题名

支持服務輔導機制促動偏鄉教育變革之歷程探討：以高雄國民教育幼兒班為例

并列篇名

Exploration on the Process of the Support-Service Counseling Mechanism in Promoting Education Reform in Rural Areas: A Case of Indigenous Area and Offshore Island Preschool Programs in Kaohsiung

DOI

10.6209/JORIES.202309_68(3).0004

作者

戰寶華(Pao-Hwa Chan)

关键词

支持服務輔導機制 ； 偏鄉教育 ； 國民教育幼兒班 ； 變革歷程 ； support-service counseling mechanism ； rural education ； indigenous area and offshore island preschool programs (IAOIPP) ； reform process

期刊名称

教育科學研究期刊

卷期/出版年月

68卷3期（2023 / 09 / 01）

页次

95 - 139

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

偏鄉教育變革成效攸關教育是否均衡發展，以及學童是否享有公平教育機會與更好就學品質，是彰顯社會公平正義與扭轉弱勢族群困境之重要議題。本研究針對位處極偏區域之高雄國民教育幼兒班進行探討，以瞭解在教育資源極度匱乏下，應如何面對教育困境與啟動變革之舉措和歷程。研究採用質性個案分析之紮根理論研究法，並透過半結構式訪談蒐集第一線參與者之資料，以瞭解支持服務輔導計畫之效果。本研究共計訪談九人，包含巡迴輔導教授一人、巡迴輔導員三人與受輔導教師五人，並閱讀、比對其所提供之相關資料與文件。研究發現，因其位處極偏地區，外在環境限制影響深遠，而導入輔導機制是克服困境之契機，在歷經整頓建置期、轉型試煉期、扎根深化期、穩定成長期等四階段之變革歷程，獲致教保品質提升、專業知能深化及核心素養扎根之變革成效。
英文摘要

