數位出版產業編輯人才前編輯職能之研究

The Study on Pre-Editing Competence for Digital Publishing Editors

徐明珠(Ming-Ju Hsu)；賀秋白(Chiu-Pai Ho)

數位出版 ； 編輯 ； 前編輯 ； 職能 ； digital publishing ； editor ； pre-editing ； competence

中華印刷科技年報

2013（2013 / 06 / 01）

169 - 184

繁體中文

The editing workflow including three stages: the pre-editing, editing and post-editing. Pre-editing stage is the must-have journey prior to manuscript processing, and establishing the foundation of the quality of publications. In this study, aimed at investigate the editing competences of pre-editing stage of the digital publishing, as the reference of competence checklist for editorial professionals. This study used literature analysis, Delphi Technique and expert interviews to obtain three (3) dimensions and 18 competence indicators of the pre-editing competence for digital publishing editors. The three (3) dimensions were Commissioning and Acquisitions, Developing Digital Contents and Copy Editing. The 18 competence indicators were ”Selecting publishable topic by studying marketing data”, ”Conceive and develop ideas for viable publishing opportunities”, ” Obtain material with legitimate copyright”, ”Arrange and organize graphics, audio and video”, ” Review copyright legality”, ” Review conformity of the content and topic for manuscripts”, etc. The competence indicators were categorized into ”musthave” ( ≧ 4.19), ” should- have” (3.35 ≦ ＜4.19), two groups, according to the result of Delphi Technique questionnaire evaluating the scale ranged from 1 (not important at all) to 5 (very important). There were 9 competences with ”must-have” such as ”Obtain material with legitimate copyright” etc., 9 competences with ”should-have” such as ”Develop and maintain a plan for publishing in line with targets and budget ” etc. The results of this study can be used as the references of Digital Publishing Industry in recruitment, training of editors and relevant organizations for their talent cultivation.

The editing workflow including three stages: the pre-editing, editing and post-editing. Pre-editing stage is the must-have journey prior to manuscript processing, and establishing the foundation of the quality of publications. In this study, aimed at investigate the editing competences of pre-editing stage of the digital publishing, as the reference of competence checklist for editorial professionals. This study used literature analysis, Delphi Technique and expert interviews to obtain three (3) dimensions and 18 competence indicators of the pre-editing competence for digital publishing editors. The three (3) dimensions were Commissioning and Acquisitions, Developing Digital Contents and Copy Editing. The 18 competence indicators were ”Selecting publishable topic by studying marketing data”, ”Conceive and develop ideas for viable publishing opportunities”, ” Obtain material with legitimate copyright”, ”Arrange and organize graphics, audio and video”, ” Review copyright legality”, ” Review conformity of the content and topic for manuscripts”, etc. The competence indicators were categorized into ”musthave” ( ≧ 4.19), ” should- have” (3.35 ≦ ＜4.19), two groups, according to the result of Delphi Technique questionnaire evaluating the scale ranged from 1 (not important at all) to 5 (very important). There were 9 competences with ”must-have” such as ”Obtain material with legitimate copyright” etc., 9 competences with ”should-have” such as ”Develop and maintain a plan for publishing in line with targets and budget ” etc. The results of this study can be used as the references of Digital Publishing Industry in recruitment, training of editors and relevant organizations for their talent cultivation.

