人權框架下的身心障礙者就業經驗初探

An Exploration of the Experiences of Persons with Disabilities in the Labor Market Based on a Human Rights Framework

江雅婷(Ya-Ting Chiang)；陳心怡(Hsin-Yi Chen)；唐宜楨(I-Chen Tang)

身心障礙者 ； 工作權 ； 身心障礙者權利公約 ； 合理調整 ； People with disabilities ； the right to work ； the United Nations on the Rights of People Disabilities ； reasonable accommodation

身心障礙研究季刊

19卷3&4期（2021 / 12 / 01）

132 - 156

繁體中文

目的：本研究以聯合國《身心障礙者權利公約》為研究框架，試圖瞭解身心障礙者工作權保障在勞動參與過程的經驗。方法：本研究透過方便取樣與滾雪球方式，邀請6名身心障礙者以及6名提供身心障礙者就業支持服務的工作者進行深度訪談。結果：藉由訪談資料，本研究發現身心障礙權利知能的掌握與意識覺察是重要的，如對身心障礙者權利有所覺察，較能將平等、不歧視等基本原則運用在實務層面；再者，身心障礙者工作權實踐的結構性社會阻礙仍舊存在，無論是求職或者就業過程中，雇主、同事、工作任務與工作環境等因素可能成為阻礙身心障礙者就業機會的獲取以及就業穩定性；最後，使能者對身心障礙者就業扮演關鍵角色，不僅可以促進工作任務、態度與環境等合理調整，更能極大化身心障礙者工作潛能的發揮。結論：臺灣身心障礙典範的發展已從福利觀點轉向身心障礙權利觀點，期待有意願工作且有工作能力的身心障礙者能透過就業形式與職場的合理調整，進行有意義的社會參與，促進良善的循環，以成為有尊嚴的個體。

Purpose: By adopting the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities as the research framework, the aim of this study is to understand the participation experience of persons with disabilities in the labor market. Methods: Six persons with disabilities and six workers who provide employment support services to persons with disabilities were invited to participate in in-depth interviews through purposive and snowball sampling. Results: Based on these interviews, employment service workers and job redesign specialists enhance disability rights awareness by implementing and advocating anti-discrimination and equality principles for persons with disabilities who are seeking job opportunities. In addition, while seeking job opportunities or participating in the labor market, persons with disabilities encounter various social and structural obstacles. From these results, reasonable adjustments are needed in terms of policies, job descriptions, attitudes of employers and coworkers, and the environment to reduce the limitations on the innate or acquired talents or expertise of persons with disabilities and to maximize their potential at work. Conclusion: The disability paradigm in Taiwan has shifted from the welfare perspective to the disability rights perspective. It is expected that persons with disabilities who are willing to work and are capable of work can participate meaningfully in society and gain dignity through employment.

