學科補習之動態變化對學習成就族群落差的影響：以屏東縣小學生為例

Influence of Dynamic Changes in Subject Supplementary Education on Ethnic Gap in Learning Achievement: A Case of Elementary School Students in Pingtung County

10.3966/181665042016121204002

林俊瑩(Chunn-Ying Lin)

追蹤普查 ； 動態變化 ； 潛在成長模式分析 ； 學科補習 ； 學習族群落差 ； dynamic changes ； ethnic gap in learning achievement ； follow-up general survey ； latent growth curve modeling ； subject supplementary education

教育研究與發展期刊

12卷4期（2016 / 12 / 31）

23 - 55

繁體中文

學科補習向來被認為是很重要的課後教育資源，因此就有不少研究者關注於學科補習對族群學習落差的影響。不過，學科補習資源的多寡，除了與家庭社經地位有關外，還會隨著時間而變動，因此其持續動態的變化對不同族群學生學習成就落差的影響更值得探究。基於上述，本研究運用屏東教育長期追蹤資料庫的小學生與家長三年固定樣本追蹤普查（N = 8,960），並採用潛在成長模式進行學科補習（包括時間與花費）對學習成就族群落差的動態影響分析。研究發現：一開始接受學科補習量越多的學生，往後參與補習量並沒有增加愈快的趨勢，兩者反而呈現負相關。其次，初始補習參與量對日後學習表現的影響不顯著，有顯著正影響的是補習參與量的增長趨勢。另外，原住民，或是母親為東南亞國籍之學生，起始成績差，而學科補習量增長相對較少，使其後續學習表現明顯較差。最後，母親具中國籍身分的新住民學生，學科補習供給量增加趨勢，乃至於後續的學習成就均未呈現劣勢。

Subject supplementary education has always been regarded as a very important after school educational resource. Thus, many researchers consider the influence of subject supplementary education on the ethnic learning gap. However, the number of subject supplementary educational resources is not only associated with families' socioeconomic status, but also varies over times. Therefore, the influence of continuous dynamic changes on the learning achievements of students of different populations is worthy of investigation. Given the lack of studies that can provide answers to this issue, this study used the 3-year follow-up general survey on elementary school students and parents (N = 8,960) from Pingtung Education Longitudinal Survey (PELS), and applied latent growth curve modeling to analyze the dynamic influence of subject supplementary education (including time and cost) on the ethnic gap in learning achievements at multiple time points. The research findings show that: firstly, the subsequent amount of supplementary education received by students who had received a larger amount of initial subject supplementary education did not rapidly increase with the amount of the initial subject supplementary education. Moreover, while the amount of initial supplementary education did not have a significant influence on future learning performance, it has a significantly positive influence on the increased amount of supplementary education. Furthermore, the initial learning performance of students who are aboriginals or whose mothers are from the Southeast Asian countries was poor, and the increase in their amount of subject supplementary education was relatively small compared with that of their counterparts, as well as their future learning performance was significantly much poorer. Finally, neither the increased amount of subject supplementary education of new immigrant students whose mothers are from Mainland China, nor their future learning performance, showed inferiority.

