题名

不當督導研究回顧與前瞻

并列篇名

Abusive Supervision: Retrospect and Prospect

DOI

10.6129/CJP.20140529

作者

胡昌亞(Chang-Ya Hu)；鄭瑩妮(Ying-Ni Cheng)

关键词

不當督導 ； 華人組織行為 ； 組織正義 ； 職場行為 ； abusive supervision ； Chinese organizational behavior ； organizational justice ； work behavior

期刊名称

中華心理學刊

卷期/出版年月

56卷2期（2014 / 06 / 01）

页次

191 - 214

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

自Tepper於2000年發表不當督導（abusive supervision）的主題文章起，此構念已在負向領導的研究領域中蓬勃發展。本文針對西方與華人不當督導之研究，進行回顧與前瞻。我們首先回顧不當督導之定義、內涵、測量、與構念效度證據，以瞭解不當督導之邏輯意義網絡（nomological network）。接著，我們透過比較西方與華人情境脈絡下不當督導研究結果之異同，試圖瞭解不當督導在華人文化脈絡中可能意涵。最後，我們將根據回顧之結果，指出不當督導未來研究方向及在華人研究上之意涵，為本文提出結論。
英文摘要

Since Tepper’s (2000) pioneering work on abusive supervision, this topic has become prevalent in the research domain of negative leader behavior. In this review article, we aim to provide an integrated model of abusive supervision for future research. We first discuss the nomological network of abusive supervision by introducing its definition, content, measurement, and construct validity evidence. We then discuss the possible meaning of abusive supervision under Chinese culture context by comparing abusive supervision studies conducted in the Western context with the studies conducted in the Chinese context. Finally, we propose recommendations for future study, especially those in the context of Chinese organizations.
主题分类 社會科學 > 心理學
参考文献
  1. 余明助、郭嘉博(2009)。組織公正、負面情感以及組織公民行為之關係研究：以主管不當監督為中介變項。中山管理評論，17，367-396。
    連結：
  2. 吳宗祐(2008)。由不當督導到情緒耗竭：部屬正義知覺與情緒勞動的中介效果。中華心理學刊，50，201-221。
    連結：
  3. 吳宗祐、徐瑋伶、鄭伯壎(2002)。怒不可遏或忍氣吞聲：華人企業主管威權領導與部屬憤怒反應。本土心理學研究，18，3-49。
    連結：
  4. 周婉茹、周麗芳、鄭伯壎、任金剛(2010)。專權與尚嚴之辨：再探威權領導的內涵與恩威並濟的效果。本土心理學研究，34，223-284。
    連結：
  5. 郭建志、蔡育菁(2012)。組織挫折與職場退縮：主管不當督導與工作內外控之研究。中華心理學刊，54，293-313。
    連結：
  6. 樊景立、鄭伯壎(2000)。華人組織的家長式領導：一項文化觀點的分析。本土心理學研究，13，127-180。
    連結：
  7. Andersson, L. M.,Pearson, C. M.(1999).Tit for tat? The spiraling effect of incivility in the workplace.Academy of Management Review,24,452-471.
  8. Aquino, K.,Grover, S. L.,Bradfield, M.,Allen, D. G.(1999).The effects of negative affectivity hierarchical status, and self-determination on workplace victimization.Academy of Management Journal,42,260-272.
  9. Aryee, S.,Chen, Z. X.,Sun, L. Y.,Debrah, Y. A.(2007).Antecedents and outcomes of abusive supervision: Test of a trickle-down model.Journal of Applied Psychology,92,191-201.
  10. Aryee, S.,Sun, L. Y.,Chen, Z. X. G.,Debrah, Y. A.(2008).Abusive supervision and contextual performance: The mediating role of emotional exhaustion and the moderating role of work unit structure.Management and Organization Review,4,393-411.
  11. Bamberger, P. A.,Bacharach, S. B.(2006).Abusive supervision and subordinate problem drinking: Taking resistance, stress and subordinate personality into account.Human Relations,59,723-752.
  12. Berkowitz, L.(1989).Frustration-aggression hypothesis: Examination and reformulation.Psychological Bulletin,106,59-73.
  13. Bies, R. J.,Tripp, T. M.(1996).Beyond distrust: "Getting even" and the need for revenge.Trust in organizations: Frontiers of theory and research,Thousand Oaks, CA:
  14. Bond, M. H.(Ed.)(1996).The handbook of Chinese psychology.Hong Kong:Oxford University Press.
  15. Brees, J.,Mackey, J.,Martinko, M.,Harvey, P..The mediating role of perceptions of abusive supervision in the relationship between personality and aggression.Journal of Leadership and Organizational Studies
