努力有用乎？教師能力觀、努力觀、社群共學觀及學習者中心教學觀對課程變革行為意向之影響

Does Effort Matter? The Effects of Teachers' Beliefs about Ability, Effort, Community Learning and Learner-Centered Instruction on Their Behavioral Intention for Curriculum Reform

陳文彥(Wen-Yan Chen)；黃囇莉(Li-Li Huang)

努力觀 ； 社群共學觀 ； 能力觀 ； 教師信念 ； 課程改革 ； 學習者中心教學觀 ； 變革行為意向 ； ability-based belief ； belief about community learning ； belief about learner-centered instruction ； change behavioral intention ； curriculum reform ； effort-based belief ； teacher belief

教育實踐與研究

36卷1期（2023 / 06 / 01）

39 - 72

繁體中文;英文

本研究立基108新課綱的理念與精神，並融入文化觀點，聚焦於探討國高中教師的能力觀、努力觀，還有教師的社群共學觀及學習者中心教學觀等，對於教師課程變革行為意向之影響。研究方法採問卷調查法，以臺灣本島公立國中與公立普通型高中之教師為母群體，回收有效問卷1195份。資料分析方法採描述統計、相關分析及結構方程模式，研究結果顯示：（1）臺灣國高中教師在能力固定觀的得分為中標，努力觀的得分為中高標，結果與其他華人社會的調查相似，也就是重視努力的效用與價值勝於強調能力的不可塑性。而教師對社群共學觀與學習者中心教學觀的認同分別達高標與中高標，對參與課綱變革的行為意向亦為中高標，顯示教師們有著中等以上的變革認知準備度，以及面對此課程變革的正向態度；（2）由中介模式來看，努力觀對社群共學觀及學習者中心教學觀均具正向效果，且努力觀可透過對共學觀及教學觀的影響，由不同中介路徑對教師的變革行為意向產生正向間接效果。相較之下，能力固定觀對學習觀及變革行為意向之影響，除了效果較小，影響方向更呈現負向。整體研究結果所揭示的重要意義，乃是教師認知對課程變革之關鍵作用。其中，除了教師對專業學習與學生學習的信念有著顯著影響力，教師對能力及努力的信念，更是過往研究較少關注，但卻牽引著教師學習觀點和變革意向的深層文化因素。因此，就實務而言，本研究結果指陳了課程變革若欲成功，革新方案與教師信念之契合是一大關鍵，且教師信念之改變乃是促進變革的重要槓桿；就研究而言，本研究由認知與文化面向著手，探究教師信念對教師變革之影響，是國內教育研究尚少切入之分析視角，亦值得後續進一步擴展。

The study aimed to investigate the effects of teachers' ability-based beliefs and effort-based beliefs on their behavioral intention for curriculum reform via their beliefs about learning. Data was collected through a survey from 1,195 public junior high and senior high school teachers in Taiwan. The data analysis involved descriptive statistics, correlation analysis, and structural equation modeling (SEM). The main findings were as follows:1) Teachers' score on effort-based belief was significantly higher than their score on ability-based belief, reaching a high-intermediate level. Teachers' beliefs about community learning and student-centered instruction reached high and high-intermediated levels. Their change behavioral intention showed a positive attitude toward the curriculum reform at a high-intermediate level.2) In the mediation model, teachers' effort-based belief directly affected their beliefs about community learning and learner-centered instruction. Moreover, the effort-based belief could positively influence change behavioral intention through different indirect paths via its impact on belief of community learning and belief of learner-centered instruction. Conversely, the ability-based belief had a negative effect on teachers' change behavioral intention. The study revealed that teachers' beliefs about community learning and student-centered instruction were critical to their behavioral intention for the reform. Moreover, teachers' beliefs about effort and ability were found to be fundamental cultural factors influencing their conceptions of learning and their behavioral intention for change.