Research Motivation and Purpose: Remote schools often face a vicious cycle due to insufficient professional teachers, inadequate socioeconomic resources, and low student motivation, resulting in educational challenges. Therefore, effective practices for educational reform in remote areas should focus on teacher development, resource provision, curriculum design, and professional growth by implementing a transformative model to improve the quality of rural education. However, how to implement and promote these changes is a topic worthy of exploration and the main motivation behind this research. The effectiveness of educational reforms in remote areas is crucial for achieving balanced development in education, as well as ensuring equal educational opportunities and better learning quality for students. It is an important issue that highlights social fairness and justice and addresses the challenges faced by disadvantaged groups. In light of this, this study focuses on the investigation of the indigenous area and offshore island preschool programs (IAOIPP) in Kaohsiung, aiming to understand how to address educational challenges and initiate transformative processes of the support-service counseling mechanism in the context of extremely scarce educational resources. Literature Review: The literature review of this study focuses on two main aspects, including the exploration of rural education and the context of educational transformation in remote areas. It approaches the topic from various angles, such as the definition and impact of rural areas, the situation of rural education, the focal points of educational transformation, and the key factors in transformative change. The aim is to understand the core components and necessary measures for rural education reform. Based on this understanding, interview guidelines are developed to provide theoretical support for subsequent analysis and discussions. Concurrently, through the literature review, it is understood that the drivers of transformation should integrate the government's plans, local thinking, cultural characteristics, and potential dynamics of remote areas. By engaging in long-term reflection, adjustments, and participatory guidance, one can comprehend the dynamic trends and directions of development. This understanding will facilitate the provision of phased adjustment steps, practical transformative practices, and necessary resource allocation, leading to transformative outcomes that yield significant results. Research Method: The study adopts a qualitative case analysis using grounded theory research methodology and collects data through semi-structured interviews with frontline participants to understand the effectiveness of the IAOIPP. A total of nine individuals were interviewed, including one touring counseling professor, three itinerant assistants, and five remedial teachers. Since the study's interview subjects include participants with different job attributes, the interview guidelines also focus on different perspectives. The data analysis followed coding procedures based on grounded theory, including open coding, axial coding, selective coding, and coding for process. Various data collected from interviews, observations, notes, and documents were analyzed through processes of textualization, conceptualization, proposition, visualization, and theorization. Relevant information and documents provided by the participants were also reviewed and compared. Solid research results were obtained, and triangulation among multiple sources of data was employed to enhance the credibility of the research findings. Results: This research found that due to the remote location of the IAOIPP in Kaohsiung, the external environmental constraints have had a profound impact. Introducing the support-service counseling mechanism is an opportunity to overcome these challenges. The research has gone through four stages of transformation, namely the reorganization phase, the transformation phase, the rooting phase, and the stability phase, known as the RTRS transformation process. The process of four stages of significant change leads to improvements in educational quality, deepening of professional knowledge and skills, and the establishment of a foundation for core competencies. In other words, the core perspective of the RTRS transformation process implies the significant importance of providing real transitive responsible services to children in remote areas. Furthermore, during the reorganization phase, by identifying problems, communicating solutions, establishing concepts, seeking support, and building networks, the aim is to break bad habits, reshape ideas, introduce routines, and establish systems to initiate the transformation. In the transformation stage, by understanding policy trends, emphasizing indigenous language teaching, internalizing intangible assets, and integrating resources while preserving cultural heritage, the goal is to accumulate transformative momentum