  16. Burris, E. R.,Detert, J. R.,Chiaburu, D. S.(2008).Quitting before leaving: The mediating effects of psychological attachment and detachment on voice.Journal of Applied Psychology,93,912-922.
  17. Burton, J. P.,Hoobler, J. M.(2011).Aggressive reactions to abusive supervision: The role of interactional justice and narcissism.Scandinavian Journal of Psychology,52,389-398.
  18. Burton, J. P.,Hoobler, J. M.,Scheuer, M. L.(2012).Supervisor workplace stress and abusive supervision: The buffering effect of exercise.Journal of Business and Psychology,27,271-279.
  19. Carlson, D.,Ferguson, M.,Hunter, E.,Whitten, D.(2012).Abusive supervision and work-family conflict: The path through emotional labor and burnout.The Leadership Quarterly,23,849-859.
  20. Chen, F. F.(2008).What happens if we compare chopsticks with forks? The impact of making inappropriate comparisons in cross-cultural research.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,95,1005-1018.
  21. Cheng, B. S.,Chou, L. F.,Wu, T. Y.,Huang, M. P.,Farh, J. L.(2004).Paternalistic leadership and subordinate responses: Establishing a leadership model in Chinese organizations.Asian Journal of Social Psychology,7,89-117.
  22. Chi, S.-C. S.,Liang, S. G.(2013).When do subordinates' emotion-regulation strategies matter? Abusive supervision, subordinates' emotional exhaustion, and work withdrawal.The Leadership Quarterly,24,125-137.
  23. Clugston, M.,Howell, J. P.,Dorfman, P. W.(2000).Does cultural socialization predict multiple bases and foci of commitment?.Journal of Management,26,5-30.
  24. Cox, H.(1991).Verbal abuse nationwide, part I: Oppressed group behavior.Nursing Management,22,32-35.
  25. Cronshaw, S. F.,Lord, R. G.(1987).Effects of categorization, attribution, and encoding processes on leadership perceptions.Journal of Applied Psychology,72,97-106.
  26. Cross, S. E.,Bacon, P. L.,Morris, M. L.(2000).The relational-interdependent self-construal and relationships.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,78,791-808.
  27. Detert, J. R.,Trevino, L. K.,Burris, E. R.,Andiappan, M.(2007).Managerial modes of influence and counterproductivity in organizations: A longitudinal business-unit-level investigation.Journal of Applied Psychology,93,993-1005.
  28. Diaz, A. L.,McMillin, J. D.(1991).A definition and description of nurse abuse.Western Journal of Nursing Research,13,97-109.
  29. Ding, X. Q.,Tian, K.,Yang, C. S.,Gong, S. F.(2012).Abusive supervision and LMX Leaders' emotional intelligence as antecedent variable and trust as consequence variable.Chinese Management Studies,6,257-270.
  30. Duffy, M. K.,Ganster, D. C.,Pagon, M.(2002).Social undermining in the workplace.Academy of Management Journal,45,331-351.
  31. Dupre, K. E.,Inness, M.,Connelly, C. E.,Barling, J.,Hoption, C.(2006).Workplace aggression in teenage part-time employees.Journal of Applied Psychology,91,987-997.
  32. Eden, D.,Leviatan, U.(1973).Implicit leadership theory as a determinant of the factor structure underlying supervisory behavior scales.Journal of Applied Psychology,60,736-741.
  33. Farh, J. L.,Earley, P. C.,Lin, S. C.(1997).Impetus for action: A cultural analysis of justice and organizational citizenship behavior in Chinese society.Administrative Science Quarterly,42,421-444.
  34. Ferris, G. R.(Ed.),Treadway, D. C.(Ed.)(2012).Politics in organizations: Theory and research considerations.New York:Routledge.
  35. Goodyear, R. K.,Crego, C. A.,Johnston, M. W.(1992).Ethical issues in the supervision of student research: A study of critical incidents.Professional Psychology: Research and Practice,23,203-210.
