题名

師資生集中實習教學省思札記之內容分析

并列篇名

A Content Analysis of Reflective Journal Writing: Exploring Prospective Teachers' Reflections on Field Experience during Intensive Practicum

DOI

10.6764/JTEPD.201006.0041

作者

周鳳美(Phone-Mei Chou)

关键词

省思 ; 省思札記 ; 師資培育 ; 教學實習 ; reflection ; reflective journal ; teacher education ; teaching practicum

期刊名称

師資培育與教師專業發展期刊

卷期/出版年月

3卷1期(2010 / 06 / 01)

页次

41 - 69

内容语文

繁體中文

中文摘要

本文探討四位師資生在教學實習課程集中實習期間的教學省思。藉由分析省思札記的省思主題與省思層次,以瞭解師資生的學習以及省思品質。研究結果顯示:(一)省思主題涵蓋五個範圍:教學方法與教學過程、教學評鑑、輔導老師行爲與理念、自我知覺、參考理論與文獻。由各主題的條目數量多寡透露:師資生最重視各科教學方法與教學過程,而甚少聯繫正式知識於教學實務。(二)省思層次出現「描述」、「描述省思」、與「對話省思」。其中,不具備省思特質的「描述」條目,稍多於其他兩項的總和。就省思品質而言,師資生實踐四種省思類型,缺少批判省思;此外,近於一半的省思條目具建設性省思的性質。基於研究結果,肯定本文實施的省思札記教學策略,並提出改善之處。結論對師培課程提出建議以促進培養師資生省思能力。

英文摘要

The purpose of this study was to explore four preservice teachers' reflections on field experiences in the context of their Teaching Practicum course through the analysis of journal writing. To understand the ways that they learned to teach as well as the quality of reflection among prospective teachers, the researcher examined the topics and the levels of reflection produced by the four preservice teachers.Two major findings emerged. First, topics of reflection fell into five categories: (a) teaching methods and process, (b) evaluating teaching, (c) mentors' performance and ideas, (d) self-awareness, and (e) theories from the literature. These topics reveal that informants pay much more attention to teaching methods and process than to formal knowledge presented in the literature. Second, descriptive writing, descriptive reflection, and dialogic reflection were the three categories of reflective levels that appeared in the preservice teachers' journals. Among them, nonreflective descriptive writing appeared more frequently in their journals than the other two categories.As for the quality of reflection, informants were able to produce four types of reflection: (a) technical reflection, (b) reflection on action, (c) deliberative reflection, and (d) personalistic reflection. In addition, almost half the entries that were defined as descriptive reflection and dialogic reflection were analytic. Based on the research results, the author concluded that the use of the reflective journal is useful as a tool for transforming preservice teachers into reflective practitioners. The study concludes with a suggestion for cultivating reflection in preservice teachers in teacher education programs.

