國小學童參與科展的歷程、內在動機與科技創造力成長的縱貫性分析

The Longitudinal Analysis of Elementary School Pupils' Science Competition Experience, Intrinsic Motivation and Creativity Growth

蕭佳純(Chia-Chun Hsiao)

科學展覽 ； 動機 ； 創造力 ； 階層線性模式 ； 縱貫性分析 ； creativity ； hierarchical linear modeling ； longitudinal analysis ； motivation ； science fair

教育實踐與研究

27卷2期（2014 / 12 / 01）

33 - 66

繁體中文

本研究分別以參加科展及未參加科展的學生為研究對象，目的在於了解經過相關科展訓練的參加科展學生，以及未有任何相關訓練的未參加科展學生，在經過四次長期追蹤調查之後的創造力成長歷程；除此之外，更進一步探討內在動機分別對兩組學生科技創造力發展的影響。樣本來源是國立臺灣科學教育館第41至50屆參展資料中選取自願參與的教師，透過教師尋找對應指導的學生，其中參展學生為208名，非參展學生為871名，使用的工具則為科技創造力測驗及內在動機量表。利用階層線性模式的成長模型分析後發現，有無參加科展學生的科技創造力在開始階段就呈現個別差異且成長趨勢呈現不同發展。其中有參加科展的學生為先下後上的發展趨勢，然無參加科展的學生則為先上後下的發展趨勢，而且參加科展訓練的學生科技創造力低於初始點。而在內在動機方面，有參加科展學生的內在動機對開始階段的創造力為正向影響，且對科技創造力的成長加速度有正向調節效果；反之，內在動機則對未參加科展的學生無任何影響。依據上述研究結果，本研究進一步提出相關建議。

Comparing students who have participated in Taiwan International Science Fair and those who have not, this study aims to understand the creativity development between the ones with creativity trainings for participating in the Fair and the ones who did not participate in science fair and did not receive any related trainings. Furthermore, this study intends to investigate the effects of intrinsic motivation on the development of creativity between the two groups. From National Taiwan Science Education Center, 208 student participants of the 41^(st)-50^(th) Fair and 871 non-participants were sampled through their teachers who voluntarily participated in this study. With growth model analysis in Hierarchical Linear Modeling, individual differences in scientific creativity between science fair participants and non-participants were found and its growth was developed distinctively. Students who participated in Taiwan International Science Fair presented downward development in scientific creativity and then upward, while the non-participants revealed upward then downward development. In regard to intrinsic motivation, science fair participants showed positive effects of Self-efficacy and Internal value on creativity, while their intrinsic motivation presents moderating effects on the rapid growth of creativity. Contrarily, intrinsic motivation did not appear to have any effects on non-participants. Based on the research outcomes, relevant suggestions are further proposed.

