從實證觀點談OSCE於護理教育之應用

The Implication of Objective Structured Clinical Examination in Nursing Education : An Evidence-based Appropach

10.6386/CGN.202012_31(4).0003

黃湘萍(Hsiang-Ping Huang)；趙莉芬(Li-Fen Chao)；范君瑜(Jun-Yu Fan)；樓迎統(Ying-Tung Lau)；簡淑慧(Sui-Whi Jane)

實證觀點 ； 護理客觀結構式臨床技能測驗 ； 護理教育 ； evidence-based approach ； objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) ； nursing education

長庚護理

31卷4期（2020 / 12 / 01）

476 - 487

繁體中文

隨著國內人口老化及疾病型態的轉變，國人對醫療照護多元化及品質之需求均增加，護理人員應思考如何於此複雜化之健康照護體系展現專業之角色及功能。考量護理是「以能力為導向之實作專業」，護理教育者須透過以能力為導向之課程設計及客觀的評估方法，評量學生的專業知識、技能及態度，以培育兼備臨床及理論能力且符合實務需求之護理學生，本文以實證觀點探討建構及評價客觀結構式臨床技能測驗（objective structured clinical examination, OSCE）於護理教育之應用，包括OSCE發展沿革及應用、標準化考題建構、考生準備、考官及標準病人訓練，OSCE考題之信效度、難易度及鑑別度檢定方法及判讀。另外，為了讓OSCE達到護理教育最大的教學及評量效益，建議發展學生準備的評估工具、發展長站型或整合型考題、建構E化評分系統、檢定合適考站數目。本文提供護理學校與醫療機構考慮採用OSCE教學評量之參考，日後更能以標準化及實證化方式規劃及執行護理OSCE。

Due to the increased number of aging population and changing disease pattern, there are increases in demand for multidisciplinary care and quality care. Nurses are expected to perform their roles and functions within a complicated health care system. Also, considering nursing as a competence-based practice profession, nursing educators need to develop competence-based curriculum and objective evaluation of students' knowledge, psychomotor, and attitude, thereby enhancing students' clinical & theoretical competencies and fitness for practice. The purpose of this article was to describe the construction and evaluation of objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) in nursing education from an evidence-based perspective. This included the development and implication of OSCE, standardized examination construction, preparation of examinees, training of evaluator and standardized patient, analyses and interpretations of reliability, validity, difficulty, and discrimination of OSCE. In addition, the authors suggested developing related evaluation tools for the preparation of examinees, long and/or integrated station, OSCE management information system, and the appropriateness of station numbers to strengthen the OSCE efficacy in teaching and evaluation. This article provided nursing schools and medical institutions with essential information for planning and implementing OSCE from a standardized and evidence-based approach in the future.