主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. Dewey, J. (1933). How we think: A restatement of the relation of reflective thinking to the educative process. Boston: Heath and Company.
  2. Atkins, S.,Murphy, K.(1993).Reflection: A review of the literature.Journal of Advanced Nursing,18,1188-1192.
  3. Bain, J. D.,Ballantyne, R.,Packer, J.,Mills, C.(1999).Using journals writing to enhance student teachers' reflectivity during field experience placements.Teachers and Teaching: Theory and practice,5(1),51-73.
  4. Bain, J. D.,Mills, C.,Ballantyne, R.,Packer, J.(2002).Developing reflection on practice through journal writing: Impacts of variations in the focus and levels of feedback.Teachers and Teaching: Theory and practice,8(2),171-196.
  5. Borko, H.,Michalec, P.,Timmons, M.,Siddle, J.(1997).Student teaching portfolios: A tool for promoting reflective practice.Journal of Teacher Education,48(5),345-357.
  6. Boud, D.(ed.),Keogh, R.(ed.),Walker, D.(ed.)(1985).Reflection: turning experience into learning.London:Kogan Page.
  7. Calderhead, J.(1989).Reflective teaching and teacher education.Teaching and Teacher Education,5(1),43-51.
  8. Colton, A. B.,Sparks-Langer, G. M.(1993).A conceptual framework to guide the development of teacher reflection and decision making.Journal of Teacher Education,44(1),45-54.
  9. Davis, E. A.(2006).Characterizing productive reflection among perservice teachers: Seeing what matters.Teaching and Teacher Education,22(3),281-301.
  10. Francis, D.(1995).The reflective journal : A window to preservice teachers' practical knowledge.Teaching and Teacher Education,11(3),229-241.
  11. Galvez-Martin, M. E.,Bowman, C. L.,Morrison, M. A.(1998).An exploratory study of the level of reflection attained by preservice teachers.Mid-Western Educational Researcher,11(2),9-18.
  12. Gil-Garcia, A.,Clintron, Z.(2002).The reflective journals as a learning and professional development tool for teachers and administrators.the World Association for Case Method Research and Application Conference,Germany:
  13. Guillaume, A. M.,Rudney, G. L.(1993).Student teachers' growth toward independence.Teaching and Teacher Education,9(1),65-80.
  14. Hargreaves, A.(ed.),Fullan, M. G.(ed.)(1992).Understanding teacher development.New York:Teacher College Press.
  15. Hatton, N.,Smith, D.(1995).Reflection in teacher education: Towards definition and implication.Teaching and Teacher Education,11(1),33-49.
  16. Ho, B.,Richards, J. C.(1993).Reflective thinking through teacher journal writing: Myths and Realities.Perspectives,5(2),25-40.
  17. Hoover, L. A.(1994).Reflective writing as a window on preservice teachers' thought process.Teaching and Teacher Education,10(1),83-93.
  18. Jay, J. K.,Johnson, K. L.(2002).Capturing complexity: A typology of reflective practice for teacher education.Teaching and Teacher Education,18(1),73-85.
  19. Kagan, D. M.(1992).Implications or research on teacher belief.Educational Psychologist,27(1),65-90.
  20. Kraus, S.,Butler, K.(2000).Reflection is not description: Cultivating reflection with pre-service teachers.the Annual Meeting of the American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education(52nd ),Chicago, IL:
  21. Lee, Hea-Jin(2005).Understanding and assessing preservice teachers' reflective thinking.Teaching and Teacher Education,21(6),699-715.
  22. Loughran, J. J.(2002).Effective reflective practice: In search of meaning in learning about teaching.Journal of Teacher Education,53(1),33-43.
  23. Mansvelder-Longayroux, D. D.,Beijaard, D.,Verloop, N.(2006).The portfolio as a tool for stimulating reflection by student teachers.Teaching and Teacher Education,23(1),47-62.
  24. McIntyre, D.(ed.),Hagger, H.(ed.),Wilkin, M.(ed.)(1993).Mentoring: Perspectives on school- based teacher education.London:Kogan Page.
  25. McLaughlin, D.,Hanifin, P.(1994).Empowering the novice: Promoting reflection in preservice teacher education.the Annual Conference of the Australian Teacher Education Association (24th),Queensland, Australia:
  26. Mclaughlin, H. J.(1991).The reflection on the blackboard: student teacher self evaluation.International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education,4(2),141-159.
