Virtual reality-based badminton teaching in physical education courses

虛擬實境輔助體育課羽球教學之研究

10.6222/pej.202012_53(4).0001

李宏盈(Hung-Ying Lee)；掌慶維(Ching-Wei Chang)；鍾啟暘(Chi-Yang Chung)

qualitative research ； action learning ； immersive ； ICT ； 質性研究 ； 行動學習 ； 沉浸式 ； ICT

體育學報

53卷4期（2020 / 12 / 01）

375 - 391

英文

Introduction: Curriculum integration and cross-disciplinary/cross-curricular integrated learning have become worldwide trends. Taiwan's directives for its 12-year education curricula encourage that secondary schools' flexible learning programs include cross-disciplinary topics to foster the cross-disciplinary learning. The use of virtual reality (VR) for integrated teaching, particularly in physical education (PE), is likely to be developed in the future. This paper aims to explore the effectiveness of VR in PE classes to teach badminton and to discover potential difficulties while employing this method, as well as the coping techniques teachers may need to adopt. Methods: The participants were a PE teacher and their seventh-grade students who were enrolled in Taipei City high school, Taiwan. The study used a qualitative approach, and the data were collected from semi-structured interviews, course reviews, student feedback questionnaires, study notes, and cognitive tests after the implementation of a four-week, eight-session badminton course, where VR was used to teach the forehand serve. The data analysis was conducted using various qualitative methods. Results: 1. The VR-based badminton teaching method improved learning effectiveness from the following aspects: ＂understanding essentials and mastering the skill,＂ ＂repeated practice and adjusting posture,＂ ＂teamwork and mutual support,＂ and ＂promoting motivation and learning.＂ 2. Teachers encountered three potential types of dilemmas when using VR-based teaching: ＂moving,＂ ＂playing,＂ and ＂learning.＂ ＂Moving＂ refers to the conflict between class time spent engaged in physical activities and using technology. ＂Playing＂ encompasses the dilemma that occurs when the frequent use of the device decreased its novelty, and some students discontinued using it. ＂Learning＂ refers to the conflict between the students' desire to enjoy their class and the teacher's desire to educate during class. Conclusion: VR-based badminton teaching in PE can effectively improve the learning effect. However, teachers should reflect upon the design and implementation of teaching and understand students' perceptions of the PE curriculum to overcome the dilemmas of VR-based badminton teaching methods.

目的：橫向整合的跨領域／科目的統整學習是世界趨勢。在臺灣所推動的十二年基本教育之總綱中，也特別明訂國民中學彈性學習課程可以規劃跨領域統整性主題，以培養橫向整合的素養與跨領域的學習。將虛擬實境應用於教學裡，尤其是體育教學中，很可能成為未來的趨勢。本文旨在探討運用虛擬實境輔助體育課程羽球教學之成效，以及教師在教學時可能遭遇的困難與因應之道。方法：以臺北市某國中七年級體育課之師生為研究對象，在為期四週、每週兩節的羽球教學中，透過虛擬實境、數位教學平台及平板電腦來教授正手發球；並以質性研究之半結構式訪談為主要資料來源，輔以觀課記錄、學生回饋問卷、學習單及認知測驗等資料，再以紮根理論的方法進行資料分析。結果：一、虛擬實境輔助體育課程羽球教學能提升學習者的成效，包括「理解要領與掌握訣竅」、「反覆練習與修正姿勢」、「團結合作與相互扶持」、以及「提升動機與促進學習」等面向。二、教師教學時可能遭遇到學生「動與不動」、「玩與不玩」、「學與不學」三個層面之困難，動與不動此處學生認為虛使用擬實境會減少他們的活動時間；玩與不玩此處是指學生認為在實施虛擬實境輔助時，頻率太頻繁；學與不學此處是指學生因先前的經驗，認為體育課應是來放鬆的。結論：虛擬實境輔助體育課程羽球教學，能有效提升學習效果；然而教師也應反思教學設計與實施流程，並瞭解學生對於體育課程的觀念與想法，以解決虛擬實境輔助羽球教學所遭遇之困難。