1. 王玉品, Y. -P.,徐偉民, W. -M.(2009)。一位國小教師面對數學教學改革的抗拒和改變。科學教育學刊，17(3)，233-253。
   連結：
2. 王冠樺, K. -H.,陳舜文, S. -W.(2020)。父母努力信念對兒童學習投入之預測效果：以兒童知覺父母與自身努力信念為中介。本土心理學研究，54，63-111。
   連結：
3. 宋佩芬, P. -F.(2016)。扶助弱勢學生學習：教師教學信念與教學取向之探究。嘉大教育研究學刊，37，149-180。
   連結：
4. 宋佩芬, P. -F.(2021)。歷史教學備課：國中楷模教師的個案研究。教育實踐與研究，34(2)，1-40。
   連結：
5. 林文瑛, W. -Y.(2004)。教師的人性觀與教育觀—以能力觀為例。教育心理學報，35(4)，355-374。
   連結：
6. 符碧真, B. -J.,陳舜文, S. -W.,危芷芬, C. -F.,王秀槐, H. -H.(2021)。華人的學業成就目標與儒家倫理觀：兼回應「臺灣青少年是否認為努力與學業成就關乎道德？」一文。中華心理學刊，63(4)，357-372。
   連結：
7. 陳佩英, P. -Y.(2017)。對話即實踐：網絡學習社群專業資本積累之個案研究。教育科學研究期刊，62(3)，159-191。
   連結：
8. 陳偉仁, W. -R.,黃楷茹, K. -R.,吳青陵, C. -L.,呂金燮, C. -H.(2018)。專業學習的建構：「設計本位學習」創新教學之行動探究。教育實踐與研究，31(2)，25-57。
   連結：
9. 黃囇莉, L. -L.,洪才舒, T. -S.(2017)。學習的意義感：建立、失落及再創生。教育科學研究期刊，62(1)，133-162。
   連結：
10. 黃囇莉, L. -L.,陳文彥, W. -Y.(2017)。做了很不一樣！學習共同體對課堂中社會關係及學生學習之影響。課程與教學季刊，20(2)，111-138。
    連結：
11. 楊幸真, H. -C.,符雅筑, Y. -C.(2021)。從教師專業學習社群到行動網絡學習社群：性別融入醫學教育的另類途徑。教育實踐與研究，34(3)，165-204。
    連結：
12. 雷庚玲, K. -L.,林楷潔, K. -C.,吳淑娟, S. -C.,蔡宜妙, Y. -M.,張泰銓, T. -T.,黃素英, S. -Y.,鄭澈, C.(2022)。華人母親的學習信念與共讀行為：努力有用觀與能力增進觀的比較。中華心理學刊，64(3)，311-340。
    連結：
13. 潘慧玲, H. -L.,洪瑞璇, J. -H.(2022)。共治共學觀關乎課程變革？教師對十二年國教課綱變革意向的影響因素。當代教育研究季刊，30(1)，1-37。
    連結：
14. 潘慧玲, H. -L.,黃囇莉, L. -L.,陳文彥, W. -Y.,鄭淑惠, S. -H.(2020)。學校準備好了嗎？國高中教育人員實施108 課綱的變革準備度。教育研究與發展，16(1)，65-100。
    連結：
15. 潘慧玲, H. -L.,鄭淑惠, S. -H.(2018)。植基真實情境的共學效應：學習共同體促動之教師改變。課程與教學，21(4)，121-149。
    連結：
16. 蔡玉玲, Y. -L.,張靜嚳, C. -K.(2008)。輔導國中數學實習教師學習問題中心教學並探討其教學改變。彰化師大教育學報，13，63-95。
    連結：
17. 薛雅慈, Y. -C.(2014)。國中教師以學習共同體啟動新學習型態之研究。教育科學研究期刊，59(1)，101-140。
    連結：
18. 顏綵思, T. -S.,黃光國, K. -K.(2011)。儒家社會中學生的角色義務及其對獎懲正當性的知覺。中華心理學刊，53(1)，79-95。
    連結：
19. Abrami, P. C.,Poulsen, C.,Chambers, B.(2004).Teacher motivation to implement an educational innovation: Factors differentiating users and non-users of cooperative learning.Educational Psychology,24(2),201-216.
20. Akerson, V. L.,Cullen, T. A.,Hanson, D. L.(2009).Fostering a community of practice through a professional development program to improve elementary teachers’ views of nature of science and teaching practice.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,46(10),1090-1113.
21. Anderson, J. C.,Gerbing, D. W.(1988).Structural equation modeling in practice: A review and recommended two-step approach.Psychological Bulletin,103(3),411.
22. Bolhuis, S.,Voeten, M. J.(2004).Teachers’ conceptions of student learning and own learning.Teachers and Teaching,10(1),77-98.
23. Bonner, S. M.,Diehl, K.,Trachtman, R.(2020).Teacher belief and agency development in bringing change to scale.Journal of Educational Change,21(2),363-384.
24. Brown, J. S.,Collins, A.,Duguid, P.(1989).Situated cognition and the culture of learning.Educational Researcher,18(1),32-42.
25. Brown, K. L.(2003).From teacher-centered to learner-centered curriculum: Improving learning in diverse classrooms.Education,124(1),49-55.
26. Chan, K. W.,Elliott, R. G.(2004).Relational analysis of personal epistemology and conceptions about teaching and learning.Teaching and Teacher Education,20(8),817-831.
