教練威權領導一定不好嗎？一項權變概念的提出與驗證

Does Authoritarian Leadership Lead to Bad Outcomes? A Contingency Perspective

10.6129/CJP.201906_61(2).0002

鄭昱宏(Yu-Hung Cheng)；周婉茹(Wan-Ju Chou)；周德賢(Te-Hsien Chou)；鄭伯壎(Bor-Shiuan Cheng)

目標導向 ； 努力行為 ； 威權領導 ； 運動團隊 ； 領導權變理論 ； authoritarian leadership ； contingency theory ； effort ； goal orientation ； sport team

中華心理學刊

61卷2期（2019 / 06 / 01）

97 - 129

繁體中文;英文

在運動團隊的相關研究中，教練採取嚴格的控制手段要求選手在訓練中付出努力，是十分常見的現象。過往亦有不少研究者從威權領導的理論觀點切入來探討此一現象，然而，儘管這些研究已累積了初步的研究成果，但多侷限於相似概念的質性訪談，沒有直接以實徵研究來釐清教練威權領導與選手努力行為的關係。因此，對於威權領導是否真的能促使選手付出更多努力，仍缺乏一明確的答案，形成了重要的研究缺口。為了彌補此一缺口，本研究依循雙向度威權領導的概念架構，將之區分為專權領導與尚嚴領導，並從領導權變觀點出發，提出了選手的目標導向作為邊界條件的理論模型。根據348筆大專甲組棒球員的資料顯示，尚嚴領導會提升選手的努力行為；但當選手擁有高逃避表現目標導向或高證明表現目標導向時，此一正向路徑的效果會弱化。另一方面，只有在選手擁有低證明表現目標導向時，專權領導才會對選手的努力行為具有負向預測效果。藉此，本研究釐清了教練的嚴格控制是否會促使選手更加努力，補足過往對此一重要現象缺乏實徵研究的缺口。

Previous studies on the sports team have mainly focused on the common phenomenon that coaches take strict control to require players to work hard in training. Many researchers have explored this phenomenon from the theoretical perspective of authoritarian leadership. Although these studies have accumulated preliminary results, they are mostly limited to qualitative interviews, but not directly examine the relationship between coaches' authoritarian leadership style and players' effort. Therefore, whether the authoritarian leadership can really encourage the players to put more efforts in training is still a puzzle and an important research void. In order to fulfill this void, this study adapts the dual dimensional model of authoritarian leadership, dividing authoritarian leadership into dominance-focus authoritarian leadership and discipline-focus authoritarian leadership. Also, taking the perspective of leadership contingency theory, we propose that player's goal orientation is an important boundary condition. According to the data of 348 college players, discipline-focus authoritarian leadership enhances the player's hard work; and the impact becomes nonsignificant when the player has a high avoid performance goal orientation or a high prove performance goal orientation. On the other hand, dominance-focus authoritarian leadership has a negative impact on the player's hard work behavior only if the player has a low prove performance goal orientation. In this way, this study clarifies whether the strict control of the coach really encourages the players to work harder and fulfill the lack of research in the past for this important phenomenon.