1. 王俊傑, J. J.,林啟東, Q. D.,楊總成, Z. C.,王元聖, Y. S.(2015)。桃竹地區之國中體育教師應用資訊科技教學與創新教學之研究。嘉大體育健康休閒期刊，14(1)，46-54。
   連結：
2. 林怡君, Y. C.,施登堯, D. Y.(2018)。虛擬實境輔助國中籃球教學之研究。嘉大體育健康休閒期刊，17(2)，48-59。
   連結：
3. 林國欽, K. C.,洪暉鈞, H. C.,楊叔卿, S. C.(2014)。平板電腦融入體育課程羽球技能教學效果之研究。體育學報，47(3)，437-450。
   連結：
4. Brown, J. S.,Collins, A.,Duguid, P.(1989).Situated cognition and the culture of learning.Educational Researcher,18(1),32-42.
5. Charmaz, K.(2014).Grounded theory in global perspective: Reviews by international researchers.Qualitative Inquiry,20(9),1074-1084.
6. Chen, X.(2016).Challenges and strategies of teaching qualitative research in China.Qualitative Inquiry,22(2),72-86.
7. Cheng, K. H.,Tsai, C. C.(2019).A case study of immersive virtual field trips in an elementary classroom: Students’ learning experience and teacher-student interaction behaviors.Computers & Education,140,1-15.
8. Chow, J. Y.,Renshaw, I.,Button, C.,Davids, K.,Tan, C.(2013).Effective learning design for the individual: A nonlinear pedagogical approach in physical education.Complexity thinking in physical education,Oxon:
9. Davids, K. W.,Button, C.,Bennett, S. J.(2008).Dynamics of skill acquisition: A constraints-led approach.Human Kinetics.
10. Delgado, A. J.,Wardlow, L.,McKnight, K.,O’Malley, K.(2015).Educational technology: A review of the integration, resources, and effectiveness of technology in K-12 classrooms.Journal of Information Technology Education,14,397-416.
11. Dube, T. J.,İnce, G.(2019).A novel interface for generating choreography based on augmented reality.International Journal of Human-Computer Studies,132,12-24.
12. Eaves, D. L.,Breslin, G.,Van Schaik, P.,Robinson, E.,Spears, I. R.(2011).The short-term effects of real-time virtual reality feedback on motor learning in dance.Teleoperators and Virtual Environments,20(1),62-77.
13. Galvin, R.(2015).How many interviews are enough? Do qualitative interviews in building energy consumption research produce reliable knowledge?.Journal of Building Engineering,1,2-12.
14. Gundersen, K.(2016).Muscle memory and a new cellular model for muscle atrophy and hypertrophy.Journal of Experimental Biology,219(2),235-242.
15. Isidori, E.,Sandor, I.,Fazio, A.(2017).Virtual reality, educational games, and leisure in contemporary society: The sport pedagogy point of view.eLearning & Software for Education,3,146-153.
16. Kang, S.,Kang, S.(2019).The study on the application of virtual reality in adapted physical education.Cluster Computing,22(1),2351-2355.
17. Ke, F.,Lee, S.,Xu, X.(2016).Teaching training in a mixed-reality integrated learning environment.Computers in Human Behavior,62,212-220.
18. Liu, L.,Yin, G. X.,Sha, K.,Gao, B.(2014).Analysis of the virtual system of sports scene based on virtual reality technology.Applied Mechanics and Materials,651,1523-1526.
19. Lowe, A.,Norris, A. C.,Farris, A. J.,Babbage, D. R.(2018).Quantifying thematic saturation in qualitative data analysis.Field Methods,30(3),191-207.
20. Makransky, G.,Terkildsen, T. S.,Mayer, R. E.(2019).Adding immersive virtual reality to a science lab simulation causes more presence but less learning.Learning and Instruction,60(1),225-236.
21. Martín-Gutiérrez, J.,Mora, C. E.,Añorbe-Díaz, B.,González-Marrero, A.(2017).Virtual technologies trends in education.EURASIA Journal of Mathematics Science and Technology Education,13(2),469-486.
