「進步」的揭示與開創：論杜威學說與美國進步主義教育各派別之差異

Revealing and Creating "Progress": Philosophical Differences between John Dewey and Various Factions within American Progressive Education

10.6388/JES.201012.0053

李玉馨(Yuh-Shin Li)

美國教育史 ； 進步主義教育運動 ； 杜威教育哲學 ； History of American Education ； Progressive Education Movement ； John Dewey's Philosophy of Education

教育科學期刊

9卷2期（2010 / 12 / 01）

53 - 76

繁體中文

19世紀末到20世紀上半葉，是美國社會變遷最劇烈的時期，進步主義教育因應著現代社會的需求而誕生，著名哲學家杜威則是迅速成爲此運動的精神領袖。本文從杜威哲學的發展過程及其所描繪的教育願景出發，以「進步」概念的多層涵意爲論述軸心，旨在釐清杜威學說與其他進步主義教育思想派別間的重大差異。研究發現杜威的確與其他派別在某些方面抱持相似主張，如拒斥傳統教育、提倡手工訓練、重視兒童自由、建立教育科學、參與社會重建。但由於杜威對教育的性質及力量有著更深刻的瞭解，他的教育藍圖更加強調經驗成長、科學方法、與民主目標－這三者是其他派別無法統整良好甚至未曾顧及的。

From the 1890s to the 1950s, the American society went through a dramatic transformation. Progressive education was born in response to the needs of modern society, and the renowned philosopher John Dewey quickly rose to leadership in the great movement. Starting with the development of Dewey's philosophical career and the insights shown in his educational theory, this study employed the multiple meanings of ”progress” to clarify the major differences between Dewey and various factions within progressive education. It was found that Dewey indeed held certain views similar to those of other progressive educators, such as rejecting traditional education, advocating manual training, emphasizing the child's freedom, establishing a science of education, and participating in social reconstruction. However, owing to his much deeper understanding of the nature and power of education, Dewey put remarkable stress on experiential growth, scientific methods, and democratic goals in education, which others could hardly integrate well or even imagine.

1. Addams, J.(1961).Twenty years at Hull-House.New York:Signet Classic.
2. Archambault, R. D.(ed.)(1966).Dewey on education: Appraisals.New York:Random House.
3. Baker, M. C.(1965).Foundations of John Dewey's educational theory.New York:Atherton Press.
4. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1977).John Dewey: The middle works, 1899-1924.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
5. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1976).John Dewey: The middle works, 1899-1924.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
6. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1976).John Dewey: The middle works, 1899-1924.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
7. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1985).John Dewey: The middle works, 1899-1924.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
8. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1988).John Dewey: The middle works, 1899-1924.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
9. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1972).John Dewey: The early works, 1882-1898.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
10. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1986).John Dewey: The later works, 1925-1953.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
11. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1984).John Dewey: The later works, 1925-1953.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
12. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1987).John Dewey: The later works, 1925-1953.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
13. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1985).John Dewey: The middle works, 1899-1924.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
14. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1988).John Dewey: The later works, 1925-1953.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
15. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1984).John Dewey: The later works, 1925-1953.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
16. Boydston, J. A.(ed.)(1991).John Dewey: The later works, 1925-1953.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
17. Counts, G. S.(1978).Dare the School Build a New Social Order?.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
18. Cremin, L. A.(1961).The transformation of the school: Progressivism in American education, 1876-1957.New York:Knopf.
19. Deegan, M. J.(1988).Jane Addams and the men of the Chicago school, 1892-1918.New Brunswick, NJ:Transaction Books.
20. Dewey, J.(1997).How we think.New York:Dover.
21. Dewey, J.(1966).Democracy and education.New York:The Free Press.
22. Diggins, J. P.(1994).The promise of pragmatism: Modernism and the crisis of knowledge and authority.Chicago:The University of Chicago Press.
23. Dworkin, M. S.(ed.)(1959).Dewey on education.New York:Teachers College Press.
24. Farrell, J. C.(1967).Beloved lady: A history of Jane Addams' ideas on reform and peace.Baltimore:The Johns Hopkins Press.
25. Feffer, A.(1993).The Chicago pragmatists and American progressivism.Ithaca, NY:Cornell University Press.
26. Graham, P. A.(1967).Progressive education: From arcady to academe.New York:Teachers College Press.
27. Kellum, R.(1983).The influence of Francis Wayland Parker's pedagogy on the pedagogy of John Dewey.Journal of Thought,18(1),77-91.
28. Kliebard, H. M.(2004).The struggle for the American curriculum, 1893-1958.New York:Routledge Falmer.
29. Lagemann, E. C.(1996).Experimenting with education: John Dewey and Ella Flagg Young at the University of Chicago.American Journal of Education,104(3),171-185.
30. Martin, J.(2002).The education of John Dewey: A biography.New York:Columbia University Press.
31. Miller, R.(1997).What are schools for? Holistic education in American culture.Brandon, VT:Holistic education Press.
32. Ravitch, D.(1983).The troubled crusade: American education, 1945-1980.New York:Basic Books.
33. Ryan, A.(1995).John Dewey and the high tide of American liberalism.New York:Norton.
34. Schilpp, P. A.(ed.),Hahn, L. E.(ed.)(1989).The philosophy of John Dewey.La Salle, IL:Open Court.
35. Webb, L. D.,McCarthy, M. M.(1998).Ella Flagg Young: Pioneer of democratic school administration.Educational Administration Quarterly,34(2),223-242.
36. Westbrook, R. B.(1991).John Dewey and American democracy.Ithaca, NY:Cornell University.
37. Zilversmit, A.(1993).Changing schools: Progressive education theory and practice, 1930-1960.Chicago:The University of Chicago Press.
38. 李恭蔚(1999)。美國社會改革家珍‧亞當斯的教育理念與貢獻。屏東師院學報，12，199-219。
39. 李園會(1977)。杜威的教育思想研究。臺北市:文史哲。
40. 林逢祺編、洪仁進編(2008)。教師哲學：哲學中的教師圖像。臺北市:五南。

1. 戴晨修,黃儒傑,洪梅芳(2019)。十二年國民基本教育課程之中學實地情境學習理念與實施。中等教育，70(1)，37-50。
2. 單文經(2021)。十九世紀末至二十世紀前半葉美國進步教育流派分法與Dewey的流派歸屬。教育研究集刊，67(3)，43-93。
3. 宋明娟(2019)。杜威實驗學校的課程理念與實踐。教育研究集刊，65(1)，1-41。