题名

Who Wins and Who Loses in Transparent Markets? Daily and Intraday Analysis of Taiwan Stock Market

并列篇名

在更透明的市場誰獲益？誰損失？臺灣股票市場日間與日內之實證分析

DOI

10.29629/TEFP.201103.0004

作者

陳秀桂(Hsiu-Kuei Chen)；謝舒帆(Shu-Fan Hsieh)；馬黛(Tai Ma)

关键词

執行成本 ； 價格衝擊 ； 執行差額 ； 交易前透明度 ； 日內分析 ； Execution cost ； Price impact ； Implementation shortfall ； Pre-trade transparency ； Intraday analysis

期刊名称

臺灣經濟預測與政策

卷期/出版年月

41卷2期（2011 / 03 / 01）

页次

127 - 178

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

本研究探討交易前透明度增加對於下市價單與限價單之法人、散戶福利變化之影響。爲瞭解投資人福利變化與市場透明度之關聯性，首先必須先驗證投資人因應市場透明度增加之行爲調整（下單積極性與委託單規模調整）。本研究發現散戶與法人在市場透明度增加後提供流動性之意願皆增加；散戶投遞限價單與市價單時之行爲皆更爲積極，且投遞更大規模之委託單；但法人相較於散戶因應透明度增加之行爲調整較爲保守，且投遞較小規模之委託單。本文以執行差額法(implementation shortfall)衡量投資人之福利；執行差額爲價格衝擊與機會成本之加權平均。實證結果顯示，對於流動性有需求之法人與散戶（特別是法人）在交易前透明度增加後獲益最多，然而散戶在更透明之市場提供流動性時反而蒙受損失。本文日內分析進一步顯示交易前透明度增加後，散戶在接近收盤時段提供流動性蒙受之損失最大；相反的，投資人（法人與散戶）於接近收盤時段對流動性有需求者因透明度增加獲益最多。
英文摘要