27. Chen, S. W.,Fwu, B. J.,Wei, C. F.,Wang, H. H.(2016).High-school teachers’ beliefs about effort and their attitudes toward struggling and smart students in a Confucian society.Frontiers in Psychology,7,1366-1366.
28. Cheng, K. M.(1998).Can education Values be borrowed? Looking into cultural differences.Peabody Journal of Education,73(2),11-30.
29. Cheung, W. S.,Wong, J. L. N.(2017).Understanding reflection for teacher change in Hong Kong.International Journal of Educational Management,31(7),1135-1146.
30. Dahl, T. I.,Bals, M.,Turi, A. L.(2005).Are students’ beliefs about knowledge and learning associated with their reported use of learning strategies?.British Journal of Educational Psychology,75(2),257-273.
31. Dunne, F.,Nave, B.,Lewis, A.(2000).Critical friends groups: Teachers helping teachers to improve student learning.Phi Delta Kappa,28(4),31-37.
32. Dweck, C. S.(2006).Mindset: The new psychology of success.New York, NY:Random House.
33. Dweck, C. S.,Chiu, C. Y.,Hong, Y. Y.(1995).Implicit theories and their role in judgments and reactions: A word from two perspectives.Psychological Inquiry,6(4),267-285.
34. Dweck, C. S.,Leggett, E. L.(1988).A social-cognitive approach to motivation and personality.Psychological Review,95(2),256.
35. Fornell, C.,Larcker, D. F.(1981).Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error.Journal of Marketing Research,18(1),39-50.
36. Fullan, M.(2007).Change the terms for teacher learning.Journal of Staff Development,28(3),35-36.
37. Hairon, S.(2016).Facilitation for professional learning community conversations in Singapore.Asia Pacific Journal of Education,36(2),285-300.
38. Hairon, S.,Chua, C. S. K.,Neo, W. L.(2018).School-based curriculum development in Singapore: A case study of a primary school.Asia Pacific Journal of Education,38(4),518-532.
39. Halverson, R.(2003).Systems of practice: How leaders use artifacts to create professional community in schools.Education Policy Analysis Archives,11(37),1-34.
40. Handal, B.,Herrington, A.(2003).Mathematics teachers’ beliefs and curriculum reform.Mathematics Education Research Journal,15(1),59-69.
41. Hong, Y. Y.,Chiu, C. Y.,Dweck, C. S.,Lin, D. M. S.,Wan, W.(1999).Implicit theories, attributions, and coping: A meaning system approach.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,77(3),588.
42. Huang, X.,Lee, J. C. K.,Yang, X.(2019).What really counts? Investigating the effects of creative role identity and self-efficacy on teachers’ attitudes towards the implementation of teaching for creativity.Teaching and Teacher Education,84,57-65.
43. Jones, B. D.,Bryant, L. H.,Snyder, J. D.,Malone, D.(2012).Preservice and inservice teachers’ implicit theories of intelligence.Teacher Education Quarterly,39(2),87-101.
44. Kern, B. D.,Richards, K. A. R.,Graber, K. C.,Templin, T. J.,Housner, L. D.(2021).Toward an integrative model for teacher change in physical education.Quest,73(1),1-21.
