國民小學校長與教師領導者的協作教學領導個案研究

Collaborative Instructional Leadership: A Case study of Elementary School Principal and Teacher Leaders

劉鎮寧(Jen-Ning Liou)

協作教學領導 ； 教師領導 ； 教學領導 ； collaborative instructional leadership ； instructional leadership ； teacher leadership

教育實踐與研究

33卷1期（2020 / 06 / 01）

33 - 69

繁體中文

本研究旨在探討校長與教師領導者所組成的協作教學領導團隊的運作歷程，並探討其成效。本研究採個案研究，以東臺灣一所國民小學為對象，研究參與者包括校長、3位教師領導者、3位學校教師，共計7位。本研究先探討校長與教師領導者所組成的協作教學領導團隊的內部運作，再了解團隊成員與校內教師的互動情形，最後探討在專業上所獲得的成長。本研究藉由訪談文本進行研究資料的分析，研究發現：（1）協作教學領導團隊透過專業共學、共作與任務取向，建立有效的學習機制；（2）不受原職務角色的束縛，係協作教學領導團隊內部運作成功的關鍵因素；（3）角色功能的轉換與發揮並搭配實務導向的推動，係協作教學領導團隊的重要策略；（4）營造公平、真誠、務實的言談情境，能為協作教學領導團隊和校內教師搭建有效的溝通平台；（5）協作教學領導團隊的運作，能同時提升團隊成員及學校教師的專業知能和領導意願。本研究結果可作為校長教學領導實務，校長與教師領導者的協作領導以及提升教師專業發展成效時之參考。

The study investigates the operating process of a collaborative instructional leadership team composed of principal and teacher leaders, and the professional growth of team members and school teachers during this process. This study presents a case study of a public elementary school in Eastern Taiwan. Seven participants from the school were interviewed including the principal, three teacher leaders, and three school teachers and the interview transcriptions were analyzed. This study reached five conclusions: 1) the collaborative instructional leadership team develops an effective learning through professional co-learning, collaboration and task orientation; 2) being non-restricted by the original role is crucial for the success of the collaborative instructional leadership team's internal operation ; 3) the conversion and fulfillment of role functions and the promotion of practice orientation are essential strategies for collaborative instructional leadership teams; 4) creating fair, sincere, and pragmatic conversation situations can build an effective communication platform for collaborative instructional leadership teams and school teachers; 5) the collaborative instructional leadership team's operation can simultaneously improve the professional knowledge and leadership willingness of team members and school teachers. Lastly, this study further proposed suggestions for practical application and future research.