1. Chou, W. J.,Cheng, B. S.(2014).Opening the black box: A two-dimensional model of authoritarian leadership and task performance.Chinese Journal of Psychology,56(4),397-414.
   連結：
2. Chou, W. J.,Cheng, B. S.(2014).Opening the black box: A two-dimensional model of authoritarian leadership and task performance.Chinese Journal of Psychology,56(4),397-414.
   連結：
3. 吳國銑, K. S.,陳廖霞, L. S.(2009)。運動教練應用轉型領導之策略。大專體育，101，97-105。
   連結：
4. 卓國雄, K. H.(2016)。運動情境中害怕失敗與 2×2 成就目標之因果關係驗證。國立台灣體育運動大學學報，5(1)，47-75。
   連結：
5. 周婉茹, W. J.,周麗芳, L. F.,鄭伯壎, B. S.,任金剛, C. K.(2010)。專權與尚嚴之辨：再探威權領導的內涵與恩威並濟的效果。本土心理學研究，34，223-284。
   連結：
6. 周婉茹, W. J.,鄭伯壎, B. S.,連玉輝, Y. H.(2014)。威權領導：概念源起、現況檢討及未來方向。中華心理學刊，56(2)，165-189。
   連結：
7. 林宛曉, W. S.,季力康, L. K(2008)。運動教練領導模式之探討：以交易和轉型領導為例。大專體育，99，156-162。
   連結：
8. 林姿葶, T. T.,鄭伯壎, B. S.(2007)。性別與領導角色孰先孰後？主管－部屬性別配對、共事時問及家長式領導。中華心理學刊，49，433-450。
   連結：
9. 高三福, S. F.(2007)。運動領導理論的發展及可行的研究方向。中華體育季刊，21(1)，59-66。
   連結：
10. 高三福, S. F.陳鈺芳, Y. F.(2006)。運動教練的教誨領導：高中運動團隊的個案研究。大專體育學刊，8(1)，97-111。
    連結：
11. 涂志賢, C. H.(2000)。運動教練領導風格對選手成績表現與滿意度影響之研究。體育學報，28，45-58。
    連結：
12. 康正男, C. N.(2005)。棒球運動教練領導行為之探討－概念建構與模式分析。體育學報，38(4)，53-68。
    連結：
13. 康正男, C. N.(2006)。棒球總教練威權領導與選手效能之研究：職棒與業餘之比較。大專體育學刊，8(1)，112-123。
    連結：
14. 曾建興, C. H.,林彥伯, Y. P.(2008)。家長式領導行為對大學棒球選手運動倦怠之影響。北體學報，16，26-37。
    連結：
15. 曾秋美, C. M.,王俊明, C. M.(2011)。家長式領導對大專體育科系運動代表隊團隊氣氛及競技倦怠的影響。長榮運動休閒學刊，5，93-112。
    連結：
16. 湯慧娟, H. C.,宋一夫, Y. F.(2004)。教練家長式領導，團隊文化價值觀對團隊承諾之影響研究。體育學報，36，119-130。
    連結：
17. 樊景立, J. L.,鄭伯壎, B. S.(2000)。華人組織的家長式領導：一項文化觀點的分析。本土心理學研究，13，126-180。
    連結：
18. 蔡英美, Y. M.(2005)。家長式領導、情緒感受與團隊凝聚力之關係研究。國立體育學院論叢，16(2)，347-358。
    連結：
19. 鄭秀貴, H. K.,高麗娟, L. C.(2008)。威權、仁慈、德行家長式領導：李瑞麟教練之個案研究。北體學報，16，157-170。
    連結：
20. 謝宛君, W. J.,高三福, S. F.,呂雲梅, Y. M.(2008)。教練威權領導的比較與省思。中華體育季刊，22(3)，67-72。
    連結：
21. 簡晉龍, C. L.,黃囇莉, L. L.(2015)。華人權威取向之內涵與形成歷程。本土心理學研究，43，55-123。
    連結：
22. Amorose, A. J.,Anderson-Butcher, D.(2015).Exploring the independent and interactive effects of autonomy-supportive and controlling coaching behaviors on adolescent athletes’ motivation for sport.Sport, Exercise, and Performance Psychology,4(3),206-218.
23. Amorose, A. J.,Horn, T. S.(2000).Intrinsic motivation: Relationships with collegiate athletes’ gender, scholarship status, and perceptions of their coaches’ behavior.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,22(1),63-84.
24. Arthur, C. A.,Woodman, T.,Ong, C. W.,Hardy, L.,Ntoumanis, N.(2011).The role of athlete narcissism in moderating the relationship between coaches’ transformational leader behaviors and athlete motivation.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,33(1),3-19.
25. Asghar, E.,Wang, X.,Linde, K.,Alfermann, D.(2013).Comparisons between Asian and German male adolescent athletes on goal orientation, physical self-concept, and competitive anxiety.International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,11(3),229-243.
26. Baker, J.,Côté, J.,Hawes, R.(2000).The relationship between coaching behaviors and sport anxiety in athletes.Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport,3(2),110-119.
27. Barcza-Renner, K.,Eklund, R. C.,Morin, A. J.,Habeeb, C. M.(2016).Controlling coaching behaviors and athlete burnout: Investigating the mediating roles of perfectionism and motivation.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,38(1),30-44.
28. Bartholomew, K. J.,Ntoumanis, N.,ThoØgersen-Ntoumani, C.(2008).A review of controlling motivational strategies from a self-determination theory perspective: Implications for sports coaches.International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology,2(2),215-233.
29. Bray, C. D.,Whaley, D. E.(2001).Team cohesion, effort, and objective individual performance of high school basketball players.The Sport Psychologist,15(3),260-275.
30. Brown, S. P.,Leigh, T. W.(1996).A new look at psychological climate and its relationship to job involvement, effort, and performance.Journal of Applied Psychology,81(4),358-368.