1. 王鴻龍、楊孟麗、陳俊如、林定香(2012)。缺失資料在因素分析上的處理方法之研究。教育科學研究期刊，57(1)，29-50。
   連結：
2. 王麗雲、游錦雲(2005)。學童社經背景與暑期經驗對暑期學習成就進展影響之研究。教育研究集刊，51(4)，1-41。
   連結：
3. 吳金香、張茂源、王昇泰(2007)。從兒童學習觀點談新住民子女的教育問題。學校行政，50，269-281。
   連結：
4. 李佩嬛、黃毅志(2011)。原漢族群、家庭背景與高中職入學考試基測成績、教育分流：以臺東縣為例。教育科學研究期刊，56(1)，193-226。
   連結：
5. 林大森、陳憶芬(2006)。臺灣高中生參加補習之效益分析。教育研究集刊，52(4)，35-70。
   連結：
6. 林定香、藍信龍(2008)。缺失資料對潛在類別迴歸模式參數估計之影響。中國統計學報，46，197-212。
   連結：
7. 林慧敏(2012)。造成原漢族群高中入學考試基測成績不同之影響機制：以台東縣國三生為例。教育研究與發展期刊，8(2)，151-182。
   連結：
8. 林慧敏、黃毅志(2009)。原漢族群、補習教育與學業成績關聯之研究－以臺東地區國中二年級生為例。當代教育研究，17(3)，41-81。
   連結：
9. 邱冠斌(2008)。新竹縣外籍配偶子女國小一年級國語文學習成就之研究－以竹北市為例。中華行政學報，5，145-163。
   連結：
10. 陳俊瑋、黃毅志(2011)。重探學科補習的階層化與效益：Wisconsin 模型的延伸。教育研究集刊，57(1)，101-135。
    連結：
11. 陳建州(2010)。影響跨國婚姻子女學習成就之因素—父母「外籍身份」的效果。臺東大學教育學報，21(2)，61-89。
    連結：
12. 黃毅志、陳俊瑋(2008)。學科補習、成績表現與升學結果：以學測成績與上公立大學為例。教育研究集刊，54(1)，117-149。
    連結：
13. 劉正(2006)。補習在臺灣的變遷、效能與階層化。教育研究集刊，52(4)，1-34。
    連結：
14. 關秉寅、李敦義(2010)。國中生數學補得越久，數學成就越好嗎？傾向分數配對法的分析。教育研究集刊，56(2)，105-139。
    連結：
15. 國立屏東大學統計工作室（2016）。計畫簡介。取自於http://www.pels.nptu.edu.tw/files/11-1034-8.php?Lang=zh-tw
16. Barnes, G. M.,Reifman, A. S.,Farrell, M. P.,Dintcheff, B. A.(2000).The effects of parenting on the development of adolescent alcohol misuse: A six-wave latent growth model.Journal of Marriage and the Family,62(1),175-186.
17. Bentler, P. M.,Bonett, D. G.(1980).Signifi cance tests and goodness of fit in the analysis of covariance structures.Psychological Bulletin,88,588-606.
18. Bray, M.(2013).Shadow education: Comparative perspectives on the expansion and implications of private supplementary.Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,77,412-420.
19. Bray, M.,Zhan, S.,Lykins, C.,Wang, D.,Kwo, O.(2014).Differentiated demand for private supplementary tutoring: Patterns and implications in Hong Kong secondary education.Economics of Education Review,38,24-37.
20. Brown-Jeffy, S.(2009).School effects: Examining the race gap in mathematics achievement.Journal of Africa- American Study,13,388-405.
21. Buchmann, C.,Condron, D. J.,Roscigno, V. J.(2010).Shadow education, American Style: Test preparation, the SAT and college enrollment.Social Forces,89(2),435-462.
22. Burchinal, M.,McCartney, K.,Steinberg, L.,Crosnoe, R.,Friedman, S. L.,McLoyd, V.,Pianta, R.(2011).Examining the black-white achievement gap among lowincome children using the NICHD study of early child care and youth development.Child Development,82(5),1404-1420.
23. Byun, S. Y.,Park, H.(2012).The academic success of East Asian American youth: The role of shadow education.Sociology of Education,85,40-60.
24. Camerson, C. E.,Grimm, K. J.,Steele, J. S.,Castro-Schilo, L.,Grissmer, D. W.(2015).Nonlinear gompertz curve models of achievement gaps in mathematics and reading.Journal of Educational Psychology,107(3),789-804.
25. Chen, W. W.,Wong, Y. L.(2014).What my parents maks me believe in learning: The role of fi lial pieth in Hong Kong students' motivation and academic achievement.International Journal of Psychology,49(4),249-256.
26. Collins, A. M.,Layer, J. I.,Kreader, J. L.,Werner, A.,Glantz, F. B.(2000).,未出版
27. Dearing, E.,Taylor, B. A.(2007).Home improvements: Within-family associations between income and the quality of children's home environments.Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology,28,427-444.
28. Duncan, T. E.,Duncan, S. C.,Stoolmiller, M.(1994).Modeling developmental processes using latent growth structural equation methodology.Applied Psychological Measurement,18,343-354.
29. Farfan-Portet, M. I.,Lorant, V.,Petrella, F.(2011).Access to childcare services: The role of demand and supply-side policies.Population Research and Policy Review,30(2),165-183.
30. Furlong, M.,Quirk, M.(2011).The relative effects of chronological age on Hispanic students' school readiness and grade 2 academic achievement.Contemporary School Psychology,15,81-92.
31. Jenkins, L.,Demaray, M. K.(2015).Indirect effects in the peer victimization-academic achievement realtion: The role of academic self-concept and gender.Psychology in the Schools,52(3),235-247.
32. Jung, J. H.,Lee, K. H.(2010).The determinants of private tutoring participation and attendant expenditures in Korea.Asian Pacifi c Education Review,11,159-168.
33. Kenayathulla, H. B.(2013).Household expenditures on private tutoring: Emerging evidence from Malaysia.Asia Pacifi c Education Review,14,629-644.