1. 王瑤芬、陳素萍(2010)。國際觀光旅館餐飲部中階主管工作職能之研究。餐旅暨家政學刊，7(4)，299-323。
   連結：
2. CHRC (2011). Magazine Publishing - Competency Profile. Cultural Human Resources Council, Canada..
3. CHRC (2011).Training Gaps Analysis – Magazine Publishing in Canada. Cultural Human Resources Council, Canada..
4. CASE (2001). Standards for Editing Practice. Council of Australian Societies of Editors, Australian..
5. CHRC (2006). Chart of Competencies for Book Publishers. Cultural Human Resources Council, Canada..
6. Aysling Digital Media Solutions (2013). Cross-media Digital Publishing. Retrieved from http://www.aysling.com/digital-publishing
7. 行政院勞工委員會職業訓練局(2012)。職業分類資訊查詢系統－各項編輯人員職業簡 介。2012。 取 自 http://www3.evta.gov.tw/odict/srch.htm
8. Association of American Publishers (2013).“Commonly Used Terms: About Editorial etc.”, Association of American Publishers. Retrieved from http://www.bookjobs.com/commonly-used-terms#a88, 2013.
9. UK Creativeskillset (2012). Book and Journal Publishing. Creative Skillset's Standards. National Occupational Standards. U.K..
10. CHRC (2004). Interactive / New Media Content Creator - Competency Profile. Cultural Human Resources Council, Canada..
11. Dalkey, N.C.,Helmer, O.(1963).An Experimental Application of the Delphi Method to the Use of Experts.Management Science,9(3),458-467.
12. Hsu, C.C.,Sandford, B.A.(2007).The Delphi Technique: Making Sense of Consensus.Practical Assessment, Research & Evaluation,12(10)
13. Taylor, S. J.,Bogdan, R.(1984).Introduction to Qualitative Research Methods - The Search for Meanings.New York:John Wiley & Sons.
14. Young, S.J.,Jamieson, L.M.(2001).Delivery Methodology of the Delphi: A Comparison of Two Approaches.Journal of Park and Recreation Administration,19(1),42-58.
15. 王煒(2003)。論當代編輯職業技能的優化和提高。現代出版理論與實務，武漢市:
16. 王歡(2012)。論數字時代編輯出版業的人才需求。中國報業，2012(12)
17. 朴明珠(2010)。網路環境下期刊編輯流程新特點及應對策略研究。新聞界，2010(3)
18. 朱高建(1998)。關於編輯學的幾個概念。渝州大學學報
19. 吳文(2012)。淺談科技期刊編輯的職業素質。科技創新導報，2012(24)，250-252。
20. 吳莉菲(2012)。出版人才，與時俱進─淺析數字時代編輯出版人才的必備素養。青年文學家，2012(16)，225-227。
21. 吳蘭芳(2003)。選題策劃的全程性及其思考─從策劃《非典剋星》個案談起。現代出版理論與實務，武漢市:
22. 林章波(2012)。出版業改制與出版業信息化管理探索。中國管理信息化，15(24)，51-52。
23. 施純協、李基常、何宏發、吳明果(1996)。高級職業學校工科畢業生應具備之資訊能力分析研究。全國技術及職業教育研討會論文集
24. 宮承波、要力石(2007)。出版策劃。北京:中國廣播電視出版社。
25. 徐明珠(2013)。人才培育是兩岸發展數位出版產業的後盾。交流雜誌，2013(2 月號)，50-53。
26. 張積玉(2003)。編輯學新論。北京:中國社會科學出版社。
27. 曹麗華(2011)。數字出版時代編輯人員素養探討。管理工程師，2011(04)，15-17。
28. 欽建軍、王克明(2011)。做好六項準備，應對出版轉型。產權導刊，2011(12)，51-53。
29. 馮會平(2003)。試論編輯的信息意識。現代出版理論與實務，湖北:
30. 葛君(2002)。綜合策劃─圖書出版系統的靈魂。第 3 屆全國出版科學研究優秀論文獲獎論文集，武漢市:
31. 劉靜(2012)。淺談新形勢下圖書編輯知識能力的構建。職業時空，8(11)，73-75。
32. 歐陽明(2006)。書刊編輯學。武漢市:華中科技大學出版社。
33. 蔣學東(2012)。論網路環境給期刊編輯工作帶來的機遇和挑戰。鐵道科學與工程學報，2012(06)
34. 鄭一奇(2002)。試論選題策劃的必要性與限制性。第3 屆全國出版科學研究優秀論文獲獎論文集，武漢市:
35. 賴紅柳(2011)。數字時代的年鑒編纂與出版。廣西地方誌，2011(2)，36-39。
36. 魏龍泉、邵岩(2007)。縱覽美國圖書出版與發行。中國經濟出版社。

1. 賀秋白、徐明珠(2015)。圖文傳播系所學生數位出版編輯能力量表之編製與檢定。中華印刷科技年報，2015，143-163。
2. 賀秋白、徐明珠(2016)。大學圖文傳播相關系所學生自我評量數位出版內容端編輯能力。藝術學報，98，233-262。
3. 徐明珠(2014)。數位出版產業編輯人才職能地圖之研究。教育資料與圖書館學，51(3)，479-493。