不動產有效稅率對於房地產市場價量影響之探討：臺灣縣市級資料之應用

The Impact of Effective Property Tax Rates on the Housing Market: Evidence from County-Level Data of Taiwan

李明軒(Ming-Hsuan Lee)；林祖嘉(Chu-Chia Lin)；鄭輝培(Hui-Pei Cheng)

不動產有效稅率 ； 房地產市場價格 ； 房地產交易量 ； 固定效果模型 ； 分量迴歸 ； Effective property tax rate ； housing price ； housing transaction volume ； fixed effect model ； quantile regression

住宅學報

31卷2期（2022 / 12 / 01）

1 - 27

英文

本研究探討不動產有效稅率對於房地產市場價格與交易量之影響。我們利用2013至2018年不動產交易實價登錄與財政統計年報資料，推估各縣市各年度之不動產有效稅率，繼而估計不動產有效稅率對於房地產市場價格與交易量之影響。估計模型包括固定效果模型以及分量迴歸模型。估計結果顯示當不動產有效稅率提高，房地產市場之價格與交易量均會下降；分量迴歸的估計結果進一步顯示不動產有效稅率對於不同分位之價格與交易量皆有顯著影響，且對於分位越高之市場抑制效果越大。此結果說明不動產有效稅率的調整對於房地產市場的影響可望是有效且全面的。

This study examines the impact of the effective property tax rate on price and transaction volume in the housing market. We utilize the real estate transaction data drawn from the Real Estate Actual Transaction Price Inquiring System of the Ministry of the Interior and the Yearbook of Financial Statistics from 2013 to 2018 to estimate the effective property tax rates for each county and city in each year. Then we estimate the effect of the effective property tax rate on the price and transaction volume of the housing market. The estimation strategies include a fixed-effects model and a quantile regression model. The estimation results show that when the effective property tax rate increases, the price and transaction volume in the housing market will decrease. The results of the quantile regression model further show that the effective property tax rate has a significant impact on the price and transaction volume for different quantiles-the market restraint effect becomes greater among the higher quantiles. The findings of this paper suggest that increasing the effective property tax rate will be effective in cooling down the housing market activities.

