臺灣學術界數學史研究之現況分析與建議：以1992年至2017年學位論文為例

Analysis of Current State and Recommendations for HPM Research in Taiwan: The Case of Theses and Dissertations from 1992 to 2017

10.6278/tjme.201904_6(1).003

蔡文榮(Wen‐Rong Tsay)；張鈞淇(Chun‐Chi Chan)；劉柏宏(Po‐Hung Liu)

HPM ； 數學史 ； 數學教育 ； 學位論文 ； HPM ； history of mathematics ； mathematics education ； degree thesis

臺灣數學教育期刊

6卷1期（2019 / 04 / 01）

27 - 51

繁體中文

本研究旨在探討目前臺灣學術界關於數學史研究、數學史融入教學的現況、發展趨勢及對數學史教學研究的啟示。本研究係以內容分析法進行，針對1992年至2017年間143篇碩博士學位論文，從論文數量變化趨勢、研究主題、研究方法及數學史融入教學的單元等角度切入。結果顯示，純數學史的研究中，以探討中國古代數學的篇數過半為最多，而歐洲國家數學史最少。亞洲區域除了中國外，也對朝鮮及日本等地區的數學史進行相關研究。以教育階段區分，數學史融入教學的研究數量以國小與國中階段最多，高中次之，高職最少。不過數學史融入教學的單元佔比卻呈現相反趨勢。在研究方法方面，以質性研究的比例最高，除了行動研究與準實驗研究外，問卷和訪談是最主要的研究工具。本研究也針對未來數學史融入教學的方向提出一些建議。

The purpose of this study was to investigate the current state, trend, and revelation of Taiwan's theses and dissertations in the field of HPM. This study adopted content analysis approach. By investigating 143 theses and dissertations ranging from 1992 to 2017, the study conducted a holistic analysis in terms of the trend in the change of quantity, research topics, methodologies, and HPM-integrated lessons. The result reveals that, regarding the study of ancient mathematics, over one half of the studies focused on Chinese context, while Europe context attracted the least attention. Beside of the ancient Chinese mathematics, Korean and Japanese mathematics were also investigated. As of the HPM-integrated lessons, the elementary and junior high school levels have the highest percentage followed by the high school level, and senior vocational school received the least attention. However, the ratio of the HPM-integrated lessons to the textbook lessons appears an opposite trend. Qualitative studies outnumbered the quantitative ones in these theses and dissertations. Beside of action research and quasi-experimental studies, questionnaires and interviews are the main instruments. The present study recommends several issues for future HPM researches.

1. Fasanelli, F.,Fauvel, J.(2006).The international study group on the relations between the history and pedagogy of mathematics: The first twenty-five years, 1976-2000.Proceedings of HPM 2004 & ESU 4: ICME 10 satellite meeting of the HPM Group & Fourth European Summer University on the history and epistemology in mathematics education,Iraklion, Greece:
2. Fauvel, J.,Van Maanen, J.(1997).The role of the history of mathematics in the teaching and learning of mathematics: Discussion document for an ICMI Study (1997-2000).Educational Studies in Mathematics,34(3),255-259.
3. Furinghetti, F.,Paola, D.(2003).History as a crossroads of mathematical culture and educational needs in the classroom.Mathematics in School,32(1),37-41.
4. Kilpatrick, J.,Swafford, J.,Findell, B.(2003).Adding it up: Helping children learn mathematics.Washington, DC:National Academy Press.
5. Nesher, P.(Ed.),Kilpatrick, J.(Ed.)(1990).Mathematics and cognition: A research synthesis by the international group for the psychology of mathematics education.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
6. 王添法, Tian-Fa(1992)。臺北市=Taipei，國立臺灣師範大學=National Taiwan Normal University。
7. 李國偉, KoWei,黃文璋, Wen-Jang,楊德清, Der-Ching,劉柏宏, Po-Hung(2013)。教育部提升國民素養專案辦公室研究計劃成果報告教育部提升國民素養專案辦公室研究計劃成果報告,臺北市=Taipei:教育部=Ministry of Education。
8. 林炎全（2006）。數學史料融入數學教學引例。取自 http://210.70.9.16/moodle/file.php/241/_.doc 【Lin, Yan-Chyuan (2006). Instructional examples of HPM-integrated lesson. Retrieved from http://210.70.9.16/moodle/file.php/241/_.doc (in Chinese)】
9. 洪萬生, Wann-Sheng(2001)。參加一九九六年 HPM 研討會有感。HPM 通訊，4(5)，1-4。
10. 洪萬生, Wann-Sheng(1999)。HPM 隨筆（二）：數學史與數學的教與學。HPM 通訊，2(4)，1-3。
11. 洪萬生, Wann-Sheng(2004)。數學史如何呈現。科學月刊，35(12)，1002-1004。
12. 洪萬生, Wann-Sheng(1998)。發刊詞。HPM 通訊，1(1)，1-1。
13. 張俊忠, Jun-Zhong(2015)。武漢市=Wuhan，華中師範大學=Central China Normal University。
14. 楊騰凱（2016 年 11 月 29 日）。TIMSS 調查：台灣 8 年級學生數學能力全球第 3。中時電子報。取自 https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20161129006870-260405?chdtv【Yang, TengKai (2016, November 29). TIMSS survey: Taiwan$$@@s eighth-graders having the third place in mathematics ability in the world. Chinatimes. Retrieved from https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20161129006870-260405?chdtv (in Chinese)】

1. 蔡文榮,宋如婷(2020)。臺灣學位論文中以數學史融入國中數學之教育研究現況分析。教育科學期刊，19(2)，1-16。
2. 蔡文榮,宋如婷(2022)。數學史融入教學之國內外博碩士論文之文字探勘。教育科學期刊，21(2)，25-66。
3. 蔡政樺,秦爾聰(2021)。建構SOTO分類法並探討其評價高中數學教學之蘊涵。臺灣數學教育期刊，8(2)，1-42。
4. 蘇意雯(2021)。中小學數學史教案開發與實作研究。臺灣數學教育期刊，8(1)，27-53。
5. (2024)。數學史與數學教育課程的STEAM實踐研究。教育研究與實踐學刊，71(1)，57-83。