1. 王環鈴, H. -L.,王文科, W. -K.,王智弘, C. -H.(2011)。學校分布式領導與創新經營之研究：以台中市國民小學為例。彰化師大教育學報，20，1-20。
   連結：
2. 張奕華, I. -H.,顏弘欽, H. -C.(2012)。學校分散式領導構面之探析：領導者、追隨者與情境三元互動之檢證。教育實踐與研究，25(2)，225-254。
   連結：
3. 陳偉仁, W. -R.,黃楷茹, K. -J.,吳青陵, C. -L.,呂金燮, C. -H.(2018)。專業學習的建構：「設計本位學習」創新教學之行動探究。教育實踐與研究，31(2)，25-58。
   連結：
4. 鄭志強, C. -C.,胡俊, J.,施瀾, L.(2019)。開展日本授業研究的文化因素—從野中郁次郎的知識創造理論來看。當代教育研究季刊，27(2)，77-109。
   連結：
5. Ansell, C.,Gash, A.(2012).Stewards, mediators, and catalysts: Toward a model of collaborative leadership.The Innovation Journal,17(1),1-21.
6. Aoki, T. T.(2005).Toward curriculum inquiry in a new key.Curriculum in a new key,Mahwah, NJ:
7. Arani, M. R. S., Keisuke, F., & Lassegard, J. P. (2010). ‟Lesson Study” as professional culture in Japanese schools: An historical perspective on elementary classroom practices. Retrieved from JSTOR Web site: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED512090.pdf
8. Australian Research Alliance for Children & Young. (2013). Collaborative leadership. Retrieved from ARACY Web site: https://www.aracy.org.au/publications-resources/area?command=record&id=28 record&id
9. Bruffee, K. A.(1999).Collaborative learning: Higher education, interdependence, and the authority of knowledge.Baltimore, MD:Johns Hopkins University Press.
10. Buckner, K.,McDowelle, J. O.(2000).Developing teacher leaders: Providing enco-uragement, opportunities and support.NASSP Bulletin,84(616),35-41.
11. Camburn, E.,Rowan, B.,Taylor, J. E.(2003).Distributed leadership in schools: The case of elementary schools adopting comprehensive school reform models.Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis,25(4),347-373.
12. Cheung, R.,Reinhardt, T.,Stone, E.,Little, J. W.(2018).Defining teacher leadership: A framework.Phi Delta Kappan,100(3),38-44.
13. Coleman, J. S.,Campbell, E. Q.,Hobson, C. J.,McPartland, J.,Mood, A. M.,Weinfeld, F. D.,York, R. L.(1966).Equality of educational opportunity.Washington, DC:US Government Printing Office.
14. Crowther, F.,Kaagen, S. S.,Ferguson, M.,Hann, L.(2002).Developing teacher leaders: How teacher leadership enhances school success.Thousand Oaks, CA:Corwin Press.
15. Curtis, R.(2013).Finding a new way: Leveraging teacher leadership to meet unprecedented demands.Washington, DC:Aspen Institute.
16. Day, C.,Jacobson, S. L.,Johansson, O.(2011).Leading organizational learning and capacity building.US and cross-national policies, practices, and preparation,Dordrecht, NL:
17. Deal、 T. E.,Peterson, K. D.,林明地（譯）, M. D.(Trans.)(1998).學校領導—平衡邏輯與藝術.台北=Taipei:五南=Wunan.
18. Desimone, L. M.(2009).Improving impact studies of teachers’ professional development: Toward better conceptualizations and measures.Educational Researcher,38(3),181-199.
19. Donaldson, M. L.,Johnson, S. M.,Kirkpatrick, C. L.,Marinell, W. H.,Steele, J. L.,Szczesiul, S. A.(2008).Angling for access, bartering for change: How second-stage teachers experience differentiated roles in schools.Teachers College Record,110(5),1088-1114.
20. DuFour, R.(2002).The learning-centered principal.Educational Leadership,59(8),12-15.
21. Eren, A.,Rakıcıoğlu-Söylemez, A.(2017).Pre-service teachers’ ethical stances on unethical professional behaviors: The roles of professional identity goals and efficacy beliefs.Teaching and Teacher Education,68,114-126.
22. Fiarman, S. E.(2017).Building a schoolwide leadership mindset.Educational Leadership,74(8),22-27.
23. Foriska, T.(1994).The principal as instructional leader: Teaming with teachers for student success.Schools in the Middle,3(3),31-34.
24. Fullan, M. G. (2002). Leadership and sustainability. Retrieved from NASSP Web site: http://michaelfullan.ca/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/13396047460.pdf
25. Goh, S. C.(1998).Toward a learning organization: The strategic building blocks.SAM Advanced Management Journal,63,15-22.
26. Graham, P.,Ferriter, W. M.(2010).Building a professional learning community at work: A guide to the first year.Bloomington, IN:Solution Tree.
27. Gronn, P.(2002).Distributed leadership.Second international handbook of educational leadership and administration,Dordrecht, NJ:
28. Guo, Y.,Guan, Y.,Yang, X.,Xu, J.,Zhou, X.,She, Z.,Pan, Z.(2014).Career adaptability, calling and the professional competence of social work students in China: A career construction perspective.Journal of Vocational Behavior,85(3),394-402.