34. Kim, J. H.,Park, D.(2010).The determinants of demand for private tutoring in South Korea.Asia Pacifi c Education Review,11,411-421.
35. Kline, R. B.(2011).Principles and practice of structural equation modeling.New York, NY:Guilford.
36. Kuan, P. Y.(2011).Effects of cram schooling on mathematics performance: Evidence from junior high students in Taiwan.Comparative Education Review,55,342-369.
37. Lee, S.,Shouse, R. C.(2011).The impact of prestige orientation on shadow education in South Korea.Sociology of Education,84(3),212-224.
38. Lin, C. Y.,Hsieh, Y. H.,Chen, C. H.(2015).Use of latent growth curve modeling for assessing the effects of summer and after-school learning on adolescent students' achievement gap.Asia Pacifi c Education Review,16,49-61.
39. Liu, J.(2012).Does cram schooling matter? Who goes to cram schools? Evidence from Taiwan.International Journal of Educational Development,32,46-52.
40. Liu, Y. C.,Hung, H.,Lin, C.Y.(2014).Effects of cram schooling on ethnic learning achievement gap: Evidence from elementary school students in Taiwan.Paper presented at the International Business Research, Economics, Finance and MIS Conference,Okinawa, Japan:
41. Phillipson, S. N.,Tse, K. A.(2007).Discovering patterns of achievement in Hong Kong students: An application of the Rasch measurement model.High Ability Studies,18(2),173-190.
42. Phillipson, S.,Phillipson, S. N.(2012).Children's cognitive ability and their academic achievement: The mediation effects of parental expectations.Asia Pacific Education Review,13,495-508.
43. Rhy, D.,Kang, C.(2013).Do private tutoring expenditures raise academic performance? Evidence from middle school students in South Korea.Asian Economic Journal,27,59-83.
44. Rojas-LeBoouef, A.,Slate, J. R.(2011).The achievement gap between white and non-white students: A conceptual analysis.International Journal of Educational Leadership Preparation,64(1),1-33.
45. Rowley, R.,Wright, D. W.(2011).No "White" child left behind: The academic achievement gap between black and white students.The Journal of Negro Education,80,93-107.
46. Shih, Y. P.,Yi, C. C.(2014).Cultivating the difference: Social class, parental values, cultural capital and children's after-school activities in Taiwan.Journal of Comparative Family Studies,45,55-75.
47. Stevenson, D. L.,Baker, D. P.(1992).Shadow education and allocation in formal schooling: Transition to university in Japan.American Journal of Sociology,97,1639-1657.
48. Tabachnick, B. G.,Fidell, L. S.(2013).Using multivariate statistics.Boston, MA:Pearson.
49. Weiser, D. A.,Riggio, H. R.(2010).Family background and academic achievement: Does self-effi cacy mediate outcomes?.Social Psychology of Education,13(3),367-383.
50. Whitley, J.,Rawana, E.,Brownlee, K.(2014).A comparison of aboriginal and nonaboriginal students on the inter-related dimensions of self-concept, strengths and achievement.Brock Education: A Journal of Educational Research and Practice,23(2),24-46.
51. Wu, P. C.(2008).Modern robust methods for covariance in structural equation modeling: ADF, SCALED, and Bootstrapping.Journal of Education & Psychology,30(4),1-22.
52. Yoshikawa, H.,Gassman-Pines, A.,Morris, P.,Gennetian, L. A.,Godfrey, E. B.(2010).Racial /ethnic differences in effects of welfare policies on early school readiness and later achievement.Applied Development Science,14(3),137-153.
53. You, S.,Ho, H.,Hong, S.(2011).Longitudinal effects of perceived control on academic achievement.The Journal of Educational Research,104,253-266.
54. Zadeh, Z. Y.,Farnia, F.,Ungerleider, C.(2010).How home enrichment mediates the relationship between maternal education and children's achievement in reading and math.Early Education and Development,21(4),568-594.
55. Zhang, Y.(2013).Does private tutoring improve students' national college entrance exam performance? A case study from Jinan, China.Economics of Education Review,32,1-28.
56. 王振世、蔡清中(2008)。臺灣外籍配偶子女學習適應與學業成就之間的關係：東南亞、大陸與本國籍配偶子女的比較。教育政策論壇，11(2)，75-105。
57. 江芳盛(2006)。國中生課業補習效果之探討。臺北市立教育大學學報：教育類，37(1)，131-148。
58. 林大森(2012)。補習效益的再探討—以技職體系為例。台東大學教育學報，23(1)，38-77。
59. 林俊瑩、謝亞恆、陳成宏(2014)。暑期學習對族群學習差距的影響：潛在成長曲線模型分析。教育政策論壇，17(4)，103-134。
60. 孫清山、黃毅志(1996)。補習教育、文化資本與教育取得。臺灣社會學刊，19，95-139。
61. 陳玉樹、黃財尉、黃芳銘(2006)。結構方程模式的基本原理。高雄市:麗文。
62. 陳毓文(2000)。新住民家庭青少年子女生活適應狀況模式檢測。教育心理學報，42(1)，29-52。
63. 黃沛文、唐淑芬(2007)。新住民子女教育困境與因應策略。研習資訊，24(6)，139-148。
64. 黃芳銘(2003)。結構方程模式理論與應用。臺北市:五南。
65. 蔡瑞全(2006)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。花蓮市，國立花蓮教育大學國民教育研究所。