31. Butler, R.(1992).What young people want to know when: Effects of mastery and ability goals on interest in different kinds of social comparisons.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,62(6),934-943.
32. Cellar, D. F.,Stuhlmacher, A. F.,Young, S. K.,Fisher, D. M.,Adair, C. K.,Haynes, S.(2011).Trait goal orientation, self-regulation, and performance: A meta-analysis.Journal of Business and Psychology,26(4),467-483.
33. Chang, S. J.,van Witteloostuijn, A.,Eden, L.(2010).From the editors: Common method variance in international business research.Journal of International Business Studies,41(2),178-184.
34. Cohen, J.,Cohen, P.(1983).Applied multiple regression/correlations analysis for the behavioral sciences.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
35. Cranmer, G. A.,Brann, M.,Weber, K. D.(2018).Challenge Me!”using confirmation theory to understand coach confirmation as an effective coaching behavior.Communication and Sport,6(2),239-259.
36. Deci, E. L.,Ryan, R. M.(1985).The general causality orientations scale: Self-determination in personality.Journal of Research in Personality,19(2),109-134.
37. Dietz, B.,van Knippenberg, D.,Hirst, G.,Restubog, S. L. D.(2015).Outperforming whom? A multilevel study of performance-prove goal orientation, performance, and the moderating role of shared team identification.Journal of Applied Psychology,100(6),1811-1824.
38. Duda, J. L.(Ed.)(1998).Advances in sport and exercise psychology measurement.Morgantown, WV:Fitness Information Technology.
39. Duda, J. L.,White, S. A.(1992).Goal orientations and beliefs about the causes of sport success among elite skiers.Sport Psychologist,6(4),334-343.
40. Dweck, C. S.(1999).Self theories: Their role in motivation, personality, and development.Philadelphia, PA:Psychology Press.
41. Dweck, C. S.(1986).Motivational processes affecting learning.American Psychologist,41(10),1040-1048.
42. Elliot, A. J.(Ed.),Dweck, C. S.(Ed.)(2005).Handbook of competence and motivation.New York:Guilford Press.
43. Fredrickson, B. L.(2001).The role of positive emotions in positive psychology: The broaden-and-build theory of positive emotions.American Psychologist,56(3),218-226.
44. Gilbert, W. D.,Trudel, P.(2004).Role of the coach: How model youth team sport coaches frame their roles.The Sport Psychologist,18(1),21-43.
45. Gist, M. E.,Mitchell, T. R.(1992).Self-efficacy: A theoretical analysis of its determinants and malleability.Academy of Management Review,17(2),183-211.
46. Gjesdal, S.,Haug, E. M.,Ommundsen, Y.(2018).A conditional process analysis of the coach-created mastery climate, task goal orientation, and competence satisfaction in youth soccer: The moderating role of controlling coach behavior.Journal of Applied Sport Psychology,31(2),203-217.
47. Gråstén, A.,Forsman, H.,Watt, A.(2018).The associations and development of motivational climate, achievement goals, and physical functional skills in young floorball players.International Journal of Sports Science and Coaching,13(6),958-967.
48. Gucciardi, D. F.,Stamatis, A.,Ntoumanis, N.(2017).Controlling coaching and athlete thriving in elite adolescent netballers: The buffering effect of athletes’ mental toughness.Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport,20(8),718-722.
49. Hackman, J. R.,Oldham, G. R.(1976).Motivation through the design of work: Test of a theory.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,16(2),250-279.
50. Hanrahan, S. J.,Cerin, E.(2009).Gender, level of participation, and type of sport: Differences in achievement goal orientation and attributional style.Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport,12(4),508-512.
51. Hayes, A. F.(2018).Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach.New York, NY:Guilford Press.
52. Heyman, G. D.,Dweck, C. S.(1992).Achievement goals and intrinsic motivation: Their relation and their role in adaptive motivation.Motivation and Emotion,16(3),231-247.