45. Kolb, D. A.(1984).Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning and development.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
46. Komarraju, M.,Nadler, D.(2013).Self-efficacy and academic achievement: Why do implicit beliefs, goals, and effort regulation matter?.Learning and Individual Differences,25,67-72.
47. Lambert, L.(2002).A framework for shared leadership.Educational Leadership,59(8),37-40.
48. Lee, C. J.(2000).Teacher identity to curriculum change in the implementation stage: The case of environmental education in Hong Kong.Journal of Curriculum Studies,32(1),95-115.
49. Leroy, N.,Bressoux, P.,Sarrazin, P.,Trouilloud, D.(2007).Impact of teachers’ implicit theories and perceived pressures on the establishment of an autonomy supportive climate.European Journal of Psychology of Education,22,529-545.
50. Lewis, C.,Perry, R.,Murata, A.(2006).How should research contribute to instructional improvement? The case of lesson study.Educational Researcher,35(3),3-14.
51. Li, J.(2003).US and Chinese cultural beliefs about learning.Journal of Educational Psychology,95(2),258-267.
52. Ma, Y. P.,Yin, H. B.,Tang, L. F.,Liu, L. Y.(2009).Teacher receptivity to system-wide curriculum reform in the initiation stage: A Chinese perspective.Asia Pacific Education Review,10(3),423-432.
53. MacBeath, J.,Dempster, N.(2009).Connecting leadership and learning: Principles for practice.London, UK:Routledge.
54. Massouleh, N. S.,Jooneghani, R. B.(2012).Learner-centered instruction: A critical perspective.Journal of Education and Practice,3(6),50-59.
55. Moroz, R.,Waugh, R. F.(2000).Teacher receptivity to system-wide educational change.Journal of Educational Administration,38(2),159-178.
56. Muthén, L. K.,Muthén, B. O.(2017).Mplus: Statistical analysis with latent variables.
57. National Board for Professional Teaching Standards. (2023). Five core propositions. Retrieved from https://www.nbpts.org/certification/five-core-propostions/
58. O’Sullivan, M.(2004).The reconceptualisation of learner-centred approaches: A Namibian case study.International Journal of Educational Development,24,585-602.
59. Rissanen, I.,Kuusisto, E.,Hanhimäki, E.,Tirri, K.(2018).Teachers’ implicit meaning systems and their implications for pedagogical thinking and practice: A case study from Finland.Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research,62(4),487-500.
60. Rissanen, I.,Kuusisto, E.,Hanhimäki, E.,Tirri, K.(2018).The implications of teachers’ implicit theories for moral education: A case study from Finland.Journal of Moral Education,47(1),63-77.
61. Salinas, M. F.,Garr, J.(2009).Effect of learner-centered education on the academic outcomes of minority groups.Journal of Instructional Psychology,36(3),226-237.
62. Schuh, K. L.(2004).Learner-centered principles in teacher-centered practices?.Teaching and Teacher Education,20,833-846.
63. Stipek, D. J.,Givvin, K. B.,Salmon, J. M.,MacGyvers, V. L.(2001).Teachers’ beliefs and practices related to mathematics instruction.Teaching and Teacher Education,17(2),213-226.
