题名

修正式循環音韻治療法介入以提升聽力損失兒童語音能力之研究

并列篇名

The Efficacy of the Modified Cycles Phonological Remediation to Enhance Speech for Hearing-Impaired Children

作者

柯巧翊(Ciao-Yi Ke)；陳凱玫(Kai-Mei Chen)；鄧菊秀(Chu-Hsiu Teng)

关键词

音韻系統 ； 循環音韻治療法 ； 語音能力 ； 語音異常 ； 聽力損失 ； Cycles Phonological Remediation Approach ； hearing loss ； phonological system ； speech ； speech sound disorders

期刊名称

教育實踐與研究

卷期/出版年月

35卷2期（2022 / 12 / 01）

页次

103 - 137

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

本研究旨在探討透過修正式循環音韻治療法（The Modified Cycles Phonological Remediation Approach, MCPRA）提升學前聽力損失兒童之語音能力。研究採單一個案研究法之跨參與者多基準線設計，研究對象為三名年齡介於4歲0個月至6歲4個月的重度語音異常聽損兒童，以MCPRA為主要介入模式，進行2個循環階段，合計18次之課程。本研究使用「目標音類化單字正確題數」作為主要介入目標，並將資料記錄於基線期、介入期及維持期，再以目視分析、效果量及C統計進行分析。研究結果顯示，三位研究對象於治療後的「目標音類化單字正確題數」皆一致呈現立即及維持成效，亦能類化至非目標語音，使整體語音能力獲得改善。另外，三名研究對象介入後的聲母正確率、語詞正確率、清晰度百分比及音韻歷程出現率均明顯進步，整體語音異常嚴重度從重度轉為輕度或正常。本研究為聽損兒童之語音治療研究提供實證，亦提供臨床人員MCPRA詳細介入程序，包含語音分析方式、目標語音挑選原則、課程步驟等。最後，本研究闡述該治療法於臨床場域應用及未來研究建議，進而提供後續研究與臨床實務之參考。
英文摘要