  36. Greenberg, J.(Ed.)(2003).Organizational behavior: The state of science.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  37. Grzywacz, J. G.,Arcury, T. A.,Marin, A.,Carrillo, L.,Coates, M. L.,Burke, B.(2007).The organization of work: Implications for injury and illness among immigrant Latino poultry-processing workers.Archives of Environmental and Occupational Health,62,19-26.
  38. Harris, K. J.,Harvey, P.,Kacmar, K. M.(2011).Abusive supervisory reactions to coworker relationship conflict.The Leadership Quarterly,22,1010-1023.
  39. Harris, K. J.,Kacmar, K. M.,Zivnuska, S.(2007).An investigation of abusive supervision as a predictor of performance and the meaning of work as a moderator of the relationship.The Leadership Quarterly,18,252-263.
  40. Harvey, P.,Stoner, J.,Hochwarter, W.,Kacmar, C.(2007).Coping with abusive supervision: The neutralizing effects of ingratiation and positive affect on negative employee outcomes.The Leadership Quarterly,18,264-280.
  41. Hershcovis, M. S.(2011)."Incivility, social undermining, bullying... oh my!": A call to reconcile constructs within workplace aggression research.Journal of Organizational Behavior,32,499-519.
  42. Hobfoll, S. E.(1989).Conservation of resources: A new attempt at conceptualizing stress.American Psychologist,44,513-524.
  43. Hofstede, G. H.(1980).Culture's consequences: International differences in work-related values.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  44. Hofstede, G. H.,Bond, M. H.(1988).The Confucius connection: From cultural roots to economic growth.Organizational Dynamics,16,5-21.
  45. Hoobler, J. M.,Brass, D. J.(2006).Abusive supervision and family undermining as displaced aggression.Journal of Applied Psychology,91,1125-1133.
  46. Hoobler, J. M.,Hu, J.(2013).A model of injustice, abusive supervision, and negative affect.The Leadership Quarterly,24,256-269.
  47. Hu, C.,Wu, T. Y.,Wang, Y. H.(2011).Measurement equivalence/invariance of the abusive supervision measure across workers from Taiwan and the United States.Journal of Psychology,145,111-131.
  48. Hu, H. H.(2012).The influence of employee emotional intelligence on coping with supervisor abuse in a banking context.Social Behavior and Personality,40,863-874.
  49. Huang, X.(Ed.),Bond, M. H.(Ed.)(2012).Handbook of Chinese organizational behavior: Integrating theory, research and practice.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
  50. Inness, M.,Barling, J.,Tumer, N.(2005).Understanding supervisor-targeted aggression: A within-person, between-jobs design.Journal of Applied Psychology,90,731-739.
  51. Jian, Z. Q.,Kwan, H. K.,Qiu, Q.,Liu, Z. Q.,Yim, F. H. K.(2012).Abusive supervision and frontline employees' service performance.The Service Industries Journal,32,683-698.
  52. Johnson, R. E.,Venus, M.,Lanaj, K.,Mao, C.,Chang, C. H.(2012).Leader identity as an antecedent of the frequency and consistency of transformational, consideration, and abusive leadership behaviors.Journal of Applied Psychology,97,1262-1272.
  53. Keashly, L.,Trott, V.,MacLean, L. M.(1994).Abusive behavior in the workplace: A preliminary investigation.Violence and Victims,9,341-357.
  54. Kelloway, E. K.(Ed.),Barling, J.(Ed.),Hurrell, J. J., Jr.(Ed.)(2006).Handbook of workplace violence.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  55. Kernan, M. C.,Watson, S.,Chen, F. F.,Kim, T. G.(2011).How cultural values affect the impact of abusive supervision on worker attitudes.Cross Cultural Management: An International Journal,18,464-484.