  27. Meijer, P. C.,Zanting, A.,Verloop, N.(2002).How can student teachers elicit experienced teachers' practical knowledge?.Journal of Teacher Education,51(5),406-419.
  28. Minott, M. A.(2008).Valli's typology of reflection and the analysis of pre-service teachers' reflective journals.Australian Journal of Teacher Education,33(5),55-65.
  29. Pedro, J. Y.(2005).Reflection in teacher education: exploring pre-service teachers' meanings of reflective practice.Reflection Perspective,6(1),49-66.
  30. Ross, D. D.(1989).First steps in developing a reflective approach.Journal of TeacherEducation,40(2),22-31.
  31. Ross, D. D.(1990).Programmatic structures for the preparation of reflective teachers.Encouraging reflective practice in education,New York:
  32. Rovegno, I.(1992).Learning to reflect on teaching: A case study of on preservice physical education teacher.The Elementary School Journal,92(4),491-510.
  33. Schon, D. A.(1987).Educating the reflective practitioner.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
  34. Sherin, M. G.(2004).Teacher learning in the context of a video club.Teaching and Teacher Education,20(2),163-183.
  35. Shulman, L.(ed.),Sykes, G(ed.)(1983).Handbook of teaching and policy.New York:Longman.
  36. Spalding, E.,Wilson, A.(2002).Demystifying reflection: A study of pedagogical strategies that encourage reflective journal writing.Teacher College Record,104(7),1393-1421.
  37. Sparks-Langer, G. M.,Colton, A. B.(1991).Synthesis of research on teachers' reflective thinking.Educational Leadership,48(6),37-44.
  38. Sparks-Langer, G. M.,Simmons, J. M.,Pasch, M.,Colton, A.,Starko, A.(1990).Reflective pedagogical thinking: How can we promote it and measure it?.Journal of Teacher Education,41(5),23-32.
  39. Stemler, S.(2001).An overview of content analysis. Practical Assessment.Research & Evaluation,7(17)
  40. Strahan, D. B.(1990).A developmental analysis of preservice teachers' orientations toward themselves, their students, and their subject matter.the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association,Boston:
  41. Tsangaridous, N.,O'Sullivan, M.(1994).Using pedagogical reflective strategies to enhance reflection among preservice physical education teachers.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,14(1),13-33.
  42. Valli, L.(1997).Listening to other voices: A description of teacher reflection in the United States.Peabody Journal of Education,72(1),67-88.
  43. Valli, L.(1992).Reflective teacher education: Cases and critiques.New York:State University of New York Press.
  44. Ward, J. R.,McCotter, S. S.(2004).Reflection as visible outcome for preservice teachers.Teaching and Teacher Education,20,243-257.
  45. Wiltz, N. W.(2000).Group seminars: Dialogues to enhance professional development and reflection.the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association,New Orleans, LA:
  46. Wong, F. K.,Kember, D.,Chung, L. Y.,Yan, L.(1995).Assessing the level of student reflection from journals.Journal of Advanced Nursing,22,48-57.
  47. Zanting, A.,Verloop, N.,Vermunt, J. D.(2001).Student teachers' beliefs about mentoring and learning to teach during teaching practice.British Journal of Educational Psychology,71(1),57-80.
  48. Zanting, A.,Verloop, N.,Vermunt, J. D.(2001).Student teachers eliciting mentors' practical knowledge and comparing it to their own beliefs.Teaching and Teacher Education,17,725-740.
  49. Zeichner, K. M.,Liston, D. P.(1987).Teaching student teachers to reflect.Harvard Educational Review,57(1),23-48.
  50. Zembal-Saul, C.,Blumenfeld, P.,Krajcik, J.(2000).Influence of guided cycles of planning, teaching, and reflection on prospective elementary teachers' science content presentations.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,37(4),318-339.
  51. 吳和堂(1999)。國中實習教師教學反省的內容與層次之分析。教育學刊,15,143-170。
  52. 吳清山(2006)。師資培育的理念與實踐。教育研究與發展期刊,2(1),1-32。
  53. 林玫君(2000)。實習教師之教學省思研究初探。國立台南師院學報,33,347-365。
  54. 陳向明(2002)。社會科學質的研究。台北:五南。
  55. 陳春蓮(2002)。以撰寫日誌培養中學體育科實習教師教學反省能力。國立台灣體育學院學報,10,21-37。
  56. 楊國樞編、文崇一編、吳聰賢編、李亦園編(1989)。社會及行為科學研究法。台北:東華。
被引用次数
  1. 徐靜嫻(2013)。PBL融入師資培育教學實習課程之個案研究。教育科學研究期刊,58(2),91-121。
  2. 張甄玲、林靜萍(2012)。體育師資生試教經驗之探討。臺灣運動教育學報,7(1),45-56。
  3. 周水珍,方舟(2023)。教學實習課程協同師徒制師資生專業成長之研究。師資培育與教師專業發展期刊,16(1),1-27。
  4. (2012)。從教育實習內涵探討國民小學各學習領域教學輔導推動之研究。教育行政與評鑑學刊,13,1-26。