1. Wang, C. W.,Chen, M.,Horng, R. W.,Huang, C. Y.,Li, H. P.(2004).Case studies of implementation of Web-based group decision support system and creativity training in organizations.Taiwan Management Journal,4(3),357-378.
   連結：
2. 江美惠(2005)。創造性問題解決教學方案對資優學生創造力及問題解決能力影響之研究。資優教育研究，5(2)，83-106。
   連結：
3. 李堅萍、游光昭、朱益賢(2009)。國中科技教育運用 Teresa M. Amabile 工作動機原則與自我效能激發策略之研究。新竹教育大學教育學報，25(2)，129-159。
   連結：
4. 林偉文(2006)。學校創意守門人對創意教學與創造力培育態度與教師創意教學之關係。教育學刊，27，69-92。
   連結：
5. 洪素蘋、黃宏宇、林珊如(2008)。重要他人回饋影響創意生活經驗？以模式競爭方式檢驗創意自我效能與創意動機的中介效果。教育心理學報，90，303-322。
   連結：
6. 陳玉樹(2008)。創造力訓練課程成效分析：準 Solomon 四組設計。課程與教學，11(4)，187-212。
   連結：
7. 陳玉樹、周志偉(2009)。目標導向對創造力訓練效果之影響：HLM 成長模式分析。課程與教學季刊，12(2)，19-46。
   連結：
8. 陳玉樹、胡夢鯨(2008)。任務動機與組織創新氣候對成人教師創意教學表現之影響：階層線性模式分析。教育心理學報，40(2)，179-198。
   連結：
9. 葉玉珠(2004)。「科技創造力測驗」的發展與常模的建立。測驗學刊，51(2)，127-162。
   連結：
10. 蔡執仲、段曉林、靳知勤(2007)。巢狀探究模式對國二學生理化學習動機影響之探討。科學教育學刊，15(2)，119-144。
    連結：
11. 蕭佳純(2011)。學生創造力影響因素之研究：三層次分析架構。特殊教育學報，33，151-178。
    連結：
12. 教育部（2006）。九年一貫課程綱要。中華民國 95 年 3 月 27 日台國（二）字第0950030367C 號令修正。台北：教育部。
13. Amabile, T. M.(1996).Creativity in context: Update to the social psychology of creativity.Bouler, CO:Westview.
14. Amabile, T. M.,Hill, K. G.,Hennessey, B. A.,Tighe, E. M.(1994).The work preference inventory: Assessing intrinsic and extrinsic motivational orientations.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,66(5),950-967.
15. Ambrose, M. L.,Kulik, C. T.(2001).Old friends, new faces: Motivation research in the 1990s.Journal of Management,25(3),251-292.
16. Baldwin, T. T.,Ford, K. J.(1988).Transfer of training: A review and directions for future research.Personnel Psychology,41,63-105.
17. Beghetto, R. A.(2006).Creative self-efficacy: Correlates in middle and secondary students.Creativity Research Journal,18(4),447-457.
18. Benedek, M.,Fink, A.,Neubauer, A. C.(2006).Enhancement of ideational fluency by means of computer-based training.Creativity Research Journal,18(3),317-328.
19. Besançon, M.,Lubart, T.(2008).Differences in the development of creative competencies in children schooled in diverse learning environments.Learning and Individual Differences,18(4),38-389.
20. Birdi, K. S.(2005).No Idea? Evaluating the effectiveness of creativity training.Journal of European Industrial Training,29(2),102-111.
21. Bryk, A. S.,Raudenbush, S.W.(1992).Hierarchical linear models in social and behavioral research: Applications and data analysis methods.Newbury Park, CA:Sage Publications.
22. Burke, L. A.,Hutchins, H. M.(2007).Training transfer: An integrative literature review.Human Resource Management Review,6(3),263-296.
23. Caro, D. H.,McDonald, J. T.,Willms, J. D.(2009).Socio-economic status and academic achievement trajectories from childhood to adolescence.Journal of Education,32(3),558-590.
24. Choi, J. N.(2004).Individual and contextual predictors of creativity performance: The mediating role of psychological processes.Creativity Research Journal,16(2),187-199.
25. Claxton, A. F.,Pannells, T. C.,Rhoads, P. A.(2005).Developmental trends in the creativity of school-age children.Creativity Research Journal,17(4),327-335.
26. Cohen, D.,Raudenbush, S.,Ball, D.(2003).Resources, instruction, and research.Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis,25(2),1-24.
27. Colquitt, J. A.,LePine, J. A.,Noe, R. A.(2000).Toward an integrative theory of training motivation: A meta-analytic path analysis of 20 years of research.Journal of Applied Psychology,85(5),678-707.
28. Cramond, B.,Matthews-Morgan, J.,Bandalos, D.,Zuo, L.(2005).A report on the 40-Year follow-up of the Torrance test of creative thinking: Alive and well in the new millennium.Gifted Child Quarterly,49(4),283-291.
29. Cropley, A. J.(2001).Creativity in education: Producing effective novelty.Report Review,21(4),253-260.
30. Csikszentmihalyi, M.(1996).Creativity: Flow and the psychological discovery and invention.New York, NY:HarperCollins.
31. Daniel, M.(2007).Can creativity be improved by an attention-broadening training program? An exploratory study focusing on team sports.Creativity Research Journal,19(2-3),281-291.
