國民小學男女教師的工作壓力源之研究－以臺灣參與TALIS為例

The Work Stressors of Male and Female Teachers in Elementary Schools: Evidence from Taiwan's Participation in TALIS Data

10.6423/HHHC.202105_(133).0006

張芳全(Fang-Chung Chang)

成長型壓力源 ； 自我效能 ； 阻礙型壓力源 ； 教師工作壓力 ； 專業成長 ； growth pressure source ； hindering pressure source ； professional growth ； self-efficacy ； teacher work pressure

學校行政

133期（2021 / 05 / 16）

121 - 151

繁體中文

國民小學男女教師工作壓力長期以來受到關注。然而國小教師的壓力源有哪些呢？本研究以OECD於2018年教學與學習國際調查的臺灣3,472名國小教師，分析與他們工作壓力有關因素。獲得以下結論：（一）國小教師的性別、工作年資、教育程度和工作壓力沒有明顯關聯，同時女教師授課負擔、感受政策朝令夕改愈多、感受要為學生學習表現負責愈多，工作壓力愈大，而男教師則否。（二）國小男女教師專業成長愈多，工作壓力較低，而自我教學效能則與工作壓力沒有關聯。（三）國小男女教師的行政工作負擔、維持教室秩序、學生恐嚇羞辱、家長關切、備課負擔、代理缺席同事工作，與工作壓力有正向顯著關聯，其中行政工作負擔與維持教室秩序是重要壓力源。（四）國小男女教師為身心障礙學生設計課程愈多，工作壓力愈低；國小男女教師批改作業負擔與工作壓力沒有顯著關聯。本研究貢獻在於發現，國小教師的壓力源以行政工作及班級經營、家長關切與備課負擔較重要，而教師專業成長為成長型壓力源，可以舒緩教師工作壓力。針對結論深入討論，提出具體建議。

The work pressure of male and female teachers in elementary schools has long been concerned. However, what were the stressors of elementary school teachers? This study used 3,472 elementary school teachers in Taiwan from the OECD International Survey of Teaching and Learning in 2018 to analyze factors related to their work stress. The following conclusions were obtained: 1. The gender, working experience, education level, and work pressure of elementary school teachers were not significantly related to the teachers' work pressure. For female teachers, the more they were burdened with teaching, the policy changes, the responsibility for students' learning performance, the more work pressure they experienced. However, these factors were not related to male teachers' work pressure. 2. The more professional growth the elementary school male and female teachers experienced, the lower their work pressure. However, self-efficacy was not related to work pressure. 3. The administrative burden, the maintenance of classroom order, student intimidation and humiliation, parental concerns, the burden of preparing lessons, and the work of acting as an agent for absent colleagues were all positively significantly related to both the male and female teachers' work pressure. Among them, the administrative burden and maintaining the classroom order were two important source of stress. 4 The more courses the male and female elementary school teachers designed for students with disabilities, the lower their work pressure. The burden of grading homework was not significantly related to the teachers' work pressure. The burden of graded homework by male and female teachers in elementary schools is not significantly related to work pressure. The contributions of this research were: first, the key stressors of elementary school teachers were administrative work and class management, parents' concerns and the burden of lesson preparation; second, teachers' professional growth, which was beneficial to teachers' work stress reduction, was a growth stressor. This paper concluded with in-depth discussions and specific suggestions.