and face challenges such as natural disasters. In the rooting phase, practices such as extending the concept of life as culture, discovering local cultural characteristics, and responding to children's localized experiences are carried out to promote ethnic culture and create unique curriculum features, thereby transforming the opportunity for change. Finally, in the stability phase, practices such as demonstrating excellent teaching abilities, deepening the learning organization, and self-reflective corrections are undertaken to achieve recognition and professional improvement, thereby implementing the outcomes of the transformation. Conclusions and Suggestions: According to the research findings, the following conclusions are proposed: 1. The extremely remote location of the IAOIPP in Kaohsiung has profound impacts due to the constraints of the external environment. The deeply ingrained conventional thinking has a significant influence on administration and teaching, making the challenges of change more severe compared to typical rural school educational development issues. 2. The introduction of the support-service counseling mechanism in IAOIPP of Kaohsiung increases the possibilities of problem-solving and nurturing professional growth. It also enhances the feasibility of stabilizing teaching staff and creating additional benefits, thereby providing an opportunity for overcoming difficulties through the mechanism. 3. The IAOIPP of Kaohsiung has gradually transformed and flourished through four major phases of reform. These include the promotion of transformative effects through reshaping institutional norms, the impact and effect of transformational trials through internalizing intangible resources, the concept extension and deepening benefits achieved through the design of distinctive curricula, and the motivating and elevating effects of stable growth recognized through continuous awards. 4. The effectiveness of the reform in the IAOIPP of Kaohsiung is closely related to the implementation of counseling mechanisms. The improvement of educational quality relies on collaboration from multiple parties and manifests in the children's competencies. Meanwhile, the effectiveness of the reform is rooted in the interactive stimulation of the reform mechanisms throughout the process. Sequential and progressive implementation of mechanisms helps accumulate momentum and expand the effects of transformation. Additionally, the substantial delivery of real transitive responsible services highlights the achievements of rural education reform. Finally, based on the conclusions, the suggestions are proposed, including addressing inherent environmental limitations and appropriate mechanisms for rural education reform, acknowledging the influence of the implementation of transformational mechanisms to the effectiveness of rural education reform, setting correct goals and continuously accumulating momentum for successful educational transformations, and employing the conceptual framework formed from this research for future studies.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 丁一顧, Y.-K.,王淑麗, S.-L.,江姮姬, H.-C.(2019)。國小校長共創式領導與教師專業學習社群關係之研究：以教師信任為中介變項。教育科學研究期刊，64(3)，237-264。
    連結：
  2. 吳清山, C.-S.,王令宜, L.-Y.,林雍智, Y.-C.(2021)。中小學教師換證制度之研究：體系內涵、遭遇阻力與配套措施。教育科學研究期刊，66(3)，161-190。
    連結：
  3. 林淑華, S.-H.,田秀蘭, H.-S.,盧鴻文, H.-W.(2020)。學校輔導教師督導者之督導經驗與學校輔導督導系統建構。教育心理學報，52(2)，311-336。
    連結：
  4. 郭俊呈, C.-C.,侯雅雯, Y.-W.(2017)。翻轉教室觀點融入偏鄉教育之省思。師資培育與教師專業發展期刊，10(1)，33-48。
    連結：
  5. 陳茹玲, J.-L.,柯華葳, H.-W.,蔡佩真, P.-C.(2020)。從教師認知、教學資源與教學實踐論國語文教育政策之困境與契機。教育科學研究期刊，65(1)，47-91。
    連結：
  6. 黃東益, T.-Y.,謝忠安, C.-A.(2014)。縣市合併改制議題之研究：以高雄市、臺南市及臺中市為例。東吳政治學報，32(3)，51-130。
    連結：
  7. 楊永年, Y.-N.(2009)。八八水災救災體系之研究。公共行政學報，32，143-169。
    連結：
  8. 簡菲莉, F.-L.,陳佩英, P.-Y.(2018)。一所高中學校轉型之歷程研究：活動理論取徑。教育研究與發展期刊，14(3)，65-100。
    連結：
  9. 教育部國民及學前教育署（2020b）。教育部國民及學前教育署補助辦理公私立幼兒園輔導作業原則。https://edu.law.moe.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=FL038235 【K-12 Education Administration, Ministry of Education. (2020b). The K-12 education administration of the Ministry of Education subsidizes the principles of public and private preschools’ tutoring operations. https://edu.law.moe.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=FL038235】
  10. 教育部（2017）。偏遠地區學校教育發展條例。https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll. aspx?pcode=H0070073 【Ministry of Education. (2017). Act for education development of schools in remote areas. https://law.moj.gov.tw/ ENG/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=H0070073】
  11. 教育部國民及學前教育署（2022）。教育部國民及學前教育署補助辦理教保服務機構輔導作業原則。https://edu.law.moe.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=FL038235 【K-12 Education Administration, Ministry of Education. (2022). The K-12 education administration of the Ministry of Education subsidizes the principles of educare service institutions’ tutoring operations. https://edu.law. moe.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=FL038235】