32. Dresel, M.(2001).A longitudinal study of Dweck's motivation-process-model in the classroom.Psychologische Beiträge,43(1),129-152.
33. Elliot, A. J.,McGregor, H. A.(2001).A 2×2 achievement goal framework.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,80(3),501-519.
34. Elliot, A. J.,Trash, T. M.(2001).Achievement goals and the hierarchical model of achievement motivation.Educational Psychology Review,12,139-156.
35. Eris, O.,Chachra, D.,Chen, C.,Sheppard, S.,Ludlow, L.,Rosca, C.,Bailey, T.,Toye, G.(2010).Outcomes of a longitudinal administration of the persistence in engineering survey.Journal of Engineering Education,99(4),371-395.
36. Esquivel, M.(1995).Teacher behaviors that foster creativity.Educational Psychology Review,7(2),185-202.
37. Feldhusen, J. F.,Clinkenbeard, P. R.(1986).Creativity instructional materials: A review of research.Journal of Creative Behavior,20,153-182.
38. Fleith, D. S.(2000).Teacher and student perceptions of creativity in the classroom environment.Report Review,22(3),148-153.
39. Florida, R.(2004).Americas looming creativity crisis.Harvard business review,37,122-134.
40. Garaigordobil, M.(2006).Intervention in creativity with children aged 10and 11 years: Impact of a play program on verbal and graphic-figural creativity.Creativity Research Journal,18(3),329-345.
41. Goldstein, H.(1995).Multilevel statistical models.New York, NY:Halstead Press.
42. Gruber, H. E.,Wallace, D. B.(2001).Creative work: The case of Charles Darwin.American Psychologist,61(4),346-349.
43. Harackiewicz, J. M.,Barron, K. E.,Tauer, J. M.,Elliot, A. J.(2002).Predicting success in college: A longitudinal study of achievement goals and ability measures as predictor interest and performance from freshman year through graduation.Journal of Education Psychology,94(3),562-575.
44. Hunsaker, S. L.(2005).Outcomes of creativity training programs.The Gifted Child Quarterly,49(4),292-299.
45. Kahai, S. S.,Sosik, J. J.,Avolio, B. J.(2003).Effects of leadership style, anonymity, and rewards on creativity-relevant processes and outcomes in an electronic meeting system context.Leadership Quarterly,14(4),499-524.
46. Kharkhurin, A. V.(2009).The role of Bilingualism in creative performance on divergent thinking and invented Alien creatures tests.Journal of Behavior,43,59-71.
47. Kim, T. Y.,Hon, A. H. Y.,Crant, J. M.(2009).Proactive personality, employee creativity, and newcomer outcomes: A longitudinal study.J Bus Psychol,24,93-103.
48. Klein, H. J.,Noe, R. A.,Wang, C.(2006).Motivation to learn and course outcomes: The impact of delivery mode, learning goal orientation, and perceived barriers and enablers.Personnel Psychology,59,665-702.
49. Ma, H.(2006).A synthetic analysis of the effectiveness of single components and packages in creativity training programs.Creativity Research Journal,18(4),435-446.
50. Mayer, R. E.(2008).Applying the science of learning: Evidence-based principles for the design of multimedia instruction.American Psychologist,63(8),760-769.
51. Mayer, R. E.,Johnson, C. I.(2010).Adding instructional features that promote learning in a game-like environment.Journal of Educational Computing Research,42,241-265.
52. Michael, D. M.,Samuel, T. H.,Dawn, L. E.,Katrina, E. B.,Stephen, T.(2007).Developing leaders for creative efforts: A domain-based approach to leadership development.Human Resource Management Review,17(4),402-417.
53. Moneta, G. B.,Siu, C. M. Y.(2002).Trait intrinsic and extrinsic motivations, academic performance, and creativity in Hong Kong college students.Journal of College Student Development,43,664-683.
54. Mortagy, Y.,Boghikian-Whitby, S.(2010).A longitudinal comparative study of student perceptions in online education.Journal of E-Learning and Learning Object,6,23-44.
55. Oldham, G. R.,Cummings, A.(1996).Employee creativity: Personal and contextual factors at work.Academy of Management Journal,39(3),607-634.