29. Habermas, J.(1979).Communication and the evolution of society.Boston, MA:Beacon.
30. Hallam, P. R.,Smith, H. R.,Hite, J. M.,Hite, S. J.,Wilcox, B. R.(2015).Trust and collaboration in PLC teams: Teacher relationships, principal support, and collaborative benefits.NASSP Bulletin,99(3),193-216.
31. Hallinger, P.(2011).Leadership for learning: Lessons from 40 years of empirical research.Journal of Educational Administration,49(2),125-142.
32. Hargreaves, A.(2001).Changing teachers, changing times: Teachers’ work and culture in the postmodern age.London, UK:A&C Black.
33. Harris, A.(2013).Teacher leadership and school improvement.Effective leadership for school improvement,London, UK:
34. Holtshouse, D.(1998).Knowledge research issues.California Management Review,43(3),277-280.
35. James, K. T.,Mann, J.,Creasy, J.(2007).Leaders as lead learners: A case example of facilitating collaborative leadership learning for school leaders.Management Learning,38(1),79-94.
36. Kadroon, T.,Inprasitha, M.(2013).Professional development of mathematics teachers with lesson study and open approach: The process for changing teachers values about teaching mathematics.Psychology,4(2),101-105.
37. Lai, E.,Cheung, D.(2015).Enacting teacher leadership: The role of teachers in bringing about change.Educational Management Administration & Leadership,43(5),673-692.
38. Lambert, L.(2002).A framework for shared leadership.Educational Leadership,59(8),37-40.
39. Law, E.,Galton, M.,Wan, S.(2010).Distributed curriculum leadership in action: A Hong Kong case study.Educational Management Administration & Leadership,38(3),286-303.
40. Li, L.,Hallinger, P.,Kennedy, K. J.,Walker, A.(2017).Mediating effects of trust, communication, and collaboration on teacher professional learning in Hong Kong primary schools.International Journal of Leadership in Education,20(6),697-716.
41. Lim, C.,Lee, C.,Saito, E.,Haron, S. S.(2011).Taking stock of lesson study as a platform for teacher development in Singapore.Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education,39(4),353-365.
42. Lumpkin, A.,Claxton, H.,Wilson, A.(2014).Key characteristics of teacher leaders in schools.Administrative Issues Journal,4(2),59-67.
43. MacBeath, J.,Dempster, N.(2008).Connecting leadership and learning: Principles for practice.London, UK:Routeledge.
44. Mangin, M. M.,Stoelinga, S. R.(2008).Effective teacher leadership: Using research to inform and reform.New York, NY:Teachers College Press.
45. Marquardt, M. J.,Revans, R. W.(1999).Action learning in action: Transforming problems and people for world-class organizational learning.Palo Alto, CA:Davies-Black.
46. Mohamed, A.,Razak, A. Z. A.,Abdullah, Z.(2019).Teacher leadership and teacher professional learning in schools of Maldives.International Online Journal of Educational Leadership,2(2),36-50.
47. Mohammad, M,Khaled, M.(2017).Exploring change in EFL teachers’ perceptions of professional development.Journal of Teacher Education for Sustainability,19(1),22-42.
48. Muijs, D.,Harris, A.(2007).Teacher leadership in action: Three case studies of contrasting schools.Educational Management, Administration, and Leadership,35(1),111-134.
49. Muijs, D.,Harris, A.(2006).Teacher led school improvement: Teacher leadership in the UK.Teaching and Teacher Education,22,961-972.
50. Murphy, J.,Elliott, S. N.,Goldring, E.,Porter, A. C.(2007).Leadership for learning: A research-based model and taxonomy of behaviors.School Leadership and Management,27(2),179-201.
51. Murphy, J.,Smylie, M.,Mayrowetz, D.,Louis, K. S.(2009).The role of the principal in fostering the development of distributed leadership.School Leadership & Management,29(2),181-214.
52. Neumerski, C. M.(2013).Rethinking instructional leadership, a review: What do we know about principal, teacher, and coach instructional leadership, and where should we go from here?.Educational Administration Quarterly,49(2),310-347.
53. Ngcobo, T.,Tikly, L. P.(2010).Key dimensions of effective leadership for change: A focus on township and rural schools in South Africa.Educational Management Administration & Leadership,38(2),202-228.
54. Nicholson, J.,Capitelli, S.,Richert, A. E.,Bauer, A.,Bonetti, S.(2016).The affordances of using a teacher leadership network to support leadership development: Creating collaborative thinking spaces to strengthen teachers’ skills in facilitating productive evidence-informed conversations.Teacher Education Quarterly,43(1),29-50.