This paper provides evidence regarding the welfare effect of pre-trade transparency according to investor and order type. In order to appreciate the manner in which welfare varies with market transparency, it is necessary to examine investors’ behavioral adjustments (aggressiveness and order size adjustments) with respect to market transparency. We find that both individual and institutional investors are more willing to supply liquidity following the enhancement of market transparency. Although individual investors behave more aggressively and submit larger orders when they supply and demand liquidity, institutional investors are relatively more conservative and submit smaller orders in an open environment. The welfare of investors is measured in terms of implementation shortfall, which is the weighted average of price impacts and opportunity costs. Our main conclusion is that both institutional and individual investors, but especially institutional investors, who demand immediacy benefit from pre-trade transparency; however, individual investors who supply liquidity lose on account of pre-trade transparency. Further, intraday analysis indicates that although transparency enhancement is most detrimental for individual investors providing liquidity during the period approaching market close, it is most beneficial for institutional and individual investors demanding liquidity during the period approaching the close of markets.
主题分类 社會科學 > 經濟學
参考文献
  1. Pascual, R. and D. Veredas (2008), "What Pieces of Limit Order Book Information Matter in Explaining the Behavior of Aggressive and Patient Traders?" Working Paper, Universidad de las Islas Baleares.
  2. Cao, C., O. Hansch, and X. Wang (2008), "Order Placement Strategies in a Pure Limit Order Book Market," Working Paper, Pennsylvania State University.
  3. Cao, C., O. Hansch, and X. Wang (2007), "The Informational Content of an Open Limit Order Book," Working Paper, Pennsylvania State University.
  4. Dennis, P. and J. Weston (2001), "Who's Informed: An Analysis of Information and Ownership Structure," Working Paper, Rice University.
  5. Gerke,W., S. Arneth, R. Bosch, and C. Syha (1997), "Open and Closed Order Book and Its Effect on Liquidity and Volatility-Market Microstructure of Stock Exchanges in Experiments and in the Neuer Market,"Working Paper, Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg.
  6. Gajewski, J. F. and C. Gresse (2003), "Trading Cost Analysis: A Comparison of Euronext Paris and the London Stock Exchange," Working Paper, Université Paris XII.
  7. Pardo, A. and R. Pascual (2003), "On the Hidden Side of Liquidity," Working Paper,University of Valencia.
  8. Al-Suhaibani, M. and L. Kryzanowski (2001), "Limit vs. Market Order Trading on the Saudi Stock Market," Working Paper, EFMA 2001 Lugano Meetings.
  9. Aitken, M. J.,Berkman, H.,Mak, D.(2001).The Use of Undisclosed Limit Orders on the Australian Stock Exchange.Journal of Banking and Finance,25,1589-1603.
  10. Alangar, S.,Bathala, C.,Rao, R.(1999).The Effect of Institutional Interest on the Information Content of Dividend-Change Announcements.Journal of Financial Research,22,429-448.
  11. Anand, A.,Chakravarty, S.,Martell, T.(2005).Empirical Evidence on the Evolution of Liquidity:Choice of Market Versus Limit Orders by Informed and Uninformed Traders.Journal of Financial Markets,8,289-309.
  12. Anand, A.,Weaver, D. G.(2004).Can Order Exposure Be Mandated?.Journal of Financial Markets,7(4),405-426.
  13. Back, K.,Cao, C. H.,Willard, G. A.(2000).Imperfect Competition among Informed Traders.Journal of Finance,55,2117-2155.
  14. Baruch, S.(2005).Who Benefits from an Open Limit-Order Book?.Journal of Business,78,1267-1306.
  15. Bertsimas, D.,Lo, A. W.(1998).Optimal Control of Execution Costs.Journal of Financial Markets,1(1),1-50.
  16. Biais, B.,Hillion, P.,Spatt, C.(1995).An Empirical Analysis of the Limit Order Book and the Order Flow in the Paris Bourse.Journal of Finance,50,1655-1689.
  17. Bloomfield, R.,O''Hara, M.(2005).The Make or Take Decision in an Electronic Market: Evidence on the Evolution of Liquidity.Journal of Financial Economics,75,165-199.
  18. Bloomfield, R.,O''Hara, M.(2000).Can Transparent Market Survive?.Journal of Financial Economics,55,425-459.
  19. Boehmer, E.,Saar, G.,Yu, L.(2005).Lifting the Veil: An Analysis of Pre-Trade Transparency at the NYSE.Journal of Finance,60,783-815.
  20. Bortoli, L.,Frino, A.,Jarnecic, E.,Johnstone, D.(2006).Limit Order Book Transparency, Execution Risk and Market Liquidity.The Journal of Futures Markets,26,1147-1167.
  21. Chakravarty, S.(2001).Stealth Trading: Which Traders' Trades Move Stock Prices?.Journal of Financial Economics,61,289-307.
  22. Chordia, T.,Roll, R.,Subrahamanyam, A.(2000).Commonality in Liquidity.Journal of Financial Economics,56,3-28.
  23. Chung, K. H.,Chuwonganant, C.(2009).Transparency and Market Quality: Evidence from Super Montage.Journal of Financial Intermediation,18,93-111.
  24. Comerton-Forde, C.,Rydge, J.(2006).The Current State of Asia-Pacific Stock Exchange: A Critical Review ofMarket Design.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,15,18-35.
  25. Conrad, J.,Johnson, K. M.,Wahal, S.(2003).Institutional Trading and Alternative Trading Systems.Journal of Financial Economics,70,99-134.
  26. Copeland, T. E.,Galai, D.(1983).Information Effects on the Bid-Ask Spread.The Journal of Finance,38(5),1457-1469.
  27. Easley, D.,O''Hara, M.(1987).Price, Trade Size and Information in Securities Markets.Journal of Financial Economics,19,69-90.
  28. Flood, M. D.,Huisman, R.,Koedijk, K. G.,Mahieu, R. J.(1999).Quote Disclosure and Price Discovery in Multiple-Dealer Financial Markets.Review of Financial Studies,12,37-59.
  29. Foster, F. D.,Viswanathan, S.(1996).Strategic TradingWhen Agents Forecast the Forecasts of Others.Journal of Finance,51,1437-1478.
  30. Friedman, D.(1993).Privileged Traders and Asset Market Efficiency:A Laboratory Study.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,28,515-534.
  31. Griffiths, M.,Smith, B.,Turnbull, D.,White, R. W.(2000).The Costs and the Determinants of Order Aggressiveness.Journal of Financial Economics,56,65-88.
  32. Huang, Y. C.,Chen, P. L.,Cheng, Y. J.(2007).The Impact of New Trading Rules on Market Performance:The Case of Taiwan Stock Exchange.Review of Securities and Futures Markets,19(2),153-190.
  33. Jones, C. M.,Lipson, M. L.(1999).Execution Costs of Institutional Equity Orders.Journal of Financial Intermediation,8,123-140.
  34. Keim, D. B.,Madhavan, A.(1997).Transactions Costs and Investment Style:An Inter-Exchange Analysis of Institutional Equity Trades.Journal of Financial Economics,46,265-292.
  35. Kyle, A.(1985).Continuous Auctions and Insider Trading.Econometrica,53,1315-1335.
  36. Lee, Y. T.,Liu, Y. J.,Wang, J. Y.,Chen, W. J.,Lai, W. H.(2009).Limit Order Book Transparency and Market Quality.Review of Securities and Futures Markets,21(1),51-86.
  37. Ma, T.,Lin, Y.,Chen, H. K.(2008).Are Investors More Aggressive in Transparent Markets?.Asia-Pacific Journal of Financial Studies,37,343-380.
  38. Madhavan, A.(2000).Market Microstructure:A Survey.Journal of Financial Markets,3,205-258.
  39. Madhavan, A.(1996).Security Prices and Market Transparency.Journal of Financial Intermediation,5,255-283.
  40. Madhavan, A.,Porter, D.,Weaver, D.(2005).Should Securities Markets Be Transparent?.Journal of Financial Markets,8,265-287.
  41. O''Hara, M.(1995).Market Microstructure Theory.Cambridge, MA:Basil Blackwell.
  42. Pagano, M.,Röell, A.(1996).Transparency and Liquidity:A Comparison of Auction and DealerMarkets with Informed Trading.Journal of Finance,51,579-611.
  43. Perold, A.(1988).The Implementation Shortfall:Paper versus Reality.Journal of Portfolio Management,14,4-9.
  44. Ranaldo, R.(2004).Order Aggressiveness in Limit Order Book Markets.Journal of Financial Market,7,53-74.
  45. Smith, B. F.,Alasdair, D.,Turnbull, S.,White, R. W.(2001).Upstairs Market for Principal and Agency Trades:Analysis of Adverse Information and Price Effect.The Journal of Finance,56,1723-1746.
  46. Szewczyk, S.,Tsetsekos, G.,Varma, R.(1992).Institutional Ownership and the Liquidity of Common Stock Offerings.The Financial Review,27,211-225.
  47. Wagner, W. H.,Edwards, M.(1993).Best Execution.Financial Analysts Journal,49,65-71.
  48. Wu, C.,Zhang,W.(2002).Trade Disclosure, Information Learning and Securities Market Performance.Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting,18,21-38.
print cancel