64. Suprayogi, M. N.,Valcke, M.,Godwin, R.(2017).Teachers and their implementation of differentiated instruction in the classroom.Teaching and Teacher Education,67,291-301.
65. Tarbetsky, A. L.,Collie, R. J.,Martin, A. J.(2016).The role of implicit theories of intelligence and ability in predicting achievement for indigenous (aboriginal) Australian students.Contemporary Educational Psychology,47,61-71.
66. Tu, W. M.(1979).Humanity and self-cultivation: Essays in confucian thought.Berkeley, CA:Asian Humanities Press.
67. Vescio, V.,Ross, D.,Adams, A.(2008).A review of research on the impact of professional learning communities on teaching practice and student learning.Teaching and Teacher Education,24(1),80-91.
68. Vygotsky, L. S.,Cole, M.(Ed. Trans.),John-Steiner, V.(Ed. Trans.),Scribner, S.(Ed. Trans.),Souberman, E.(Ed. Trans.)(1978).Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
69. Waugh, R. F.,Punch, K. F.(1987).Teacher receptivity to systemwide change in the implementation stage.Review of Education Research,57(3),237-254.
70. Weimar, M.(2013).Learner-centered teaching: Five key changes to practice.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
71. Yilmaz, K.(2008).Social studies teachers’ views of learner-centered instruction.European Journal of Teacher Education,31(1),35-53.
72. Yin, H.,Keung, C. P. C.,Tam, W. W. Y.(2022).What facilitates kindergarten teachers’ intentions to implement play-based learning?.Early Childhood Education Journal,50(4),555-566.
73. 佐藤學, M.,黃郁倫（譯）, Y. -L.(Trans.),鍾啟泉（譯）, Q. -Q.(Trans.)(2012).學習的革命：從教室出發的改革.台北=Taipei:親子天下=Parenting.
74. 佐藤學, M.,鍾啟泉（譯）, Q. -Q.(Trans.),陳靜靜（譯）, C. -C.(Trans.)(2012).教師的挑戰：寧靜的課堂革命.上海=Shanghai:華東師範大學=East China Normal University.
75. 李子建, J. -C.,尹弘颷, H. -B.(2005)。教師對課程變革的認同感和關注：課程實施研究的探討。教育研究與發展，1(1)，107-128。
76. 范聖佳, S. -J.,郭重吉, C. -J.(2007)。國中數學教師試行合作學習之行動研究。科學教育，13，73-90。
77. 教育部=Ministry of Education(2016)。教育部（2016）。中華民國教師專業標準指引。台北：作者。[Ministry of Education. (2016). Teacher professional standard guidelines of Republic of China. Taipei: Author.]。
78. 教育部（2014）。十二年國民基本教育課程綱要總綱。台北：作者。[Ministry of Education. (2014). The general curriculum guideline of 12-year basic education. Taipei: Author.]
79. 陳文彥, W. -Y.(2019)。專業學習社群與學校課程發展。教育研究月刊，308，17-33。
80. 陳文彥, W. -Y.(2021)。權力觀及課程觀對學校中層領導者課綱變革行為意向之影響。教育政策論壇，24(2)，107-139。
81. 潘慧玲、李麗君、黃淑馨、余霖、薛雅慈（2016）。學習領導下的學習共同體 1.2 版。取自 https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BzFo0Q7y8dmZa1BmU3d0SEVlbnM/view [Pan, H. -L., Lee, L. -J., Hwang, S. -S., Yu, L., & Hsueh, Y. -T. (2016). Learning community under the leadership for learning, version 1.2: Basic handbook. Retrieved from https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BzFo0Q7y8dmZa1BmU3d0SEVlbnM/view]
82. 潘慧玲, H. -L.,陳佩英, P. -Y.,張素貞, S. -C.,鄭淑惠, S. -H.,陳文彥, W. -Y.(2014)。從學習領導論析學習共同體概念與實踐。市北教育學刊，45，1-28。
83. 潘慧玲, H. -L.,黃淑馨, S. -S,李麗君, L. -J.,余霖, L.,劉秀嫚, S. -M.,薛雅慈, Y. -T.(2015).學習領導下的學習共同體進階手冊 2.0 版.