55. Pearce, C. L.,Conger, J. A.(2003).All those years ago: The historical underpinnings of shared leadership.Shared leadership: Reframing the hows and whys of leadership,San Francisco, CA:
56. Poekert, P. E.(2012).Teacher leadership and professional development: Examining links between two concepts central to school improvement.Professional Development in Education,38(2),169-188.
57. Ross, J. A., & Gray, P. (2006). School leadership and student achievement: The mediating effects of teacher beliefs. Retrieved from JSTOR Web site: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/3f10/5c2d5395333d23503152ae04820a829373de.pdf
58. Rothwell, W. J.(1999).The action learning guidebook: A real-time strategy for problem solving, training design, and employee development.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
59. Santos, D.,Miguel, L.(2019).The relationship between teachers’ beliefs, teachers’ behaviors, and teachers’ professional development: A literature review.International Journal of Education and Practice,7(1),10-18.
60. Silva, D.Y.,Gimbert, B,Nolan, J.(2010).Sliding the door: Locking and unlocking possibilities for teacher leadership.Teachers College Record,102,779-804.
61. Spee, A. P.,Jarzabkowski, P.(2011).Strategic planning as communicative process.Organization Studies,32(9),1217-1245.
62. Spillane, J. P. (2005). Distributed leadership. Retrieved from Taylor & Francis Web site:
63. Sterret, W. L.,Parker, M. A.,Mitzner, K.(2018).Maximizing teacher time: The collaborative leadership role of the principal.Journal of Organizational and Educational Leadership,3(2),1-27.
64. Uribe-Flórez, L. J.,Al-Rawashdeh, A.,Morales, S.(2014).Perceptions about teacher leadership: Do teacher leaders and administrators share a common ground?.Journal of International Education and Leadership,4(1),1-15.
65. Watkins, K. E.,Marsick, V. J.(1993).Sculpting the learning organization: Lessons in the art andscience of systemic change.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
66. Wells, C.,Feun, L.(2007).Implementation of learning community principles: A study of six high schools.Nassp Bulletin,91(2),141-160.
67. Wenner, J. A.,Campbell, T.(2017).The theoretical and empirical basis of teacher leadership: A review of the literature.Review of Educational Research,87(1),134-171.
68. Wilson, A.(2016).From professional practice to practical leader: Teacher leadership in professional learning communities.International Journal of Teacher Leadership,7(2),45-61.
69. York-Barr, J.,Duke, K.(2004).What do we know about teacher leadership? Findings from two decades of scholarship.Review of Educational Research,74(3),255-316.
70. Zepeda, S. J.,Mayers, R. S.,Benson, B. N.(2003).The call to teacher leadership.Larchmont, NY:Eye on Education.
71. Zhang, J.,Pang, N. S. K.(2016).Exploring the characteristics of professional learning communities in China: A mixed-method study.The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher,25(1),11-21.
72. 吳百祿, B. -L.(2010)。中小學教師領導者之理念及其對我國學校教育的啟示。教育政策論壇，13(2)，129-158。
73. 吳清山, C. -S.,林天祐, T.- Y.(2011)。協作領導。教育研究月刊，210，117-118。
74. 吳清山, C. -S.,林天祐, T. -Y.(2001)。教學領導。教育資料與研究，43，121。
75. 李安明, A. -M.,謝傳崇, C. -C.(2011)。校長教學領導：理論與實踐。當代教育研究，19(3)，161-175。
76. 林明地, M. -D.(2013)。學習領導：理念與實際初探。教育研究月刊，229，18-31。
77. 張德銳, T. -J.(2015)。學習領導在教學輔導教師制度中的發展與實踐。市北教育學刊，52，1-20。
78. 教育部（ 2006 ）。 教育部補助辦理教師專業發展實踐方案作業要點。 取自http://edu.law.moe.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=GL000567 [Ministry of Education. (2006). On the subsidies for teachers’ professional development practice plan of Ministry of Education. Retrieved from Ministry of Education Web site: http:// edu.law.moe.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=GL000567]
79. 賴志峰, Z. -F.(2008)。分佈式領導理論的意義、構面與主張。教育研究月刊，171，28-40。

1. 陳麗如(2020)。校園植物綠美化管理案例分析－以OKR運用在一所國民小學為例。學校行政，130，242-260。
2. 陳麗如(2021)。從教師領導研究回顧探討其若干應用與限制。學校行政，133，152-178。
3. 賈志琳,李政軒(2020)。人工智慧的實踐：對話式日語學習智慧家教系統進行日語補救教學之研究。教育實踐與研究，33(2)，1-41。
4. 鍾易達,蕭德光,劉鎮寧(2022)。國民中小學校長專業學習社群之個案研究。嘉大教育研究學刊，49，1-31。
5. (2021)。國民中小學候用校長教學領導指標之建構。教育政策論壇，24(1)，41-80。
6. (2022)。建立學校協作文化：校長與教師領導者應有作為之探討。教育研究月刊，342，62-79。
7. (2022)。學校協作模式的國際化與本土化：理論、研究與實踐。教育研究月刊，342，48-61。