鄉村地區綠色運輸衡量指標之建構與評估：以宜蘭縣為例

Green Transportation Index Construction and Evaluation for Rural Area: A Case Study of Yilan County

10.6128/CP.42.4.455

李家儂(Chia-Nung Li)

綠色運輸 ； 鄉村地區 ； 灰色理論 ； 分析網絡程序法 ； Green Transportation ； Rural area ； Grey theory ； Analytic Network Process

都市與計劃

42卷4期（2015 / 12 / 31）

455 - 485

繁體中文

近年來隨著臺灣可用土地取得困難，且民眾對於運具使用、運輸建設所導致的空氣污染、能源消耗、生態環境等課題日益嚴重，因此交通部將「發展綠色運輸系統」列為運輸部門節能減碳策略方向之一。過去雖然交通部運輸研究所有針對都市計畫階段之綠色運輸衡量指標進行探討，並研訂都市計畫案綠色運輸衡量指標，但隨著各類交通建設推展，各地所推行的捷運系統皆逐漸將服務範圍延伸到都市計畫地區以外的鄉村地區，因此全臺廣大的鄉村地區亦需要有相應的指標，供未來規劃者研擬相關運輸建設時之參考。故本研究建立綠色運輸衡量指標，評估其綠色運輸效益，並將焦點著重於過去較為缺乏的鄉村地區指標擬定。依據綠色運輸相關文獻回顧，以專家問卷方式，應用自擬的 Grey-ANP灰色分析網絡程序法進行探討。分析結果，以目的地可及性面向之權重值為最高，其次則分別為轉乘距離與土地使用多元性。實證部分則以宜蘭縣四個具相近特性之鄉村地區為例，比較其綠色運輸發展現況的差異。實證結果，礁溪鄉略優於五結鄉、冬山鄉，但彼此之間差異不大，壯圍鄉的綠色運輸發展則較低。未來可依此研究選出之指標，比較不同鄉村地區之綠色運輸發展情形，以便作為政策擬定或交通改善上之參考。

Acquisition of land for use in Taiwan's land has become difficult in recent years, especially with the increased public attention on transportation-related air pollution, energy consumption and ecological environment. Consequently, the Ministry of Transportation and Communications (MOTC) has listed the ＂Development of Green Transportation Systems＂ as an energy-saving carbonreduction strategy in the transportation sector. The MOTC's Institute of Transportation has studied green transportation, and established measurement indicators for urban planning phases. However, as various transportation facilities are being developed, the massive rapid transit (MRT) systems have extended their service ranges beyond urban areas into suburban areas. Accordingly, Taiwan's vast non-urban lands also need appropriate indicators for planners to develop transportation development strategies. This study aims to establish green transportation measurement indicators for assessing the threshold values of green transportation planning indicators, and, in particular, focuses on the suburban areas that have been less discussed in the past. Based on a literature review of public transportation, this study establishes 5 dimensions, each with several indicators. This study applies an expert questionnaire method and a self-developed Grey-ANP (Analytic Network Process) method. Analytical results show that the dimension of destination accessibility has the greatest weight, followed by transfer distance and land use versatility. For the empirical part, four local suburban districts of Yilan County are taken for illustration, in which their green transportation developments are compared for observation of variance. Empirical results indicate that Jiaoxi township is slightly greener than Wujie and Dongshan townships, while Zhuangwei township has the lowest green transportation development. The indicators established by this study can be applied in future studies to compare the green transportation development of different suburban areas, and referenced for transportation policy formulation or transportation improvement.