  56. Kiazad, K.,Restubog, S. L. D.,Zagenczyk, T. J.,Kiewitz, C.,Tang, R. L.(2010).In pursuit of power: The role of authoritarian leadership in the relationship between supervisors' machiavellianism and subordinates' perceptions of abusive supervisory behavior.Journal of Research in Personality,44,512-519.
  57. Kirkman, B. L.,Shapiro, D. L.(1997).The impact of cultural values on employee resistance to teams: Toward a model of globalized self-managing work team effectiveness.Academy of Management Review,22,730-757.
  58. Kohli, A. K.,Jaworski, B. J.(1990).Market orientation: The construct, research propositions, and managerial implications.Journal of Marketing,54,1-18.
  59. Lian, H.,Brown, D.,Ferris, D. L.,Liang, L.,Keeping, L.,Morrison, R.(2014).Abusive supervision and retaliation: A self-control framework.Academy of Management Journal,57,116-139.
  60. Lian, H.,Ferris, D. L.,Brown, D. J.(2012).Does power distance exacerbate or mitigate the effects of abusive supervision? It depends on the outcome.Journal of Applied Psychology,97,107-123.
  61. Lian, H.,Ferris, D. L.,Brown, D. J.(2012).Does taking the good with the bad make things worse? How abusive supervision and leader-member exchange interact to impact need satisfaction and organizational deviance.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,117,41-52.
  62. Lin, W.,Wang, L.,Chen, S.(2013).Abusive supervision and employee well‐being: The moderating effect of power distance orientation.Applied Psychology,62,308-329.
  63. Liu, D.,Liao, H.,Loi, R.(2012).The dark side of leadership: A three-level investigation of the cascading effect of abusive supervision on employee creativity.Academy of Management Journal,55,1187-1212.
  64. Liu, J.,Kwan, H. K.,Wu, L. Z.,Wu, W.(2010).Abusive supervision and subordinate supervisor-directed deviance: The moderating role of traditional values and the mediating role of revenge cognitions.Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology,83,835-856.
  65. Martinko, M. J.,Harvey, P.,Brees, J. R.,Mackey, J.(2013).A review of abusive supervision research.Journal of Organizational Behavior,34,S120-S137.
  66. Martinko, M. J.,Harvey, P.,Sikora, D.,Douglas, S. C.(2011).Perceptions of abusive supervision: The role of subordinates' attribution styles.The Leadership Quarterly,22,751-764.
  67. Mawritz, M. B.,Mayer, D. M.,Hoobler, J. M.,Wayne, S. J.,Marinova, S. V.(2012).A trickle-down model of abusive supervision.Personnel Psychology,65,325-357.
  68. Mitchell, M. S.,Ambrose, M. L.(2012).Employees' behavioral reactions to supervisor aggression: An examination of individual and situational factors.Journal of Applied Psychology,97,1148-1170.
  69. Mitchell, M. S.,Ambrose, M. L.(2007).Abusive supervision and workplace deviance and the moderating effects of negative reciprocity beliefs.Journal of Applied Psychology,92,1159-1168.
  70. Neuman, J. H.,Baron, R. A.(1998).Workplace violence and workplace aggression: Evidence concerning specific forms, potential causes, and preferred targets.Journal of Management Studies,24,391-419.
  71. Ogunfowora, B.(2013).When the abuse is unevenly distributed: The effects of abusive supervision variability on work attitudes and behaviors.Journal of Organizational Behavior,34,1105-1123.
  72. Priesemuth, M.(2013).Stand up and speak up: Employees' prosocial reactions to observed abusive supervision.Business and Society,52,649-665.