The purpose of this study was to investigate the efficacy of the Modified Cycles Phonological Remediation (MCPRA) to enhance speech for children with severe speech sound disorders (SSD) and hearing impairment (HI). A multiple baseline design across subjects was used to examine intervention effects. Three preschoolers with severe SSD and HI at age ranging from 4 year 0 month to 6 year 4 month participated in the study. All three children received two cycles with 18 hours of phonological remediation sessions. The target generalization probe words were administered during baseline, intervention, and follow-up phases to assess generalization and maintenance of phonological skills. Data were analyzed by visual analysis, effect size and C-statistic. The results indicated that all participants' target generalization probe words exhibited significant improvement by the end of the intervention, maintain, and follow-up phase. Furthermore, three children's speech rating has improved from severe to mild or normal. Their speech intelligibility increased as well. This study provides evidence-based research on speech therapy for children with HI, and clinical procedure for MCPRA, including sounds analysis method, target selection, and the intervention steps. Finally, the result of this study could provide clinical and research application of the articulation/phonological intervention for Mandarin-speaking children with HI.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 王南梅, N. -M.,郭于靚, Y. -C.,黃國祐, K. -Y.,劉樹玉, S. -Y.,劉俊榮, C. -J.(2009)。台灣電子耳兒童現況調查研究－電子耳使用、聽覺能力、口語溝通能力表現。台灣聽力語言學會雜誌，22，55-85。
    連結：
  2. 王南梅, N. -M.,郭于靚, Y. -C.,黃國祐, K. -Y.,劉樹玉, S. -Y.,劉俊榮, C. -J.(2009)。台灣電子耳兒童現況調查研究－電子耳使用、聽覺能力、口語溝通能力表現。台灣聽力語言學會雜誌，22，55-85。
    連結：
  3. 鄭靜宜, J. -Y.(2017)。華語學前兒童語音的習得。華語文教學研究，14，109-136。
    連結：
  4. 錡寶香, P. -H,魏筠家, Y. -J.(2015)。植入人工電子耳聽損兒童的聲母構音能力。特教論壇，18，32-46。
    連結：
  5. Abraham, S.(1993).Differential treatment of phonological disability in children with impaired hearing who were trained orally.American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology,2(3),23-30.
  6. Asad, A. N.,Purdy, S. C.,Ballard, E.,Fairgray, L.,Bowen, C.(2018).Phonological processes in the speech of school-age children with hearing loss: Comparisons with children with normal hearing.Journal of Communication Disorders,74,10-22.
  7. Ashori, M.(2020).Speech intelligibility and auditory perception of pre-school children with Hearing Aid, cochlear implant and Typical Hearing.Journal of Otology,15(2),62-66.
  8. Baker, E.,McLeod, S.(2011).Evidence-based practice for children with speech sound disorders: Part 1 narrative review.Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch,42(2),102-139.
  9. Bennett, C. W.(1974).Articulation training of two hearing-impaired girls.Journal of Applied behavior analysis,7(3),439-445.
  10. Bennett, C. W.(1978).Articulation training of profoundly hearing-impaired children: A distinctive feature approach.Journal of Communication Disorders,11(5),433-442.
  11. Bernthal, John E.,Bankson, Nicholas W.,Flipsen, Peter., Jr(2021).Speech sound disorders in Children: Articulation & phonological disorders.Baltimore, MD:Brookes.
  12. Blamey, P. J.,Sarant, J. Z.,Paatsch, L. E.,Barry, J. G.,Bow, C. P.,Wales, R. J.,Tooher, R.(2001).Relationships among speech perception, production, language, hearing loss, and age in children with impaired hearing.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research : JSLHR,44(2),264-285.
  13. Chen, K. M.,Teng, C. H.(2022).The efficacy of the cycles phonological remediation approach for a child with hearing loss.Chung Shan Medical Journal,33(1),75-78.
  14. Ching, T. Y.(2015).Is early intervention effective in improving spoken language outcomes of children with congenital hearing loss?.American Journal of Audiology,24(3),345-348.
  15. Ching, T. Y.,Dillon, H.,Leigh, G.,Cupples, L.(2018).Learning from the longitudinal outcomes of children with hearing impairment (LOCHI) study: Summary of 5-year findings and implications.International Journal of Audiology,57(2),105-111.
  16. Dagenais, P. A.,Critz-Crosby, P.,Fletcher, S. G.,McCutcheon, M. J.(1994).Comparing abilities of children with Profound hearing impairments to learn consonants using electropalatography or traditional aural. Oral Techniques.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research,37(3),687-699.
  17. Ertmer, D. J.(2011).Assessing speech intelligibility in children with hearing loss: Toward revitalizing a valuable clinical tool.Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools,42(1),52-58.