  12. Alazmi, A. A.,Al-Mahdy, Y.(2020).Principal authentic leadership and teacher engagement in Kuwait’s educational reform context.Educational Management Administration & Leadership,50(3),392-412.
  13. Al-Omari, K.,Okasheh, H.(2017).The influence of work environment on job performance: A case study of engineering company in Jordan.International Journal of Applied Engineering Research,12(24),15544-15550.
  14. Battilossi, S.(Ed.),Cassis, Y.(Ed.),Yago, K.(Ed.)(2020).Handbook of the history of money and currency.Springer.
  15. Bibby, P.,Shepherd, J.(2004).The methodologyThe methodology,Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.
  16. Brown, D. L.,Schafft, K. A.(2011).Rural people and communities in the 21st century: Resilience and transformation.Polity Press.
  17. Byrnes, R. S.(2003).Extending educational reform.The Educational Forum,68(1),90-91.
  18. Campbell-Halfaker, D. C.,Gregor, M. A.(2021).The importance of cultural context in rural education: Historical and modern perspectives.Psychology from the Margins,3(1),3.
  19. Carpenter, M.,Bauer, T.,Erdogan, B.,Short, J.(2014).Principles of management.Flat World Knowledge.
  20. Chan, M. W.,Eppich, W. J.(2020).The keyword effect: A grounded theory study exploring the role of keywords in clinical communication.AEM Education and Training,4(4),403-410.
  21. Charmaz, K.(2014).Constructing grounded theory.Sage.
  22. Chun Tie, Y.,Birks, M.,Francis, K.(2019).Grounded theory research: A design framework for novice researchers.SAGE Open Medicine,7,1-8.
  23. Coburn, A. F., MacKinney, A. C., McBride, T. D., Mueller, K. J., Slifkin, R. T., & Wakefield, M. K. (2007). Choosing rural definitions: Implications for health policy (Issue Brief No. 2). Rural Policy Research Institute Health. http://www. rupri.org/Forms/RuralDefinitionsBrief.pdf
  24. Collins, J.(2019).Turning the flywheel: A monograph to accompany good to great.Random House.
  25. Corbin, J.,Strauss, A.(2015).Basics of qualitative research: Techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory.Sage.
  26. Cordova, R. A.(Ed.),Reynolds, W. M.(Ed.)(2020).Educating for social justice: Field notes from rural communities.Brill.
  27. Creswell, J. W.(2012).Educational research: Planning, conducting, and evaluating quantitative and qualitative research.Pearson.
  28. Critchlow, H.(2019).The science of fate: Why your future is more predictable than you think.Hodder & Stoughton.
  29. Denzin, N. K.(2009).The research act: A theoretical introduction to sociological methods.Routledge.
  30. Douglas, L. N.,Webster, V.(2015).Readiness of chief executives for transformational change across health, councils and third sector in Scotland to lead public service reform: A grounded theory approach.International Journal of Integrated Care,15(5),1-2.
  31. Edralin, D. M.(2015).Why do workers misbehave in the workplace.Journal of Management,2(1),88-108.
  32. Farid, P.(2021).Sifting interactional trust through institutions to manage trust in project teams: An organizational change project.Project Management Journal,52(5),504-520.
  33. Fishman, D.(2015).School reform for rural America: Innovate with charters, expand career and technical education.Education Next,15(3),8-17.
  34. Fry, G. W.,Bi, H.(2013).The evolution of educational reform in Thailand: The Thai educational paradox.Journal of Educational Administration,51(3),290-319.
  35. Gaikhorst, L.,Beishuizen, J. J. J.,Zijlstra, B. J. H.,Volman, M. L. L.(2017).The sustainability of a teacher professional development programme for beginning urban teachers.Cambridge Journal of Education,47(1),135-154.
  36. Guo, D.(Ed.)(2023).The frontier of education reform and development in China: Articles from educational research.Springer.
  37. Hachtmann, F.(2012).The process of general education reform from a faculty perspective: A grounded theory approach.The Journal of General Education,61(1),16-38.
  38. Harper, D.(Ed.),Thompson, A. R.(Ed.)(2012).Qualitative research in mental health and psychotherapy: A guide for students and practitioners.John Wiley & Sons.
  39. Hawley, L. R.,Koziol, N. A.,Bovaird, J. A.,McCormick, C. M.,Welch, G. W.,Arthur, A. M.,Bash, K.(2016).Defining and describing rural: Implications for rural special education research and policy.Rural Special Education Quarterly,35(3),3-11.
  40. Haynes, M.(2022).The impacts of school closure on rural communities in Canada: A review.The Rural Educator,43(2),60-74.
  41. Huibin, G. A. O.(2022).Deficiencies in the focus: Rural teacher policy evolution analysis-reflections on the ten-year implementation of the outline of China’s national plan for medium-and long-term education reform and development (2010-2020).Frontiers of Education in China,17(3),301-324.
  42. Hushman, G.,Hushman, C.,Carbonneau, K.(2015).Addressing educational reform: Exploring PE metrics as a system to measure student achievement in physical education.Physical Educator,72(1),179-191.