1. 柯澍馨,簡聿悊(2011)。國中教師工作壓力、家庭壓力與生活品質之研究。學校行政，75，64-82。
   連結：
2. 高鳳霞,鄭伯壎(2014)。職場工作壓力：回顧與展望。人力資源管理學報，14(1)，77-101。
   連結：
3. 陳瑋婷(2010)。中小學教師工作壓力與因應策略相關性之後設分析：多向度的觀點。師資培育與教師專業發展期刊，3(1)，1-17。
   連結：
4. 陳瑋婷,許瑛巧(2013)。教師工作壓力、工作滿意與組織承諾之關係研究：後設分析與路徑分析的應用。教育理論與實踐學刊，27，109-137。
   連結：
5. 黃寶園(2015)。教師工作壓力之研究：後設分析。高雄師大學報──教育與社會科學類，38，27-48。
   連結：
6. 黃寶園(2009)。工作壓力對工作滿足、職業倦怠影響之研究：統合分析取向。教育心理學報，40(3)，439-461。
   連結：
7. American Federation of Teachers [AFT] (2016). Educator quality of work life survey. [cited 2020 Apr 27]. Available from: https://www.aft.org/2017-educator-quality-lifesurvey
8. Antoniou, A.‐S,Polychroni, F.,Vlachakis, A.‐N.(2006).Gender and age differences in occupational stress and professional burnout between primary and high‐school teachers in Greece.Journal of Managerial Psychology,21(7),682-690.
9. Bakker, A. B.,Demerouti, E.(2007).The job demands-resources model: State of the art.Journal of Managerial Psychology,22(3),309-328.
10. Bakker, A. B.,Demerouti, E.,Verbeke, W.(2004).Using the job demands-resources model to predict burnout and performance.Human Resource Management,43(1),83-104.
11. Besse, R.,Howard, K.,Gonzalez, S.,Howard, J.(2015).Major depressive disorder and public school teachers: Evaluating occupational and health predictors and outcomes.Journal of Applied Biobehavior Research,20(2),71-83.
12. Bhattacharjee, A.(2015).Anxiety and quality of life among teaching professionals: A comparative analysis.Journal of Psychosociology Research,10(2),365-372.
13. Bottiani, J. H.,Duran, C.,Pas, E. T.,Bradshaw, C. P.(2019).Teacher stress and burnout in urban middle schools: Associations with job demands, resources, and effective classroom practices.Journal of School Psychology,77,36-51.
14. Cavanaugh, M. A.,Boswell, W. R.,Roehling, M. V.,Boudreau, J. W.(2000).An empirical examination of self-reported work stress among U.S. managers.Journal of Applied Psychology,85(1),65-74.
15. Chaplain, R. P.(1995).Stress and job satisfaction: A study of English primary school teachers.Educational Psychology,15(4),473-489.
16. Demerouti, E., A.,Bakker, B.,Nachreiner, F.,Schaufeli, W. B.(2001).The job demands-resources model of burnout.Journal of Applied Psychology,86(3),499-512.
17. Eddy, C. L.,Herman, K. C.,Reinke, W. M.(2019).Single-item teacher stress and coping measures: Concurrent and predictive validity and sensitivity to change.Journal of School Psychology,76,17-32.
18. Garrosa, E.,Moreno-Jiménez, B.,Liang, Y.,González, J. L.(2008).The relationship between socio-demographic variables, job stressors, burnout, and hardy personality in nurses: An exploratory study.International Journal of Nursing Studies,45(3),418-427.
19. Gray, C.,Wilcox, G.,Nordstokke, D.(2017).Teacher mental health, school climate, inclusive education and student learning: A review.Candia Psychology,58(3),203-210.
20. Herman, K. C.,Prewett, S. L.,Eddy, C. L.,Savala, A.,Reinke, W. M.(2020).Profiles of middle school teacher stress and coping: Concurrent and prospective correlates.Journal of school psychology,78,54-68.
21. Idris, M. K.(2011).Over time effects of role stress on psychological strain among Malaysian public university academics.International Journal of Business and Social Sciences,2(9),154-161.