  18. Ertmer, D. J.,Goffman, L.(2011).Speech production accuracy and variability in young cochlear implant recipients: Comparisons with typically developing age-peers.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research : JSLHR,54(1),177-189.
  19. Faes, J.(2017).University of Antwerp.
  20. Fairbanks, G.(1954).Systematic research in experimental phonetics: A theory of the speech mechanism as a servosystem.Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders,19(2),133-139.
  21. Flipsen, P., Jr.(2006).Measuring the intelligibility of conversational speech in children.Clinical Linguistics and Phonetics,20,303-312.
  22. Flipsen, P., Jr.,Colvard, L. G.(2006).Intelligibility of conversational speech produced by children with cochlear implants.Journal of Communication Disorders,39(2),93-108.
  23. Flipsen, P., Jr,Parker, R. G.(2008).Phonological patterns in the conversational speech of children with cochlear implants.Journal of Communication Disorders,41(4),337-357.
  24. Freeman, V.,Pisoni, D. B.,Kronenberger, W. G.,Castellanos, I.(2017).Speech intelligibility and psychosocial functioning in deaf children and teens with cochlear implants.The Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education,22(3),278-289.
  25. Glaspey, A. M.,Stoel-Gammon, C.(2007).A dynamic approach to phonological assessment.Advances in Speech Language Pathology,9(4),286-296.
  26. Glaspey, A. M.,Stoel-Gammon, C.(2005).Dynamic assessment in phonological disorders: The scaffolding scale of stimulability.Topics in Language Disorders,25(3),220-230.
  27. Goldblat, E.,Pinto, O. Y.(2017).Academic outcomes of adolescents and young adults with hearing loss who received auditory-verbal therapy.Deafness & Education International,19(3-4),126-133.
  28. Gordon-Brannan, M.,Hodson, B. W.,Wynne, M. K.(1992).Remediating unintelligible utterances of a child with a mild hearing loss.American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology,1(4),28-38.
  29. Haukedal, C. L.,Lyxell, B.,Wie, O. B.(2020).Health-related quality of life with cochlear implants: The children’s perspective.Ear and Hearing,41(2),330-343.
  30. Hickson, L.,Thy, B. S.,Aud, M.,Murdoch, B.(2009).Longitudinal study of speech perception, speech, and language for children with hearing loss in an auditory-verbal therapy program.The Volta Review,109(2),61-85.
  31. Hickson, L.,Thy, B. S.,Aud, M.,Murdoch, B.,Constantinescu, G.,Path, B.(2010).Is auditory-verbal therapy effective for children with hearing loss?.The Volta Review,110(3),361-387.
  32. Hodson, B. W.(2011).Enhancing phonological patterns of young children with highly unintelligible speech.The ASHA leader,16(4),16-19.
  33. Hodson, B. W.(1983).A facilitative approach for remediation of a child’s profoundly unintelligible phonological system.Topics in Language Disorders,3(2),24-34.
  34. Hodson, B. W.,Chin, L.,Redmond, B.,Simpson, R.(1983).Phonological evaluation and remediation of speech deviations of a child with a repaired cleft palate: A case study.Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders,48(1),93-98.
  35. Hodson, B. W.,Nonomura, C. W.,Zappia, M. J.(1989).Phonological disorders: Impact on academic performance?.Seminars in Speech and Language,10,252-259.
  36. Hodson, B.,Paden, E.(1991).Targeting intelligible speech: A phonological approach to remediation.Austin, TX:Pro-Ed.
  37. Hosseini, M.,Saki, N.,Moradi, N.,Soltani, M.,Latifi, M.,Nikakhlagh, S.(2017).The effect of duration of using cochlear implant and hearing aid on the speechintelligibility of children with hearing loss.Journal of Clinical Research in Paramedical Sciences,6(2),135-143.
  38. Hunt JM(1961).Intelligence and Experience.New York, NY:Ronald.
  39. Ingram D.(1976).Phonological disability in children.London, UK:Edward Arnold.
  40. Jiang, F.,Alimu, D.,Qin, W. Z.,Kupper, H.(2021).Long-term functional outcomes of hearing and speech rehabilitation efficacy among paediatric cochlear implant recipients in Shandong, China.Disability and rehabilitation,43(20),2860-2865.
  41. Kent, R. D.(1982).Contextual facilitation of correct sound production.Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools,13(2),66-76.
  42. Khwaileh, F. A.,Flipsen, P., Jr.(2010).Single word and sentence intelligibility in children with cochlear implants.Clinical linguistics & phonetics,24(9),722-733.
  43. Kratochwill, T. R., Hitchcock, J., Horner, R. H., Levin, J. R., Odom, S. L., Rindskopf, D. M., & Shadish, W. R. (2010). Single-case designs technical documentation. Retrieved from What Works Clearinghouse website: http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/pdf/wwc_scd.pdf
  44. Law, Z. W.,So, L. K.(2006).Phonological abilities of hearing-impaired cantonese-speaking children with cochlear implants or hearing aids.Journal of Speech, Language, and hearing research : JSLHR,49(6),1342-1353.