1. 朱敬一, Cyrus CY,康廷嶽, Ting-Yueh(2015)。經濟轉型中的社會不公平。台灣經濟預測與政策，45(2)，1-22。
   連結：
2. 李明軒, Ming-Hsuan(2016)。我國房地產價格對於經濟機會不平等的影響之研究。臺灣經濟預測與政策，47(1)，37-65。
   連結：
3. 胡勝正, Sheng-Cheng(2015)。從房價所得比看臺灣的社會不公。臺灣經濟預測與政策，45(2)，23-43。
   連結：
4. 陳揚仁, Yang-Jen(2016)。財產稅有效稅率之研究—以台北市為例。育達科大學報，42，107-130。
   連結：
5. 陳德翰, Te-Han,王宏文, Hong-Wung(2011)。臺北市房屋稅公平性之研究－兼論豪宅稅之合理性。行政暨政策學報，53，115-162。
   連結：
6. 彭建文, Chien-Wen,吳森田, Sun-Tien,吳祥華, Shyang-Hua(2007)。不動產有效稅率對房價影響分析－以台北市大同區與內湖區為例。台灣土地研究，10(2)，49-66。
   連結：
7. 蔡吉源, Chi-yuan(2001)。台灣土地課稅制度：問題、影響與改革。台灣土地研究，3，37-82。
   連結：
8. 謝文盛, Wen-Sheng(2001)。再論土地增值稅與住宅價格之關係。住宅學報，10(2)，91-105。
   連結：
9. 謝文盛, Wen-Sheng,林素菁, Sue-Jing(2000)。租稅效果對住宅租買選擇影響之分析。住宅學報，9(1)，1-17。
   連結：
10. 謝文盛, Wen-Sheng,林素菁, Sue-Jing(2000)。租稅效果對住宅租買選擇影響之分析。住宅學報，9(1)，1-17。
    連結：
11. Bentick, B. L.(1979).The Impact of Taxation and Valuation Practices in the Timing and Efficiency of Land Use.Journal of Political Economy,87(4),859-868.
12. Bloom, H. S.,Ladd, H. F.,Yinger, J.(1983).Are Property Taxes Capitalized into House Value?.Local Provision of Public Service: The Tiebout Model After Twenty Five Years,New York:
13. Bourassa, S. C.(1992).Economic Effect of Taxes on Land: A Review.American Journal of Economic and Sociology,51(1),109-114.
14. Brueckner, J. K.(1986).A Modern Analysis of the Effects of Site Value Taxation.National Tax Journal,34(1),49-58.
15. Edwards, M. E.(1984).Site Value Taxation in Australia: Where Land Is Taxed More Improvement Less, Average Housing Value and Stock Are Higher.American Journal of Economic and Sociology,43(4),481-495.
16. Fischel, W. A.(1995).Regulatory Takings: Law, Economics, and Politics.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
17. Fischel, W. A.(1985).The Economics of Zoning Laws: A Property Rights Approach to American Land Use Controls.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press.
18. Fischel, W. A.(1975).Fiscal and Environmental Considerations in the Location of Firms in Suburban Communities.Fiscal Zoning and Land Use Controls,Lexington, MA:
19. Grieson, R. E.(1974).The Economics of Property Taxes and Land Value: The Elasticity of Supply of Structure.Journal of Urban Economics,1(4),367-381.
20. Hamilton, B. W.(1975).Zoning and Property Taxation in a System of Local Governments.Urban Studies,12,205-211.
21. Hamilton, B. W.(1976).Capitalization of Intrajurisdictional Differences in Local Tax Prices.American Economic Review,66,743-753.
22. Mieszkowski, P.(1972).The Property Tax. An Excise Tax or a Profits Tax?.Journal of Public Economics,1,73-96.
23. Netzer, D.(1966).Economics of the Property Tax.Washington DC:Brookings Institution.
24. Oates, W. E.(1969).The Effect of Property Taxes and Local Public Spending on Property Values: An Empirical Study of Tax Capitalization and the Tiebout Hypothesis.Journal of Political Economy,77(6),957-971.
25. Richardson, D. H.,Thalheimer, R.(1981).Measuring the Extent of Property Tax Capitalization for Single Family Residences.Southern Economic Journal,674-689.
26. Simon, H. A. 1943 “The Incidence of a Tax on Urban Real Property,” Quarterly Journal of Economics. 59: 398-420.
27. White, M. J.(1975).Firm Location in a Zoned Metropolitan Area.Fiscal Zoning and Land Use Controls,Lexington, MA:
28. Wilson, J. D.(1999).Theories of Tax Competition.National Tax Journal,52,269-304.