53. Hollembeak, J.,Amorose, A. J.(2005).Perceived coaching behaviors and college athletes’ intrinsic motivation: A test of self-determination theory.Journal of Applied Sport Psychology,17(1),20-36.
54. Horn, T. S.(Ed.)(2008).Advances in sport psychology.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
55. Jaakkola, T.,Ntoumanis, N.,Liukkonen, J.(2015).Motivational climate, goal orientation, perceived sport ability, and enjoyment within finnish junior ice hockey players.Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports,26(1),109-115.
56. Jenkins, S.(2014).John R. Wooden, Stephen R. Covey and Servant Leadership.International Journal of Sports Science and Coaching,9(1),1-24.
57. Kavussanu, M.,Roberts, G. C.(1996).Motivation in physical activity contexts: The relationship of perceived motivational climate to intrinsic motivation and self-efficacy.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,18(3),264-280.
58. Klein, K. J.(Ed.),Kozlowski, S. W. J.(Ed.)(2000).Multilevel theory, research, and methods in organizations: Foundations, extensions, and new directions.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
59. Lochbaum, M.,Çetinkalp, Z. K.,Graham, K. A.,Wright, T.,Zazo, R.(2016).Task and ego goal orientations in competitive sport: A quantitative review of the literature from 1989 to 2016.Kinesiology: International Journal of Fundamental and Applied Kinesiology,48(1),3-29.
60. Lochbaum, M.,Jean-Noel, J.,Pinar, C.,Gilson, T.(2017).A meta-analytic review of Elliot's (1999) Hierarchical Model of Approach and Avoidance Motivation in the sport, physical activity, and physical education literature.Journal of Sport and Health Science,6(1),68-80.
61. Locke, E. A.(1968).Toward a theory of task motivation and incentives.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,3(2),157-189.
62. Locke, E. A.,Bryan, J. F.(1966).Cognitive aspects of psychomotor performance: The effects of performance goals on level of performance.Journal of Applied Psychology,50(4),286-291.
63. Locke, E. A.,Latham, G. P.(1990).A theory of goal setting and task performance.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice Hall.
64. Mageau, G. A.,Vallerand, R. J.(2003).The coach- athlete relationship : A motivational model.Journal of Sports Science,21(11),883-904.
65. Marcone, M,(2017).Kinesiology, Sport Studies, and Physical Education Synthesis ProjectsKinesiology, Sport Studies, and Physical Education Synthesis Projects,未出版
66. Matosic, D.,Cox, A. E.,Amorose, A. J.(2014).Scholarship status, controlling coaching behavior, and intrinsic motivation in collegiate swimmers: A test of cognitive evaluation theory.Sport, Exercise, and Performance Psychology,3(1),1-12.
67. Meissel, K.,Rubie-Davies, C. M.(2016).Cultural invariance of goal orientation and self efficacy in New Zealand: Relations with achievement.British Journal of Educational Psychology,86(1),92-111.
68. Mouratidis, A.,Vansteenkiste, M.,Lens, W.,Sideridis, G.(2008).The motivating role of positive feedback in sport and physical education: Evidence for a motivational model.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,30(2),240-268.
69. Nicholls, J. G.(1989).The competitive ethos and democratic education.Boston, MA:Harvard University Press.
70. Nicholls, J. G.(1984).Achievement motivation: Conceptions of ability, subjective experience, task choice, and performance.Psychological Review,91(3),328-346.
71. Ommundsen, Y.(2004).Self-handicapping related to task and performance-approach and avoidance goals in physical education.Journal of Applied Sport Psychology,16(2),183-197.
72. Parsons, T.(1968).The structure of social action.New York, NY:Free Press.
73. Pelletier, L. G.,Fortier, M. S.,Vallerand, R. J.,Briere, N. M.(2001).Associations among perceived autonomy support, forms of self-regulation, and persistence: A prospective study.Motivation and Emotion,25(4),279-306.
74. Pintrich, P.,Maehr, M.(Ed.)(1997).Advances in motivation and achievement.Stamford, CT:JAI Press.