22. Neumann, D. L.,Moffitt, R.(2018).Affective and attentional states when running in a virtual reality environment.Sports,6(3),71.
23. Ntoumanis, N.(2005).A prospective study of participation in optional school physical education using a self-determination theory framework.Journal of Education Psychology,97(3),444-453.
24. Oliveira, B. R. R.,Deslandes, A. C.,Nakamura, F. Y.,Viana, B. F.,Santos, T. M.(2015).Self-selected or imposed exercise? A different approach for affective comparisons.Journal of Sports Sciences,33(8),777-785.
25. Parong, J.,Mayer, R. E.(2018).Learning science in immersive virtual reality.Journal of Educational Psychology,110(6),785-797.
26. Pasco, D.(2013).The potential of using virtual reality technology in physical activity settings.Quest,65(4),429-441.
27. Radianti, J.,Majchrzak, T. A.,Fromm, J.,Wohlgenannt, I.(2020).A systematic review of immersive virtual reality applications for higher education: Design elements, lessons learned, and research agenda.Computers & Education,147,103778.
28. Rink, J.(2001).Investigating the assumption of pedagogy.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,20,112-129.
29. Shang, J.(2014).Research on new sports teaching mode based on virtual reality technique.Applied Mechanics and Materials,644,6039-6042.
30. Snyder, A. L.,Anderson-Hanley, C.,Arciero, P. J.(2012).Virtual and live social facilitation while exergaming: Competitiveness moderates exercise intensity.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,34(2),252-259.
31. Standage, M.,Duda, J. L.,Ntoumanis, N.(2003).A model of contextual motivation in physical education: Using constructs from self-determination and achievement goal theories to predict physical activity intention.Journal of Educational Psychology,95(1),97-110.
32. Standage, M.,Duda, J. L.,Ntoumanis, N.(2005).A test of self-determination theory in school physical education.British Journal of Education Psychology,75(3),411-433.
33. Stavroulia, K. E.,Christofi, M.,Baka, E.,Michael-Grigoriou, D.,Magnenat-Thalmann, N.,Lanitis, A.(2019).Assessing the emotional impact of virtual reality-based teacher training.The International Journal of Information and Learning Technology,36(3),192-217.
34. Yu, Y.,Yan, B.(2016).Research on the promotion of teaching quality with a new physical education teaching model based on virtual reality.Revista Iberica de Sistemas e Tecnologias de Informacao,9,46-55.
35. Zhang, K.,Liu, S. J.(2016).The application of virtual reality technology in physical education teaching and training.2016 IEEE International Conference on Service Operations and Logistics, and Informatics (SOLI)
36. 王炫智, X. Z.(2010)。「虛擬實境」在體育教學中之應用。學校體育，116，81-86。
37. 教育部 (2014)。十二年國民基本教育課程綱要總綱。臺北市：教育部。[Ministry of Education. (2014). Curriculum guidelines of 12-year basic education general guidelines. Taipei City: Ministry of Education.]

1. 陳詠儒,周建智,王駿濠,王信凱(2022)。從腦與認知科學觀點探討體育課的價值與應用。體育學報，55(2)，113-132。
2. 劉憲鋐,柯比昂(2023)。樂樂足球資訊整合平台系統規劃。興大體育學刊，22，27-33。
3. 掌慶維,李宏盈(2022)。設計思考對體育師資生學習如何教學之探討。中華體育季刊，36(1)，35-45。
4. 鄭伊婷,粘瑞狄,陳豐慈,張育愷,,鄭伊婷,粘瑞狄,陳豐慈,張育愷,(2023)。虛擬實境健身運動對認知功能之影響：系統性回顧。中華體育季刊，37(2)，115-131。
5. (2023)。體育教師科技壓力、建構主義教學信念與工作倦怠感之關係。臺灣運動教育學報，18(1)，77-104。
6. (2024)。雙語課程的游泳技術與評量方式－以蝶式為例。興大體育學刊，23，165-177。