1. 李家儂、賴宗裕(2009)。交通運輸與土地使用連結下的都市模式演變－全球 36 個主要城市比較分析。都市與計劃，36(1)，25-49。
   連結：
2. 李家儂、賴宗裕(2007)。臺北都會區大眾運輸導向發展目標體系與策略之建構。地理學報，48，19-42。
   連結：
3. 李家儂、賴宗裕(2007)。大眾捷運車站周邊土地使用規劃模型之探討─多目標與多評準決策方法之應用。都市交通半年刊，21(1)，35-49。
   連結：
4. Cervero, R.,Sarmiento, O. L.,Jacoby, E.,Gomez, L. F.,Neiman, A.(2009).Influences of built environments on walking and cycling: Lessons from Bogotá.International Journal of Sustainable Transportation,3(4),203-226.
5. Coleman, C.(1997).Tourist Traffic in English National Parks-An innovative approach to management.The Journal of Tourism Studies,8(1),2-15.
6. Cullinane, S.,Cullinane, K.(1999).Attitudes towards traffic problems and pubic transport in the Dartmoor and Lake District National parks.Journal of Transport Geography,7(1),79-87.
7. Deng, J. L.(1982).Control problems of grey systems.System Control Letter,1(5),288-294.
8. Dickinson, J. E.,Robbins, D.,Fletcher, J.(2009).Representation of transport a rural destination analysis.Annals of Tourism Research,36(1),103-123.
9. Dittmar, H.,Ohland, G.(2004).The New Transit Town: Best Practices in Transit-Oriented Development.Washington:Island Press.
10. Ewing, R.,Bartholomew, K.,Winkelman, S.,Walters, J.,Chen, D.,McCann B.,Goldberg, D.(2007).Growing Cooler: The Evidence on Urban Development and Climate Change.Chicago:Urban Land Institute.
11. Ewing, R.,Cervero R.(2001).Travel and the built environment: A synthesis.Transportation Research Record,1780,87-114.
12. Fafchamp, M.,Shilpi, F.(2003).Spatial division of labour in Nepal.The Journal of Development Studies,39(6),23-66.
13. Fafchamps, M.,Shilpi, F.(2005).Cities and specialization: Evidence from south Asia.The Economic Journal,115(503),477-504.
14. Fafchamps, M.,Wahba, J.(2006).Child labor, urban proximity and household composition.Journal of Development Economics,79(2),374-397.
15. Guiver, J. W.(2007).Modal talk: Discourse analysis of how people talk about bus and car travel.Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice,41(3),233-248.
16. Guiver, J.,Lumsdon L.,Weston R.,Ferguson M.(2007).Do buses help meet tourism objectives? The contribution and potential of scheduled buses in rural destination areas.Transport Policy,14(4),275-282.
17. Hall, D.,Roberts, L.,Mitchell, M.(2003).New Directions in Rural Tourism.Burlington:Ashgate.
18. Huang, G. H.,Moore, R. D.(1993).Grey linear programming, its solving approach and its application.International Journal of Systems Science,24(1),159-172.
19. Li, C. N.,Lai, T. Y.(2013).An empirical analysis of links between transport and land use.Proceedings of Institution of Civil Engineers-Transport,162(2),105-112.
20. Litman, T.(2006).Evaluating Transportation Land Use Impacts.Victoria:Victoria Transport Policy Institute.
21. Marsden, T.(1999).Rural futures: The consumption countryside and its regulation.Sociologia Ruralis,39(4),501-520.
22. Newman, P.,Kenworthy J. R.(1999).The land use-transport connection: An overview.Land Use Policy,13(1),1-22.
23. Newman, P.,Kenworthy, J. R.(1999).Sustainability and Cities: Overcoming Automobile Dependence.Washington:Island Press.
24. Page, S.(2005).Transport and Tourism.Harlow:Pearson Education.
25. Steiner, T. J.,Bristow, A. L.(2000).Road pricing in National Parks: A case study of the Yorkshire Dales National Park.Transport,7(2),93-103.
26. Trappey, A. J. C.,Trappey, C.,Hsiao, C. T.,Ou, J. J. R.,Li, S. J.,Chen, K. W. P.(2012).An evaluation model for low carbon island policy: The case of Taiwan's green transportation policy.Energy Policy,45,510-515.
27. Yamauchi, F.,Muto, M.,Chowdhury, S.,Dewina, R.,Sumaryanto, S.(2011).Are schooling and roads complementary? Evidence from income dynamics in rural Indonesia.World Development,39(12),2232-2244.
28. 文嬿翔(2012)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺北大學都市計劃研究所。
29. 王美惠(2014)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺北大學不動產與城鄉環境學系。
30. 交通部運輸研究所(2011)。都市計畫案綠色運輸衡量指標之研訂。臺北:交通部運輸研究所。
31. 交通部運輸研究所(2008)。綠色運輸系統與土地使用整合規劃之研究。臺北:交通部運輸研究所。
32. 江祥豪(2011)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。彰化，國立彰化師範大學地理學系。
33. 張羽捷(2013)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺北大學不動產與城鄉環境學系。
34. 許添本(2000)。廿一世紀交通工程發展趨勢。二十一世紀，臺灣土木
35. 陳怡安(2009)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。新竹，中華大學運輸科技與物流管理學系。

1. 樊祖燁,趙麗萍,王暐筑,王茜茹(2022)。汽車共乘平台設計與行銷企劃之研究。國立虎尾科技大學學報，36(3)，1-28。