75. Podsakoff, P. M.,MacKenzie, S. B.,Lee, J. Y.,Podsakoff, N. P.(2003).Common method biases in behavioral research: A critical review of the literature and recommended remedies.Journal of Applied Psychology,88(5),879-903.
76. Redding, S. G.,Hsiao, M.(1990).An empirical study of overseas Chinese managerial ideology.International Journal of Psychology,25(3-6),629-641.
77. Roberts, G. C.(Ed.)(2001).Advances in motivation in exercise and sport.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
78. Roberts, G. C.(Ed.)(1992).Motivation in sport and exercise.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
79. Roberts, G. C.,Ommundsen, Y.(1996).Effect of goal orientations on achievement beliefs, cognitions, and strategies in team sport.Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sport,6(1),46-56.
80. Roberts, G. C.,Treasure, D. C.,Balague, G.(1998).Achievement goals in sport: The development and validation of the Perception of Success Questionnaire.Journal of Sport Sciences,16(4),337-347.
81. Roberts, G. C.,Treasure, D. C.,Kavussanu, M.(1996).Orthogonality of achievement goals and its relationship to beliefs about success and satisfaction in sport.Sport Psychologist,10(4),398-408.
82. Salancik, G.,Pfeffer, J.(1978).A social information processing approach to job attitudes and task design.Administrative Science Quarterly,23(2),224-253.
83. Silin, R. H.(1976).Leadership and values: The organization of large-scale Taiwanese enterprises.Boston, MA:Harvard University Asia Center.
84. Singer, R. N.(Ed.),Hausenblas, H. A.(Ed.),Janelle, C. M.(Ed.)(2001).Handbook of sport psychology.New York, NY:Wiley.
85. Snyder, C. M.,Brewer, B. W.(1994).A between-sport analysis of peak performance characteristics.Applied Research in Coaching and Athletics Annual,96-105.
86. Spreitzer, G. M.(1996).Social structural characteristics of psychological empowerment.Academy of Management Journal,39(2),483-504.
87. Tenenbaum, G.(Ed.),Eklund, R. C.(Ed.)(2007).Handbook of sport psychology.Hoboken, NJ:Wiley.
88. Trenz, R. C.,Zusho, A.(2011).Competitive swimmers’ perception of motivational climate and their personal achievement goals.International Journal of Sports Science and Coaching,6(3),433-443.
89. Van de Pol, P. K.,Kavussanu, M.,Ring, C.(2012).Goal orientations, perceived motivational climate, and motivational outcomes in football: A comparison between training and competition contexts.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,13(4),491-499.
90. Van Yperen, N. W,Duda, J. L.(1999).Goal orientations, beliefs about success, and performance improvement among young elite Dutch soccer players.Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports,9(6),358-364.
91. VandeWalle, D.(1997).Development and validation of a work domain goal orientation instrument.Educational and Psychological Measurement,57(6),995-1015.
92. Wang, C. J.,Koh, K. T.,Chatzisarantis, N.(2009).An intra-individual analysis of players’ perceived coaching behaviours, psychological needs, and achievement goals.International Journal of Sports Science & Coaching,4(2),177-192.
93. Westwood, R.(1997).Harmony and patriarchy: The cultural basis for paternalistic headship among the overseas Chinese.Organization Studies,18(3),445-480.
94. 汪在莒, T. C.,賴文璇, W. S.(2010)。教練轉型領導行為對拔河選手成就目標、運動參與動機與組織承諾之結構模式。大專體育學術專刊，99，452-459。
95. 符碧真, B. J.(2005)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告,台北=Taipei:國家科學委員會=National Science Council。
96. 連玉輝, Y. H.,Huang, J.,鄭伯壎, B. S.。頂尖運動員的生涯成長與教練的家長式領導：一項動態歷程的分析。本土心理學研究
97. 陳怡儒, Y. J.(2004)。桃園=Toayuan，國立體育學院教練研究所=National Taiwan Sport University。
98. 黃忠榮（2009）。王貞治：別當所有選手喜歡的教練。自由體育。取自 http://sports.ltn.com.tw/news/paper/313902。[Huang, Z. R. (2009, June 25). Wang zhen zhi: Bie dang suoyou xuanshou xihuan de jiaolian. The Liberty Times. Retrieved from http://sports.ltn.com.tw/news/paper/313902]
99. 楊國樞（編）, K. S.(Ed.),黃光國（編）, K. K.(Ed.),楊中芳（編）, C. F.(Ed.)(2005).華人本土心理學.台北=Taipei:遠流=Yuan-Liou.
100. 蔡英美, Y. M.,王俊明, C. M.(2008)。大專甲組選手知覺的家長式領導、情緒感受、團隊承諾及團隊凝聚力之研究。文化體育學刊，6(6)，91-99。
101. 鄭伯壎, B. S.(1995)。家長權威與領導行為之關係：一個台灣民營企業主持人的個案研究。中央研究院民族學研究所集刊，79，105-159。

