集體效能對社區居民犯罪恐懼影響之研究

The Research of the Effect of Collective Efficacy on Community Residents' Fear of Crime

10.29607/ZHWHGX.200712.0005

翁國峰(Guo-Fong Weng)

集體效能 ； 犯罪恐懼 ； 生活品質 ； 被害經驗 ； collective efficacy ； fear of crime ； life quality ； victimized experiences

犯罪學期刊

10卷2期（2007 / 12 / 01）

115 - 143

繁體中文

近十年來在犯罪學領域以集體效能爲主軸概念，探討與社區犯罪率、失序、治安等關聯的文獻有愈來愈多趨勢。然而集體效能的效果，在各項研究中並不一致。例如集體效能對於犯罪恐懼的影響，即有直接、間接效果的爭議。本文迥異於一般集體效能研究，不以西方而是以東方社區爲標的，使用中央研究院社會所第四期第二次台灣社會變遷調查資本作爲分析樣本，首次分析華人地區的集體效能現象。分析結果發現個人對集體效能感知與犯罪恐懼有直接與顯著的影響，但是「有較高集體效能知覺的社區居民，其被害恐懼亦較高」，此結果與國外學者例如，Gibson, Ghao and Lovrich (2002)等之研究結論恰好相反。筆者認爲對於犯罪 恐懼的表達上，東西方在文化認知與情感經驗傳達模式的差異，是值得深入思索的課題。 除了集體效能之外，本文也分別以性別、年齡、治安知覺、生活品質變遷與被害經驗等變項，作爲預測社區居民犯罪被害恐懼知覺因子，多數結果均符合理論與原先之研究假設預期，並印證台灣社區居民之被害恐懼影響，代理經驗成份高於個人主觀認知。

In the recent decade in the criminology domain take the collective efficacy as the key concept, discussions on the community crime rate, social disorder and security related articles are getting more popular. However, the effects on the collective efficacy vary in the researches done. Such as the debates on whether collective potency has direct or indirect influence on the fear of crime. This research differs from regular research norm on collective efficacy. Citing the academic sinica's 4th Issue on 2nd Taiwan Societal Change Investigation as the analysis sample, it reveals the collective efficacy effects in the chinese community. Analysis results reveal the direct and noticeable effects on collective efficacy perception and fear of crime on an individual. However, those communities with higher collective efficacy perception has also a higher rate of fear of being harm. This research conclusion is different from foreign researchers such as Gibson, Ghao and Lovrich (2002). The author believes that in the expression on fear of crime, differences on cultural cognition of the East and West and communication of emotional experiences, is to be taken into serious consideration as well. Besides collective efficacy, this research also distinguishes categories on sex, age and security perception, life quality changes and victimized experiences. So as to forecast the causual perception on community civilians of being victimized, most results are accord with the theories and prior research expectations. Proofing the phobic effects of Taiwanese communities, the proxy experiences are higher than individual subjective cognition.