  73. Redding, S. G.(1990).The spirit of Chinese capitalism.Berlin, DE:Walter de Gruyter.
  74. Restubog, S. L. D.,Scott, K. L.,Zagenczyk, T. J.(2011).When distress hits home: The role of contextual factors and psychological distress in predicting employees' responses to abusive supervision.Journal of Applied Psychology,96,713-729.
  75. Robinson, S. L.,Bennett, R. J.(1995).A typology of deviant workplace behaviors: A multidimensional scaling study.Academy of Management Journal,38,555-572.
  76. Schaubhut, N.,Adams, G. A.,Jex, S. M.(2004).Self-esteem as a moderator of the relationships between abusive supervision and two forms of workplace deviance.annual meeting of the Society for Industrial Organizational Psychology,Chicago, IL:
  77. Shao, P.,Resick, C. J.,Hargis, M. B.(2011).Helping and harming others in the workplace: The roles of personal values and abusive supervision.Human Relations,64,1051-1078.
  78. Tedeschi, J. T.,Felson, R. B.(1994).Violence, aggression, and coercive actions.Washington, DC:American Psychological Association.
  79. Tehrani, N.(Ed.)(2001).Building a culture of respect: Managing bullying at work.London, UK:Taylor & Francis.
  80. Tepper, B. J.(2007).Abusive supervision in work organizations: Review, synthesis, and research agenda.Journal of Management,33,261-289.
  81. Tepper, B. J.(2000).Consequences of abusive supervision.Academy of Management Journal,43,178-190.
  82. Tepper, B. J.,Carr, J. C.,Breaux, D. M.,Geider, S.,Hu, C.,Hua, W.(2009).Abusive supervision, intentions to quit, and employees' workplace deviance: A power/dependence analysis.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,109,156-167.
  83. Tepper, B. J.,Duffy, M. K.,Henle, C. A.,Lambert, L. S.(2006).Procedural injustice, victim precipitation, and abusive supervision.Personnel Psychology,59,101-123.
  84. Tepper, B. J.,Henle, C. A.(2011).A case for recognizing distinctions among constructs that capture interpersonal mistreatment in work organizations.Journal of Organizational Behavior,32,487-498.
  85. Tepper, B. J.,Henle, C. A.,Lambert, L. S.,Giacalone, R. A.,Duffy, M. K.(2008).Abusive supervision and subordinates' organization deviance.Journal of Applied Psychology,93,721-732.
  86. Tepper, B. J.,Moss, S. E.,Duffy, M. K.(2011).Predictors of abusive supervision: Supervisor perceptions of deep-level dissimilarity, relationship conflict, and subordinate performance.Academy of Management Journal,54,279-294.
  87. Tepper, B. J.,Moss, S. E.,Lockhart, D. E.,Carr, J. C.(2007).Abusive supervision, upward maintenance communication, and subordinates' psychological distress.Academy of Management Journal,50,1169-1180.
  88. Thau, S.,Bennett, R. J.,Mitchell, M. S.,Marrs, M. B.(2009).How management style moderates the relationship between abusive supervision and workplace deviance: An uncertainty management theory perspective.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,108,79-92.
  89. Thau, S.,Mitchell, M. S.(2010).Self-gain or self-regulation impairment? Tests of competing explanations of the supervisor abuse and employee deviance relationship through perceptions of distributive justice.Journal of Applied Psychology,95,1009-1031.
  90. Thibaut, J.,Walker, L.(1975).Procedural justice: A psychological analysis.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  91. Tierney, P.,Tepper, B. J.(2007).Introduction to The Leadership Quarterly special issue: Destructive leadership.The Leadership Quarterly,18,171-173.