1. 費吳琛,周婉茹,李啓文,李庭閣(2023)。部屬啊！您有做自己的機會嗎？尚嚴、專權雙元領導與部屬任務績效之關聯性：以情緒調節策略揭開潘朵拉的盒子。組織與管理，16(2)，69-130。
2. 黃義翔,張家銘(2023)。運動情境中威權領導行為之探討。嘉大體育健康休閒期刊，22(2)，93-105。
3. 潘緯澄,葛記豪,高三福,李伯倫(2022)。教練二元威權領導與選手心理韌性的關聯：認知信任與情感信任的中介效果。大專體育學刊，24(4)，481-494。
4. 鄭昱宏,鄭伯壎,連玉輝,高三福(2020)。轉型領導與家長式領導在運動領導研究的回顧與展望。中華心理學刊，62(2)，267-298。
5. 鄭昱宏,周德賢,周婉茹(2023)。百折不撓還是一蹶不振？從資源保存理論探討雙元威權領導的作用效果。管理學報，40(1)，31-56。
6. 鄭昱宏,周婉茹(2023)。從西方到東方：教練嚴格要求行為的觀點轉移。中華心理學刊，65(4)，327-352。
7. (2023)。教練的威權領導與選手的情緒及行為：選手認知評估因應之觀點。交大體育學刊，19，56-72。
8. (2023)。主管對部屬不信任、威權領導與LMX：智力增進信念與印象管理的調節作用。應用心理研究，79，57-110。
9. (2024)。比較不同文化背景的控制型教練行為。大專體育，167，1-16。
10. (2024)。威權領導範型的效果比較：個人中心取向觀點。中華心理學刊，66(2)，247-276。