臺北都市發展歷程，臺北=Taipei:
21. 張廖萬益, W. I.(2013)。國立中央大學=National Central University。
22. 黃孫權, S. C.(2012).綠色推土機：九零年代的台北的違建、公園、自然房地產與制度化地景.新北=New Taipei:獨立媒體出版社=Independent Media Publsiher.
23. 黃錦堂, J. T.,呂育誠, Y. C.,陳英鈐, I. C.(2001)。台北市政府法規委員會委託研究計畫台北市政府法規委員會委託研究計畫,台北市政府法規委員會=Department of Legal Affairs of Taipei City Government。
24. 黃麗, L. L.(2015)。違章建築社區。全國律師，19(1)，18-27。
25. 臺北市都發局建管處2021 < 違建查報資料 > https://tccmoapply.dba.tcg.gov.tw/tccmoapply/maliapp/asp/aspsqu01.do?node=031b24b354a5396aac3350905b657d7a
26. 謝崑滄, K. T(2006)。高雄，國立中山大學中山學術研究所=National Sun Yat-Sen University。