29. Yinger, J.,Bloom, H. S.,Boersch-Supan, A.,Ladd, H. F.(1988).Property Taxes and House Values: The Theory and Estimation of Intrajurisdictional Property Tax Capitalization.San Diego, CA.:Academic Press.
30. Zodrow, G. R.,Mieszkowski, P.(1986).Pigou, Tiebout, Property Taxation and the Under-provision of Local Public Goods.Journal of Urban Economics,19,356-370.
31. Zodrow, G. R.,Mieszkowski, P.(1983).The Incidence of the Property Tax. The Benefit View vs. the New View.Local Provision of Public Services: The Tiebout Model after Twenty-five Years,New York:
32. 吳宜潔, Yi-Chieh(2017)。成功大學會計學系暨財務金融研究所=Department of Accountancy and Graduate Institute of Finance, Cheng Kung University。
33. 周良惠, Liang-Hui(1999)。地價稅與房屋稅對土地利用之經濟效果分析。土地經濟年刊，10，47-61。
34. 周美麗, Mei-Li(2003)。房屋現值評定之探討。稅務旬刊，1877，12-18。
35. 林祖嘉2021 〈實價登錄 2.0 解決不了高房價問題〉聯合報，2020/01/10。https://udn.com/news/story/7339/5161771Lin, Chu-Jia2021 “Registration of Actual Transaction Prices 2.0 Won’t Solve the Issue of High House Price,” United Daily News, January 10, 2020. https://udn.com/news/story/7339/5161771.
36. 林祖嘉, Chu-Jia,鄭輝培, Hui-Pei,林孟璇, Meng-Xuan(2021)。林祖嘉、鄭輝培、林孟璇 2021 〈不動產有效稅率對住宅價格影響之分析：實價登錄資料之應用〉手稿。Lin, Chu-Jia, Cheng, Hui-Pei & Lin, Meng-Xuan 2021 “The Effect of the Effective Property Tax Rate on Residential Prices: An Application of Real Transaction Price Data,” Unpublished manuscript.。
37. 林雯琪, Wun-Ci(2019)。國立政治大學地政學系=Department of Land Economics, National Cheng Chi University。
38. 邱戴玉, Tai-yu(2014)。嶺東科技大學財稅與會計資訊研究所=Graduate Institute of Public Finance and Accounting, Ling Tung University。
39. 翁惠英, Hui-Ying(2019)。國立臺中科技大學財政稅務系=Department of Public Finance and Taxation, National Taichung University of Science and Technology。
40. 梁仁旭, Jen-Hsu(1998)。地價稅率變動對土地開發影響之理論與實證分析。土地經濟年刊，9，163-181。
41. 陳玠安, Jie-An(2019)。國立政治大學財政學系=Department of Public Finance, National Cheng Chi University。
42. 陳建新, Jian-Hsin(2020)。國立臺中科技大學財政稅務系=Department of Public Finance and Taxation, National Taichung University of Science and Technology。
43. 華昌宜, Chang-I(1997)。從供應面解釋房地產稅率增長之趨勢。住宅學報，6，15-26。
44. 黃裕聰, Yu-Tsong(2016)。國立臺中科技大學財政稅務系=Department of Public Finance and Taxation, National Taichung University of Science and Technology。
45. 會計師小羊2019 〈台灣高房價的原因你知道嗎？〉風傳媒，2019/11/02。https://www.storm.mg/article/1898757. Accountant Hsiao-Yang2019 “Do You Know the Reason of High House Price in Taiwan?,” Storm Media, November 02, 2019. https://www.storm.mg/article/1898757.
46. 臺北市政府地政局2019 〈地價作業程序與計算公式簡介〉臺北市政府地政局。2019/06/06。https://land.gov.taipei/cp.aspx?n=78EF83E97DDD5AAC. Department of Land Administration, Taipei City Government2019 “Introduction to the Operating Procedures and Calculation Formula of Land Price,”Department of Land Administration, Taipei City Government. June 6, 2019. https://land.gov.taipei/cp.aspx?n=78EF83E97DDD5AAC.
47. 臺北市稅捐稽徵處2017 〈標準單價調整、高級住宅及路段率〉臺北市稅捐稽徵處。2017/12/27。https://tpctax.gov.taipei/cp.aspx?n=EDB4FC877A418E63. Taipei City Revenue Service 2017 “Changes on Standard Unit Price, High-Class Residential and Section Rate,” Taipei City Revenue Service. December 27, 2017. https://tpctax.gov.taipei/cp.aspx?n=EDB4FC877A418E63.
48. 劉人豪, Jen-Hao(2015)。國立成功大學建築學系=Department of Architecture, National Cheng Kung University。
49. 蔡吉源, Chi-yuan,林健次, Kien-Tsu(1999)。我國土地稅制下地價稅與土地增值稅對地價的影響。財稅研究，31(5)，1-19。
50. 蘇惠屏, Hui-Ping(2017)。房屋稅條例課稅制度之分析—以評定現值及稅率為中心。財稅研究，46(3)，47-73。

1. (2024)。不動產有效稅率對不動產市場空屋率之影響：臺灣鄉鎮級資料之應用。都市與計劃，51(1)，29-51。
2. (2024)。自住與非自住之房屋稅率差異對房價之影響－差異中之差異法的應用。住宅學報，33(2)，27-62。