  45. Li, J.,Mayr, R.,Zhao, F.(2022).Speech production in Mandarin-speaking children with cochlear implants: A systematic review.International journal of Audiology,61(9),711-719.
  46. Lieu, J.(2013).Unilateral hearing loss in children: Speech-language and school performance.B-ENT,21,107-115.
  47. Lin, C. Y.,Tseng, Y. C.,Guo, H. R.,Lai, D. C.(2018).Prevalence of childhood hearing impairment of different severities in urban and rural areas: A nationwide population-based study in Taiwan.BMJ open,8(3),e020955.
  48. Martínez, V.,Herrero, A.,Morgan, G.(2019).Late phonological development in Spanish children with bilateral hearing loss/Desarrollo fonológico tardío en niños españoles con pérdidas auditivas bilaterales.Infanciay Aprendizaje,42(4),829-870.
  49. McReynolds, L. V.,Bennett, S.(1972).Distinctive feature generalization in articulation training.Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders,37(4),462-470.
  50. Moeller, M. P.,Hoover, B.,Putman, C.,Arbataitis, K.,Bohnenkamp, G.,Peterson, B.,Stelmachowicz, P.(2007).Vocalizations of infants with hearing loss compared with infants with normal hearing: Part I-phonetic development.Ear and Hearing,28(5),605-627.
  51. Montgomery, J. K.,Bonderman, I. R.(1989).Serving preschool children with severe phonological disorders.Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools,20(1),76-84.
  52. Öller Darelid, M.,Hartelius, L.,Lohmander, A.(2016).Generalised EPG treatment effect in a cochlear implant user maintained after 2 years.International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology,18(1),65-76.
  53. Öster, A.(1995).Teaching speech skills to deaf children by computer-based speech training.STL-Quarterly Progress and Status Report,36(4),67-75.
  54. Pantelemidou, V.,Herman, R.,Thomas, J.(2003).Efficacy of speech intervention using electropalatography with a cochlear implant user.Clinical linguistics & phonetics,17(4-5),383-392.
  55. Pourmohamadreza-Tajrishi, M.,Ashori, M.,Jalilabkenar, S. S.(2013).The effectiveness of emotional intelligence training on the mental health of male deaf students.Iranian Journal of Public Health,42(10),1174-1180.
  56. Prezas, R. F.,Magnus, L. C.,Hodson, B. W.(2021).The cycles approach.Interventions for speech sound disorders in children,Baltimore, MD:
  57. Reimers, T. M.,Wacker, D. P.(1988).Parents’ ratings of the acceptability of behavioral treatment recommendations made in an outpatient clinic: A preliminary analysis of the influence of treatment effectiveness.Behavioral Disorders,14(1),7-15.
  58. Roland, L.,Fischer, C.,Tran, K.,Rachakonda, T.,Kallogjeri, D.,Lieu, J. E.(2016).Quality of life in children with hearing impairment: Systematic review and meta-analysis.Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery,155(2),208-219.
  59. Rudolph, J. M.,Wendt, O.(2014).The efficacy of the cycles approach: A multiple baseline design.Journal of Communication Disorders,47,1-16.
  60. Stampe, D.(1979).A dissertation in natural phonology.New York, NY:Garland.
  61. Stelmachowicz, P. G.,Pittman, A. L.,Hoover, B. M.,Lewis, D. E.,Moeller, M. P.(2004).The importance of high-frequency audibility in the speech and language development of children with hearing loss.Archives of Otolaryngology-Head & Neck Surgery,130(5),556-562.
  62. Theunissen, S. C.,Rieffe, C.,Netten, A. P.,Briaire, J. J.,Soede, W.,Schoones, J. W.,Frijns, J. H.(2014).Psychopathology and its risk and protective factors in hearing-impaired children and adolescents: A systematic review.JAMA Pediatrics,168(2),170-177.
  63. Tucker, S.-K.(2013).Articulatory error patterns and phonological process use of preschool children with and without hearing loss.The Volta Review,113(2),87-125.
  64. Välimaa, T. T.,Kunnari, S. M.,Laukkanen-Nevala, P.,Ertmer, D. J.(2019).Vocal development in infants and toddlers with bilateral cochlear implants and infants with normal hearing.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research,62(5),1296-1308.
  65. VanRiper C. (1939). Speech correction: Principles and methods. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
  66. Warner-Czyz, A. D.,Davis, B. L.(2008).The emergence of segmental accuracy in young cochlear implant recipients.Cochlear Implants Int,9(3),143-166.
  67. 鈕文英, W. -I.,吳裕益, Y. -Y.(2015).單一個案研究法：研究設計與後設分析.台北=Taipei:心理=Psychological.
  68. 楊惠美, H. -M.,黃啓原, C. -Y.,佘永吉, Y. -J.,林怡蕙, Y. -H.,吳俊良, J. -L.(2003)。評量植入人工耳蝸兒童之說話清晰度。臺灣耳鼻喉頭頸外科雜誌，38(4)，146-152。
  69. 劉潔心, J. -X.(1986)。臺北市國民小學一年級聽覺損失學生國語音素構音能力及其相關因素之探討。特殊教育研究學刊，2，127-162。
  70. 鄭靜宜, J. -Y.(2018).華語兒童構音與音韻測驗.台北=Taipei:心理=Psychological.
print cancel