  43. Hussain, S. T.,Lei, S.,Akram, T.,Haider, M. J.,Hussain, S. H.,Ali, M.(2018).Kurt Lewin’s change model: A critical review of the role of leadership and employee involvement in organizational change.Journal of Innovation & Knowledge,3(3),123-127.
  44. Hussein, F.,Stephens, J.,Tiwari, R.(2020).Grounded theory as an approach for exploring the effect of cultural memory on psychosocial well-being in historic urban landscapes.Social Sciences,9(12),219.
  45. Johnson, C.(2013).Educational turbulence: The influence of macro and micro-policy on science education reform.Journal of Science Teacher Education,24(4),693-715.
  46. Karami Akkary, R.(2014).Facing the challenges of educational reform in the Arab world.Journal of Educational Change,15(2),179-202.
  47. Khandelwal, S. A.,Pathan, F. C.(2012).A simplified approach for using information and communication technology in primary education for the development of rural area.International Journal of Advanced Research in Computer Science,3(1),360-362.
  48. Kish, L.(1995).Survey sampling.Wiley.
  49. Koziol, N.,Arthur, A.,Hawley, L.,Bovaird, J.,Bash, K.,McCormick, C.,Welch, G.(2015).Identifying, analyzing, and communicating rural: A quantitative perspective.Journal of Research in Rural Education,30(4),1-14.
  50. Krantz, J.(2006).Dilemmas of organizational change: A systems psychodynamic perspective.The systems psychodynamics of organizations: Integrating the group relations approach, psychoanalytic, and open systems perspectives
  51. La Prad, J.(2015).The coalition of essential schools and rural educational reform.The Rural Educator,36(3),1-15.
  52. Lambert, M.(Ed.)(2019).Practical research methods in education: An early researcher’s critical guide.Routledge.
  53. Li, L.,Huang, C.,Chen, X.,Tao, L.,Huang, Y.,Zhou, X.(2018).Reform course and development status of China’s education system.Reform and development of educational system
  54. Luttenberg, J.,Carpay, T.,Veugelers, W.(2013).Educational reform as a dynamic system of problems and solutions: Towards an analytic instrument.Journal of Educational Change,14(3),335-352.
  55. Lyubimov, I.(2016).Are educational reforms necessarily growth-enhancing? Weak institutions as the cause of policy failure.BOFIT Policy Brief,2016(7),3-8.
  56. Man, V.(2012).Educational reform: From school to later life.International Review of Education,58(2),147-149.
  57. McSwan, D.,Scott, T.,Haas, T.(1995).Conference report: Issues affecting rural communities.Journal of Research in Rural Education,11(1),66-71.
  58. Mehdibeigi, N.,Kamalian, A. R.,Yaghoubi, N. M.,Pourezzat, A. A.,Ronaghi, M. H.(2020).Developing administrative system reform capability considering smart organization based on grounded theory approach.Organizational Resources Management Research,9(3),111-132.
  59. Memon, F. A.(2021).Improving employee’s engagement in change: Reassessing Kurt Lewin’s model.City University Research Journal,11(1),144-164.
  60. Miller, B.(1993).Rural distress and survival: The school and the importance of community.Journal of Research in Rural Education,9(2),84-103.
  61. Moletsane, R.(2012).Repositioning educational research on rurality and rural education in South Africa: Beyond deficit paradigms.Perspectives in Education,30(1),1-8.
  62. Morris, A.(2015).A practical introduction to in-depth interviewing.Sage.
  63. Mulcahy, D. M.(2009).Developing government policies for successful rural education in Canada.Improving Equity in Rural Education,23,23-32.
  64. Neal, J.(Ed.)(2018).Handbook of personal and organizational transformation.Springer.
  65. Nicotera, A. M.(Ed.)(2019).Origins and traditions of organizational communication: A comprehensive introduction to the field.Routledge.
  66. Nutbrown, C.,Clough, P.(2014).Early childhood education: History, philosophy and experience.Sage.
  67. Ogawa, R.(2015).Change of mind: How organization theory led me to move from studying educational reform to pursuing educational design.Journal of Educational Administration,53(6),794-804.
  68. Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development(2016).OECD regional outlook 2016: Productive regions for inclusive societies.
  69. Padhi, S.,Mishra, S.(2017).Effect of honesty as an ethical value on software project performance: A grounded theory approach.Journal of Human Values,23(2),92-105.
  70. Patton, M. Q.(2015).Qualitative research & evaluation methods: Integrating theory and practice.Sage.
  71. Pharis, T.,Wu, E.,Sullivan, S.,Moore, L.(2019).Improving teacher quality: Professional development implications from teacher professional growth and effectiveness system implementation in rural Kentucky high schools.Educational Research Quarterly,42(3),29-48.
  72. Pizzoli, E.,Gong, X.(2007).How to best classify rural and urban?.International Conference on Agriculture Statistics IV-Advancing Statistical Integration and Analysis,Beijing, China:
  73. Plessis, V.,Beshiri, R.,Bollman, R. D.,Clemenson, H.(2001).Definitions of rural.Rural and Small Town Canada Analysis Bulletin,3(3),1-17.