1. 王敏行,黃湘羚,陳勃罕,張牧耘,盧冠甫,陳妤庭(2020)。動機式晤談於身心障礙者職業重建服務之應用探討。特殊教育季刊，155，1-10。
   連結：
2. 吳蓉璧(2014)。身心障礙者支持性就業政策目標之研究。中國行政評論，20，185-210。
   連結：
3. 林金定,嚴嘉楓,陳美花(2005)。質性研究方法－訪談模式與實施步驟分析。身心障礙研究季刊，3，122-136。
   連結：
4. 林昭吟,孫健忠(2014)。我國公部門身心障礙者定額進用實施之多面向檢視。東吳社會工作學報，26，47-75。
   連結：
5. 林昭吟,鄭雅之,張恒豪(2018)。當〔不標準的病人〕遇到醫療專業體制：身心障礙者就醫經驗的質化分析。臺大社工學刊，38，99-145。
   連結：
6. 林真平(2019)。身心障礙者職業重建個案管理員與支持性就業服務員的專業知識重要性及具備程度。特殊教育研究學刊，44，31-57。
   連結：
7. 林靖文(2017)。職務再設計對在職身心障礙者工作的影響。特殊教育發展期刊，63，69-78。
   連結：
8. 張恆豪(2007)。特殊教育與障礙社會學：一個理論的反省。教育與社會研究，13，71-94。
   連結：
9. 陳心怡,唐宜楨(2020)。特殊教育教師對身心障礙學生參與權實踐之研究。身心障礙研究，18，159-174。
   連結：
10. 陳怡伃,李宜興,王文娟,嚴嘉楓(2015)。花蓮縣身心障礙者就業需求與工作動機。身心障礙研究，13，255-267。
    連結：
11. Barlow, J. H.,Wright, C. C.,Williams, B.,Keat, A.(2001).Work disability among people with ankylosing spondylitis.Arthritis and Rheumatism,45(5),424-429.
12. Blanck, P.(2020).Disability inclusive employment and the accommodation principle: Emerging issues in research, policy, and law.Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation,30,505-510.
13. Callander, E.,Schofield, D. J.(2013).The relationship between employment and social participation among Australians with a disabling chronic health condition: Across-sectional analysis.BMJ Open,3(1),e002054.
14. de Beco, G.(2020).Intersectionality and disability in international human rights law.The International Journal of Human Rights,24(5),593-614.
15. Degener, T.(2016).A Human Rights Model of Disability.Routledge Handbook of Disability Law and Human Rights,New York:
16. Degener, T.(2017).A New Human Rights Model of Disability.The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities,Cham:
17. Ferraina, S.(2012).,未出版
18. Fiala, E.(2018).A brave new world of work through the lens of disability.Societies,8(2),27.
19. Foley, B.(2019).Intersectionality: A Marxist critique.New Labor Forum,28(3),10-13.
20. Galvão, M. F.,Lemos, A. H. D. C.,Cavazotte, F. D. S.(2018).Revisiting the mainstream: The meaning of work for people with acquired disabilities.RAM, Revista de Administração Mackenzie,19,1-30.
21. Imms, C.,Granlund, M.,Wilson, P. H.,Steenbergen, B.,Rosenbaum, P. L.,Gordon, A. M.(2017).Participation, both a means and an end: A conceptual analysis of processes and outcomes in childhood disability.Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology,59(1),16-25.
22. Kam, P. K.(2021).From the strengths perspective to an empowerment-participation-strengths model in social work practice.The British Journal of Social Work,51,1425-1444.
23. Kim, E. J.,Skinner, T.,Parish, S. L.(2020).A study on intersectional discrimination in employment against disabled women in the UK.Disability & Society,35(5),715-737.
24. Reinders Folmer, C. P.,Mascini, P.,Van der Veen, R. J.(2020).Evaluating social investment in disability policy: Impact of measures for activation, support, and facilitation on employment of disabled persons in 22 European countries.Social Policy & Administration,54(5),792-812.
25. Richard, S.,Hennekam, S.(2020).When can a disability quota system empower disabled individuals in the workplace? The case of France.Work, Employment and Society,35(13),1-19.
26. Saunders, S. L.,Nedelec, B.(2014).What work means to people with work disability: A scoping review.Journal of occupational rehabilitation,24(1),100-110.
27. Saunders, S.,Nedelec, B.,MacEachen, E.(2018).Work remains meaningful despite time out of the workplace and chronic pain.Disability and Rehabilitation,40(18),2144-2151.
28. Sun, N. Y.(2019).On the road to equal enjoyment of human rights for persons with disabilities: The development of domestic laws in Taiwan and their dialogue with the CRPD.Taiwan and International Human Rights,Singapore:
29. Swain, J.(Ed.),French, S.(Ed.),Barnes, C.(Ed.),Thomas, C.(Ed.)(2004).Disabling Barriers-Enabling Environments.London:SAGE.
30. White, G. W.,Lloyd Simpson, J.,Gonda, C.,Ravesloot, C.,Coble, Z.(2010).Moving from independence to interdependence: A conceptual model for better understanding community participation of centers for independent living consumers.Journal of Disability Policy Studies,20(4),233-240.
31. 人權公約施行監督聯盟 (2021)。合理調整專區。2021年7月21日，取自https://covenantswatch.org.tw/reasonable-accommodations/
32. 吳麗珍,黃惠滿,李浩銑(2014)。方便取樣和立意取樣之比較。護理雜誌，61，105-111。
33. 李雅惠(2013)。嘉義縣，中正大學法律學系碩士班。
34. 法務部(2021)。全國法規資料庫《身心障礙者權利公約施行法》。2021年6月30日，取自https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=D0050194
35. 法務部 (2021)。全國法規資料庫《身心障礙者權利公約》。2021年6月30日，取自https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=Y0000064
36. 法務部(2021)。全國法規資料庫《身心障礙者權益保障法》。2021年6月30日，取自https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?PCode=D0050046
37. 孫迺翔（編）,廖福特（編）(2017).身心障礙者權利公約.台北:財團法人台灣新世紀文教基金會.
38. 張恆豪,顏詩耕(2011)。從慈善邁向權利：臺灣身心障礙福利的發展與挑戰。社區發展季刊，133，402-416。
39. 傅莉珺(2013)。台中市，東海大學社會工作學系。
40. 勞動部 (2021)。108年身心障礙者勞動狀況調查。2021年7月21日，取自https://statdb.mol.gov.tw/html/svy08/0841menu.htm
41. 蔡佳穎,陳政智(2010)。以〔損傷〕與〔障礙〕並重的社會模式探討身心障礙者生活品質。社區發展季刊，131，516-529。
42. 衛生福利部社會及家庭署 (2020)。身心障礙者權利公約（CRPD）第二次國家報告。2021年6月30日，取自https://crpd.sfaa.gov.tw/BulletinCtrl?func=getBulletin&p=b_2&c=D&bulletinId=1452

1. 林秀珍,吳采俞(2023)。從生態系統觀點探討肌萎症患者之職涯韌性與韌力。輔導與諮商學報，45(1)，99-134。