22. Karasek, R. A.,Theorell, T.(1990).Healthy work: Stress, productivity, and the reconstruction of working life.New York, NY:Basic Books.
23. Katz, D.,Kahn, R. L.(1978).The social psychology of organizations.New York, NY:John Wiley & Sons.
24. Kline, R. B.(2005).Principles and practice of structural equation modeling.New York, NY:Guilford.
25. Kokkinos C. M.(2007).Job stressors, personality and burnout in primary school teachers.The British journal of educational psychology,77(Pt 1),229-243.
26. Kongcharoen, J.,Onmek, N.,Jandang, P.,Wangyisen, S.(2019).Stress and work motivation of primary and secondary school teachers.Journal of Applied Research in Higher Education,12(4),709-723.
27. McCormick, J.(1997).Occupational stress of teachers: biographical differences in a large school system.Journal of Educational Administration,35(1),18-38.
28. Nair, S.,Mee, L.Y.,Cheik, A.N.(2016).Internal push factors and external pull factors and their relationships with lecturers’ turnover intention.International Journal of Biometrics,11,110.
29. Ngo, H. Y.,Foley, S.,Loi, R.(2005).Work role stressors and turnover intentions: A study of professional clergy in Hong Kong.International Journal of Human Resource Management,16(11),2133-2146.
30. OECD(2019).TALIS 2018 technical report.Paris, France:TALIS, OECD Publishing.
31. Ouellette, R. R.,Frazier, S. L.,Shernoff, E. S.,Cappella, E.,Mehta, T. G.,Maríñez-Lora, A.,Cua, G.,Atkins, M. S.(2018).Teacher job stress and satisfaction in urban schools: Disentangling individual-, classroom-, and organizational-level Influences.Behavior Therapy,49(4),494-508.
32. Paramanandam, P.(2017).Impact of occupational stress on job satisfaction and organizational commitment among the managerial personnel of select textile units in tirupur.An International Journal of Management Studies,17(3),166-174.
33. Reilly, E.,Dhingra, K.,Boduszek, D.(2014).Teachers’ self-efficacy beliefs, self-esteem, and job stress as determinants of job satisfaction.International Journal of Educational Management,28(4),365-378.
34. Shernoff, E. S.,Mehta, T. G.,Atkins, M. S.,Torf, R.,Spencer, J.(2011).A qualitative study of the sources and impact of stress among urban teachers.School Mental Health,3(2),59-69.
35. Van der Doef, M.,Maes, S.(1999).The job demand-control (-support) model and psychological well-being: A review of 20 years of empirical research.Work & Stress,13,87-114.
36. Yu, G.,Dong, Y.,Wang, Q.,An, R.(2016).Reducing teacher stress: Improving humanized management of Chinese teachers.Journal of Chinese Human Resource Management,7(2),82-99.
37. 吳清山,林天佑(2005)。工作壓力。教育資料與研究雙月刊，65，135。
38. 邱懷萱,李麗日(2012)。教師工作壓力與自我效能感之相關研究──以苗栗縣國民小學教師為例。區域與社會發展研究，3，193-244。
39. 洪文章(2006)。國民小學實施九年一貫課程中兼任行政職務教師工作壓力與調適策略之研究。國民教育研究學報，17，173-211。
40. 蔡金田,毛睿翎(2014)。國民小學教師工作壓力與生活品質關係之研究──以南投縣國民小學為例。慈濟大學教育研究學刊，11，31-75。
41. 繆敏志(1993)。工作壓力之理論基礎與模式及其管理方法。中國行政，53，21-46。

1. 陳信助,張文權,林明地(2023)。「教師兼任行政工作倦怠」相關議題研究之回顧分析：以《學校行政》期刊論文為範疇。學校行政，146，60-87。
2. 蕭佳純(2023)。自我效能、學校環境因素對國小教師參與專業發展活動影響之研究。學校行政，145，107-131。
3. 謝傳崇,陳雨然(2023)。教育研究的發展契機：全球TALIS文獻系統性回顧。臺北市立大學學報.教育類，54(1)，1-28。
4. (2023)。國小自然科學領域教師SCCT滿意度模式之研究：以TIMSS 2019臺灣資料為例。教育研究與實踐學刊，70(2)，25-51。
5. (2023)。臺灣國小教師運用ICT於學生專題學習之決策樹分析。清華教育學報，40(2)，1-47。