  74. Senge, P.(2006).The fifth discipline: The art and practice of the learning organization.Doubleday.
  75. Shao, H.,Tao, P.(2017).Behavioral logic of community health service institutions in the background of the new healthcare reform based on the grounded theory.Chinese Journal of Health Policy,10(3),54-60.
  76. Sher, J.(Ed.)(2019).Education in rural America: A reassessment of conventional wisdom.Routledge.
  77. Sher, J.(Ed.)(2019).Reform and resistance: Rural school improvement projects in the United States.Routledge.
  78. Sprott, R.(2019).Factors that foster and deter advanced teachers’ professional development.Teaching and Teacher Education,77,321-331.
  79. Tate IV, W. F.(2008).“Geography of opportunity”: Poverty, place, and educational outcomes.Educational Researcher,37(7),397-411.
  80. Thomas, J.,Cooper, S.(2016).The road to reform: A grounded theory study of parents’ and teachers’ influence on elementary school science and mathematics.School Science and Mathematics,116(1),29-42.
  81. Valckx, J.,Devos, G.,Vanderlinde, R.(2018).Exploring the relationship between professional learning community characteristics in departments, teachers’ professional development, and leadership.Pedagogische Studiën,95(1),34-55.
  82. Vardi, Y.,Weitz, E.(2004).Misbehavior in organizations: Theory, research, and management.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  83. Waltz, S.(2019).Tutor training for service learning: Impact on self-efficacy beliefs.Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning,27(1),26-43.
  84. Weiner, I. B.(Ed.),Craighead, W. E.(Ed.)(2010).The Corsini encyclopedia of psychology.John Wiley & Sons.
  85. Wilkerson, K.(2009).An examination of burnout among school counselors guided by stress-strain-coping theory.Journal of Counseling & Development,87(4),428-437.
  86. Woollen, S.,Otto, S.(2014).Intended consequences: Challenging white teachers’ habitus and its influence in urban schools implementing an arts-based educational reform.The Urban Review,46(1),86-111.
  87. Wright, J. D.(Ed.)(2015).International encyclopedia of the social & behavioral science.International encyclopedia of the social & behavioral Elsevier.
  88. 內政部（2015）。內政部定義屬「偏遠地區」鄉鎮地區。http://www.genb2b.com/eDM/ 2015_SERVICE/SPACE.pdf 【Ministry of Interior. (2015). The township region of rural area defined by the Ministry of Interior. http://www. genb2b.com/eDM/2015_SERVICE/SPACE.pdf】
  89. 內政部（2009，6月29日）。高雄縣市合併改制計畫。行政院公報，15（170）。https://www. rootlaw.com.tw/Attach/L-Doc/A040040031006900-0980901-1000-001.pdf 【Ministry of the Interior. (2009, June 29). Merger and restructuring plan of Kaohsiung County and City. Bulletin of Executive Yuan, 15(170). https://www.rootlaw.com.tw/Attach/L-Doc/A040040031006900-0980901-1000-001.pdf】
  90. 王政忠, C.-C.(2017).我有一個夢：一場溫柔而堅定的體制內革命.天下文化=Bookzone.
  91. 朱美娟, M.-C.(2021)。紮根理論研究方法：不同陣營之間的比較與選擇。市北教育學刊，68，1-22。
  92. 何俊青, C.-C.(2022)。臺灣教育的城鄉差距：偏鄉學校實徵研究的分析。教育研究月刊，334，4-19。
  93. 吳清山, C.-S.(2018)。偏鄉教育。教育研究月刊，287，146-147。
  94. 林秀芬, S.-F.,許振華, Z.-H.(2014)。臺中市政府文化局研究報告臺中市政府文化局研究報告,臺中市政府=Taichung City Government。
  95. 國民教育幼兒班教保訪視與巡迴輔導工作小組（2021）。110學年度國民教育幼兒班教保訪視與巡迴輔導工作小組─教保服務人員參考手冊。教育部國民及學前教育署。http:// kid.magong.com.tw/guidance2.php?cid=001 【Educational Care Visit and Tour Guidance Working Group of IAOIPP. (2021). Reference manual of the 2021 school year for IAOIPP service staff. K-12 Education Administration, Ministry of Education. http://kid.magong. com.tw/guidance2.php?cid=001】
  96. 張凱程, K.-C.,逢益, F.-Y.,林俊瑩, C.-Y.(2022)。偏鄉幼兒教育品質的維繫：國民教育幼兒班巡迴輔導工作的理解、實踐與反思。教育研究月刊，334，70-85。
  97. 教育部（2008）。扶持5歲幼兒教育計畫。https://www.grow22.com/download/school/school_1.pdf 【Ministry of Education (2017). The supportive education programs for five-years-old children. https://www.grow22. com/download/school/school_1.pdf】
  98. 教育部（2021）。教育部教學卓越獎複選審查實施計畫。https://cirn.moe.edu.tw/Upload/file/ Plan/74/94170.pdf 【Ministry of Education. (2021). The second-round evaluation of the implementation plan of the Ministry of Education teaching excellence award. https://cirn.moe.edu.tw/Upload/file/Plan/74/94170.pdf】
  99. 教育部國民及學前教育署（2020a）。教育部推國幼班輔導15年強化離島原民地區幼兒園幼教品質。https://www.edu.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=9E7AC85F1954DDA8&s=8565E812FD852BE2 【K-12 Education Administration, Ministry of Education. (2020a). The Ministry of Education promotes tutoring mechanism for 15 years to strengthen the quality of preschool in the indigenous areas and offshore islands. https://www.edu.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=9E7AC85F1954DDA8&s=8565E812FD852BE2】
  100. 教育部統計處（2022）。110學年各級學校名錄及異動一覽表─偏遠地區學校。https:// stats.moe.gov.tw/files/school/110/faraway_new.xls 【Department of Statistics, Ministry of Education. (2020). The primary and secondary schools in rural areas– A list of transitional schools at all levels in the 110 school year. http://stats.moe.gov.tw/ files/school/110/faraway_new.xls】
  101. 詹志禹, C.-Y.,吳璧純, P.-C.(2015)。偏鄉教育創新發展。教育研究月刊，258，28-41。
  102. 鄭昭玲, C.-L.,王雅玄, Y.-H.(2021)。偏鄉教育論述分析：《偏遠地區學校教育發展條例》系統析論。中正教育研究，20(2)，1-36。
print cancel