1. 李香君, H. C.,蔣宜倩, Y. C,劉英妹, Y. M.(2019)。從跨國比較之觀點反思台灣護理教育。長庚護理，30(1)，29-39。
   連結：
2. 邱文璽, W. H,趙淑員, S. Y.(2018)。從國際技能競賽訓練中談護理教學創新與運用。護理雜誌，65(6)，26-31。
   連結：
3. 黃湘萍, H. P.,趙莉芬, L. F.,王瑜欣, Y. H.,劉英妹, Y. M.,倪麗芬, L. F.,簡淑慧, S. W.(2017)。建構及檢測護理客觀結構式臨床技能測驗考題之信效度、鑑別度及難易度。護理雜誌，64(6)，67-76。
   連結：
4. AACN(2013).Quality & safety education for nurses(QSEN).Author.
5. Al-Osail, A. M.,Al-Sheikh, M. H.,Al-Osail, E. M.,Al-Ghamdi, M. A.,Al-Hawas, A. M.,Al Bahussain, A. S.,Al-Dajani, A. A.(2015).Is cronbach's alpha sufficient for assessing the reliability of the OSCE for an internal medicine course?.BMC Reserch Notes,8,582.
6. Bernard, A. W.,Feinn, R.,Ceccolini, G.,Brown, R.,Rosenberg, I.,Trymbulak, W.,VanCott, C.(2019).The reliability of 2-station clerkship objective structured clinical examinations in isolation and in aggregate.Journal of Medical Education and Curricular Development,6
7. Boursicot, K.,Roberts, T.(2005).How to set up an OSCE.The Clinical Teacher,2(1),16-20.
8. Brighton, R.,Mackay, M.,Brown, R. A.,Jans, C.,Antoniou, C.(2017).Introduction of undergraduate nursing students to an objective structured clinical examination.Journal of Nursing Education,56(4),231-234.
9. Collins, S.,Hewer, I.(2014).The impact of the bologna process on nursing higher education in europe: A review.International Journal of Nursing Studies,51(1),150-156.
10. Fan, J. Y.,Wang, Y. H.,Chao, L. F.,Jane, S. W.,Hsu, L. L.(2015).Performance evaluation of nursing students following competency-based education.Nurse Education Today,35(1),97-103.
11. Goh, H. S.,Tang, M. L.,Devi, M. K.,Ng, K. C. E.,Lim, L. M.(2016).Testing the psychometric properties of objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) in nursing education in singapore.Singapore Nursing Journal,43(1),12-18.
12. Gupta, P.,Dewan, P.,Singh, T.(2010).Objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) Revisited.Indian Pediatrics,47(11),911-920.
13. Hatamleh, W.,Sabeeb, Z. A.(2014).Perception of nursing faculty members on the use of objective structured clinical examinations.IOSR Journal of Nursing and Health Science,3(6),21-26.
14. Holland, K.,Roxburgh, M.,Johnson, M.,Topping, K.,Watson, R.,Lauder, W.,Porter, M.(2010).Fitness for practice in nursing and midwifery education in Scotland, United Kingdom.Journal of clinical nursing,19(3-4),461-469.
15. Hughes, R. G.(Ed.)(2008).Patient safety and quality: An evidence-based handbook for nurses.Rockville, MD:Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.
16. Institute, of,(U.S.), M.(2011).The future of nursing: Leading change, advancing health.The National Academies Press.
17. Johnston, A. N. B.,Weeks, B.,Shuker, M.-A.,Coyne, E.,Niall, H.,Mitchell, M.,Massey, D.(2017).Nursing students' perceptions of the objective structured clinical examination: An integrative review.Clinical Simulation in Nursing,13(3),127-142.
18. Majumder, M. A. A.,Kumar, A.,Krishnamurthy, K.,Ojeh, N.,Adams, O. P.,Sa, B.(2019).An evaluative study of objective structured clinical examination (OSCE): students and examiners perspectives.Advanced in Medical Education and Practice,10,387-397.
19. Marceau, M.,Gallagher, F.,Young, M.,St-Onge, C.(2018).Validity as a social imperative for assessment in health professions education: A concept analysis.Medical Education,52(6),641-653.
20. Massey, D.,Byrne, J.,Higgins, N.,Weeks, B.,Shuker, M. A.,Coyne, E.,Johnston, A. N. B.(2017).Enhancing OSCE preparedness with video exemplars in undergraduate nursing students. A Mixed Method Study.Nurse Education Today,54,56-61.
21. Miller, G. E.(1990).The assessment of clinical skills/ competence/ performance.Academic Medicine,65(9 Suppl),S63-S67.
22. Navas-Ferrer, C.,Urcola-Pardo, F.,Subiron-Valera, A. B.,German-Bes, C.(2017).Validity and reliability of objective structured clinical evaluation in nursing.Clinical Simulation in Nursing,13(11),531-543.
23. Obizoba, C.(2018).Mitigating the challenges of objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) in nursing education: A phenome nological research study.Nurse Educ Today,68,71-74.
24. Polit, D. F.,Beck, C. T.,Owen, S. V.(2007).Is the CVI an acceptable indicator of content validity? Appraisal and recommendations.Research in Nursing & Health,30(4),459-467.
25. Roberts, C.,Newble, D.,Jolly, B.,Reed, M.,Hampton, K.(2006).Assuring the quality of high-stakes undergraduate assessments of clinical competence.Medical Teacher,28(6),535-543.
26. Rushforth, H. E.(2007).Objective structured clinical examination (OSCE): Review of literature and implications for nursing education.Nurse Education Today,27(5),481-490.
27. Solà, M.,Pulpón, A. M.,Morin, V.,Sancho, R.,Clèries, X.,Fabrellas, N.(2017).Towards the implementation of OSCE in undergraduate nursing curriculum: A qualitative study.Nurse Education Today,49,163-167.
28. Swift, M.,Spake, E.,Gajewski, B. J.(2013).Student performance and satisfaction for a musculoskeletal objective structured clinical examination.Journal of Allied Health,42(4),214-222.
29. Taylor, I.,Bing-Jonsson, P. C.,Johansen, E.,LevyMalmberg, R.,Fagerström, L.(2019).The objective structured clinical examination in evolving nurse practitioner education: A study of students' and examiners’ experiences.Nurse Education in Practice,37,115-123.
30. Uliyah, M.,Hidayat, A. A. A.(2017).Objective structure clinical examination (OSCE) based teaching material development.Advanced Science Letters,23(12),12521-12523.
31. Wagener, S.,Möltner, A.,Tımbıl, S.,Gornostayeva, M.,Schultz, J.-H.,Brüstle, P.,Fries, M.(2015).Development of a competency-based formative progress test with student-generated MCQs: Results from a multi-centre pilot study.GMS Zeitschrift für Medizinische Ausbildung,32(4)
32. 中華民國護理師護士公會全國聯合會(2019)．台閩地區護理人員統計 ．Retrieved from http://www.nurse.org.tw/publicUI/H/H102.aspx[Taiwan Union of Nurses Association. (2019). Taiwan regional nursing staff Statistics. Retrieved from http://www.nurse.org.tw/publicUI/H/H102.aspx]
33. 余民寧, M. N.(2011).教育測驗與評量：成就測驗與教學評量.心理=Psychological.
34. 李石增, S. T.(Ed.)(2012).客觀結構式臨床測驗─從基礎建立到執行與品質監測.台灣愛思唯爾=Elsevier Taiwan.
35. 范君瑜（編）, J. Y.(Ed.)(2015).護理客觀結構式臨床技能測驗.Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC:台灣愛思唯爾=Elsevier Taiwan.
36. 張媚, M.,余玉眉, Y. M.(2010).護理人力及專科護理師制度：願景與挑戰.台灣=Taiwan:國家衛生研究院=National Health Research Institutes.
37. 劉克明, K. M.,高明見, M. C(2015)。OSCE納入臺灣醫師國家考試應考資格之歷程現況與展望。國家菁英季刊，11(4)，45-70。
38. 蔡秀鸞（校閱）, H. H. (Ed.)(2009).身體評估之OSCE臨床能力鑑定.台灣=Taiwan:愛思唯爾=Elsevier Health Sciences.
39. 蔡淑鳳(2019)．護理政策與法規。Retrieved from https://dep.mohw.gov.tw/DONAHC/cp-1089-46510-104.html[Tsay, S. F. (2019). Nursing policies and regulations. Retrieved from https://dep.mohw.gov.tw/DONAHC/cp-1089-46510-104.html]

1. 蕭政廷,鄭麗華,廖美南,陳淑賢,陳姿廷,張寧郁,江金英(2023)。發展及驗證可信賴專業活動（EPAs）於新進護理人員的臨床培訓。健康科技期刊，9(2)，33-45。