1. 李素馨(1999)。都市住宅社區型式與居民被害恐懼感關係之研究。都市與計劃，27，22-45。
   連結：
2. 陳淑娟、董旭英(2006)。個人犯罪被害恐懼感影響因素之研究。犯罪學期刊，9，31-52。
   連結：
3. Adams Richard E.,Serpe Richard T.(2000).Social Integration , Fear of Crime and Life Satisification.Sociological Perspectives,43,605-629.
4. Baumer, Eric P.(2002).Neighborhood Disadvantage and Police Notification by Victims of Violence.Criminology,40,579-616.
5. Browning Christopher R.,Cagney Kathleen A.(2003).Moving Beyond Poverty: Neighborhood Structure, Social Processes, and Health.Journal of Health and Social Behavior,44,552-571.
6. Garofalo, James.(1981).The Fear of Crime: Causes and Consequences.The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology,72,839-857.
7. Gibson, Zhao, Lovrich,Gaffney(2002).Social Integration, Individual Perceptions of Collective Efficacy, and Fear of Crime in Three Cities.Justice Quarterly,19,537-564.
8. Hagan John,MacMillan Ross,Blair Wheaton(1996).Kid in Town: Social Capital and the Life Course Effects of Family Migration on Children.American Journal of Sociology,61,368-385.
9. Jackson, Jonathan.(2005).Validating New Measusres of the Fear of Crime.Social Research Methodology,4,297-315.
10. Jackson, Jonathan.(2004).Experience and Expression: Social and Cultrual Signification in the Fear of Crime.British Journal of Criminology,44,946-966.
11. LaGrange Randy L.,Ferraro Kenneth F.,Supancic Michael(1992).Perceived Risk and Fear of Crime: Role of Social and Physical Incivilities.Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency,29,311-334.
12. Lee, Matthew R.(2000).Community Cohesion and Violent Predatory Victimization: A Theoretical Extention and Cross-national Test of Opportunity Theory.Social Forces,79,683-688.
13. Lindstrom, Martin(2006).Psychosocial work conditions, social particpation and social capital: A causal pathway investigated in a longitudional study.Social Science & Medicine,62,280-291.
14. Logi, Kristjansson Alfgeir.(2007).On Social Equality and Perception of Insecuity: A Comparison Study between Two European Countries.European Journal of Criminology,4,59-86.
15. Pamela Wilcox,Neil Quisenberry,Shayne Jones(2003).The Built Environment and Community Crime Risk Interpration.Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency,40,322-345.
16. Poortinga, Wouter.(2006).Social Relations or Social Capital? Individual and Community Health Effects of Bonding Social Capital.Social Science & Medicine,63,255-270.
17. Quillian Lincoln,Pager Devah(2001).Black Neighbors, Higher Crime? The Role of Racial Stereotypes in Evaluations of Neighborhood Crime.American Journal of Sociology,107,717-767.
18. Robert J. Sampson,Jeffery D. Morenoff,Felton Earls.(1999).Beyond Social Capital: Spacial Dynamics of Collective Efficacy for Children.American Journal of Sociology,64,633-660.
19. Ross, Macmillan.(2001).Violence and the Life Course:The Consequences of Victimization for Personal and Social Development.Annual Review of Sociology,27,1-22.
20. Sampson, Robert J.(1999).Systematic Social Observation of Public Spaces: A New Look at Disorder in Urban Neighborhoods.American Journal of Sociology,105,603-651.
21. Schafer Joseph A.,Beth M. Huebner,Bynum Timothy S.(2006).Fear of Crime and Criminal Victimization: Gender-Based Contrasts.Journal of Criminal Justice,34,285-301.
22. Sharkey, Patrick T.(2006).Navigating Dangerous Streets: The Sources and Consequences of Street Efficacy.American Sociological Review,71,826-846.
23. Shinn Marybeth,Toohey Siobhan M.(2005).Community Contexts of Human Welfare.Annual Reviews of Psychology,54,427-459.
24. Simons Ronald L.,Leslie Gordon Simons,Burt Callie Harbin,Brody Gene H.,Cutrona Carolyn(2005).Collective Efficacy, Authoriative Parenting and Delinquency: A LongitudinalL Test of A Model Iintegrating Community-and Family-Level Processes.Criminology,43,989-1029.
25. Thorlindsson Thorolfur,Bernburg Jon Gunnar.(2004).Durkheim`s Theory of Social Order and Deviance: a Multi-level Test.European Sociological Review,20,271-285.
26. Warner, Barbara D.(2007).Directly Intervene of Call the Authorities? A Study of Forms of Neighborhood Social Control Within A Social Disorganization Framework.Criminology,45,16-37.
27. Warr Mark,Ellison Chirstopher G.(2000).Rethinking Social Reactions to Crime: Personal and Altruistic Fear in Family Households.American Journal of Sociology,106,551-578.
28. Watkins, Adam M.(2005).Examining the Disparity Between Juvenile and Adult Victims in Notifiying the Police: A Study of Mediating Variables.Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency,42,333-353.
29. Wells William,Schafer Joseph A.,Bynum Timothy S.(2006).Neighborhood Resident's Production of Order: The Effects of Collective Efficacy on Response to Neighborhood Problems.Cime & Delinquency,52,523-550.
30. 李碧玲(2004)。嘉義，中正大學犯罪防治研究所。
31. 黃虹如(2005)。以犯罪被害恐懼看民衆對社會治安之觀感。透視犯罪問題，5，12-29。

1. 洪偉濠(2016)。搭乘大眾捷運系統恐懼迴避行為之量測與影響因素-以臺北捷運為例。交通大學運輸與物流管理學系學位論文。2016。1-73。