56. Osburn, H. K.,Mumford, M. D.(2006).Creativity and Planning: Training interventions to develop creative problem-solving skills.Creativity Research Journal,18(2),173-190.
57. Pintrich, P. R.(2000).Multiple goals, multiple pathways: The role of goal orientation in learning and achievement.Journal of Educational Psychology,92,544-555.
58. Raudenbush, S. W.,Bryk, A. S.(2002).Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
59. Runco, M. A.(1999).A longitudinal study of exceptional giftedness and creativity.Creativity Research Journal,12,161-164.
60. Scott, G.,Leritz, L. E.,Mumford, M. D.(2004).The effectiveness of creativity training: A quantitative review.Creativity Research Journal,16(4),361-388.
61. Scott, G.,Leritz, L. E.,Mumford, M. D.(2004).Types of creativity training: Approaches and their effectiveness.Journal of Creative Behavior,38,149-179.
62. Shalley, C. E.,Perry-Smith, J. E.(2001).Effects of social-psychological factors on creative performance: The role of informational and controlling expected evaluation and modeling experience.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,84,1-22.
63. Shally, C. E.,Zhou, J.,Oldham, G. R.(2004).The effects of personal and contextual characteristics on creativity: Where should we go from here?.Journal of Management,30,933-958.
64. Simonton, D. K.(2000).Creativity: Cognitive, personal, developmental, and social aspects.American Psychologist,55(1),151-158.
65. Smith, G. J.,Carlsson, I. M.(1985).Creativity in middle and late school years.International Journal of Behavioral Development,8,329-343.
66. Smith, G. J.,Carlsson, I. M.(1990).The creative process: A functional model based on empirical studies from early childhood to middle age.Madison, CT:International Universities Press.
67. Starko, A. J.(2000).Creativity in the classroom: School in the curious delight.New York, NY:LEA.
68. Sternberg, R. J.(1996).Successful intelligence.New York, NY:Basic Books.
69. Sternberg, R. J.(1999).Successful intelligence: A broader view of who is smart in school and in life.International Schools Journal,XVII,19-31.
70. Sternberg, R. J.(Ed.)(1999).Handbook of creativity.New York, NY:Cambridge University Press.
71. Sternberg, R. J.,Williams, W. M.(1996).How to develop student creativity.Alexandria, VA:Supervision and Curriculum Development.
72. Talarico, J. M.,Rubin, D. C.(2007).Flashbulb memories are special after all: In phenomenology, not accuracy.Applied Cognitive Psychology,21,557-578.
73. Torrance, E. P.(1968).A longitudinal examination of the fourth grade slump in creativity.Gifted Child Quarterly,12,195-199.
74. Uszyńska-Jarmoc, J.(2007).Self-esteem and different forms of thinking in seven and nine year olds.Early Child Development and Care,177(4),337-348.
75. Wai, J.,Lubinski, D.,Benbow, C. P.(2005).Creativity and occupational accomplishments among intellectually precocious youths: An age 13 to 33 longitudinal study.Journal of Educational Psychology,97(3),484-492.
76. Walker, C. J.(2009).A longitudinal study on the psychological well-being of college students.New York, NJ:Cambridge University Press.
77. Wang, C. W.,Horng, R. Y.(2002).The effects of creative problem solving training on creativity, cognitive type and R&D performance.R & D Management,29(3),247-254.
78. Ward, J.,Thompson-Lake, D.,Ely, R.,Kaminski, F.(2008).Synaesthesia, creativity and art: What is the link?.Journal of Psychology,99,127-141.
79. 吳明雄、許碧珊、張德正、張可立(2009)。高職高技術創造力學生團隊之創造歷程。教育與心理研究，32(2)，1-25。
80. 林碧芳、邱皓政(2008)。創意教學自我效能感量表之編制與相關研究。教育研究與發展期刊，4(1)，141-169。
81. 邱皓政(2000)。工作動機的內生性與外生性：台灣與美國大學生工作動機取向的計量研究。應用心理研究，7，221-252。
82. 陳昭儀(2000)。傑出理化科學家之人格特質及創造歷程之研究。師大學報：科學教育類，45(1)，27-45。
83. 葉玉珠(2006)。創造力教學─過去、現在與未來。台北:心理。
84. 葉玉珠(2005)。科技創造力測驗指導手冊。台北:心理。
85. 詹志禹(2004)。台灣發明家的內在動機、思考取向及環境機會─演化論的觀點。教育與心理研究，27(4)，775-806。
86. 鄭英耀、李育嘉、劉昆夏(2008)。科展績優教師教學行為與學童創造力、問題解決能力之關係。教育與心理研究，31(1)，1-30。

1. 黃博聖,陳學志,陳姵臻,張雨霖,林緯倫,吳清麟(2021)。中文版遠距聯想測驗在創造力研究之應用：回顧與展望。教育實踐與研究，34(1)，1-44。
2. 蕭佳純(2017)。科學創造力課程成效之縱貫性分析。科學教育學刊，25(1)，47-73。
3. 蕭佳純(2017)。在職進修教師創意教學自我效能發展之縱貫性研究。教育科學研究期刊，62(3)，25-55。
4. 蕭佳純(2018)。創造力融入式課程對學生創造力成長趨勢影響之縱貫性分析。課程與教學，21(1)，79-104。