  92. Tsai, J. L.,Knutson, B.,Fung, H. H.(2006).Cultural variation in affect valuation.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,90,288-307.
  93. Tyler, T. R.(1989).The psychology of procedural justice: A test of the group-value model.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,57,830-838.
  94. Unal, A. F.,Warren, D. E.,Chen, C. C.(2012).The normative foundations of unethical supervision in organizations.Journal of Business Ethics,107,5-19.
  95. Wang, W.,Mao, J. Y.,Wu, W. K.,Liu, J.(2012).Abusive supervision and workplace deviance: The mediating role of interactional justice and the moderating role of power distance.Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources,50,43-60.
  96. Whitman, M. V.,Halbesleben, J. R. B.,Holmes, O.(2014).Abusive supervision and feedback avoidance: The mediating role of emotional exhaustion.Journal of Organizational Behavior,35,38-53.
  97. Wu, L. Z.,Kwan, H. K.,Liu, J.,Resick, C. J.(2012).Work-to-family spillover effects of abusive supervision.Journal of Managerial Psychology,27,714-731.
  98. Wu, T. Y.,Hu, C.(2009).Abusive supervision and employee emotional exhaustion: Dispositional antecedents and boundaries.Group and Organization Management,34,143-169.
  99. Wu, T. Y.,Hu, C.(2013).Abusive supervision and subordinate emotional labor: The moderating role of openness personality.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,43,956-970.
  100. Xu, E.,Huang, X.,Lam, C. K.,Miao, Q.(2012).Abusive supervision and work behaviors: The mediating role of LMX.Journal of Organizational Behavior,33,531-543.
  101. Yang, K. S.、Yu, A. B.、Yeh, M. H.(1989)。Chinese individual modernity and traditionality: Construction definition and measurement。Proceedings of the Interdisciplinary Conference on Chinese Psychology and Behavior
  102. Zellars, K. L.,Tepper, B. J.,Duffy, M. K.(2002).Abusive supervision and subordinates' organizational citizenship behavior.Journal of Applied Psychology,87,1068-1076.
  103. Zhang, H.,Kwan, H. K.,Zhang, X.,Wu, L. Z.(2014).High core self-evaluators maintain creativity: A motivational model of abusive supervision.Journal of Management,40,1151-1174.
  104. Zhao, H.,Peng, Z.,Han, Y.,Sheard, G.,Hudson, A.(2013).Psychological mechanism linking abusive supervision and compulsory citizenship behavior: A moderated mediation study.The Journal of Psychology: Interdisciplinary and Applied,147,177-195.
  105. 王震、孫建敏、趙一君(2012)。中國組織情境下的領導有效性：對變革型領導、領導—部屬交換和破壞型領導的元分析。心理科學進展，20，174-190。
  106. 任金剛、樊景立、鄭伯壎、周麗芳(2003)。教育部華人本土心理學研究追求卓越計畫研究報告教育部華人本土心理學研究追求卓越計畫研究報告,台北=Taipei:教育部=Ministry of Education。
  107. 吳維庫、王未、劉軍、吳隆增(2012)。辱虐管理、心理安全感與員工建言。管理學報，9，57-63。
  108. 李甯琪、易小年(2010)。組織公平、辱虐管理及員工工作倦怠關係實證研究。科技與管理，2010(12)，46-49。
  109. 李增(2001)。先秦法家哲學思想：先秦法家法理、政治、哲學。台北=Taipei:國立編譯館=National Institute of Compilation and Translation。
  110. 李銳、凌文輇、柳士順(2009)。上司不當督導對下屬建言行為的影響及其作用機制。心理學報，41，1189-1202。
  111. 洪贊凱、卓明德、洪詩晴(2011)。主管知覺互動不正義、主管不當督導與部屬績效關係之研究―主管與部屬適配的干擾角色以及情緒耗竭的中介歷程。中原企管評論，9，67-92。
  112. 馬力、王慧媛(2011)。從組織和領導角度降低金融風險。清華大學學報，51，530-535。
  113. 馬躍如、彭靜、李樹(2011)。複雜企業環境下辱虐式領導、團隊效能、團隊績效作用機制的實證研究。中南大學學報（社會科學版），17(4)，78-85。
  114. 高日光(2009)。破壞性領導會是組織的害群之馬嗎？中國組織情境的破壞性領導行為研究。管理世界，2009(9)，124-132+147。
  115. 黃光國(2009)。儒家關係主義―哲學反思、理論建構與實徵研究。台北=Taipei:心理=Psychological。
  116. 劉軍、吳隆增、林雨(2009)。應對辱虐管理：下屬逢迎與政治技能的作用機制研究。南開管理評論，12(2)，52-58。
  117. 蔣獎、王榮(2012)。辱虐管理與下屬針對領導的偏差行為：同事行為和懲罰可能性的調節作用。中國臨床心理學雜誌，20，214-219。
  118. 顏愛民、高瑩(2010)。虐辱管理對員工職場偏差行為的影響：組織認同的中介作用。首都經濟貿易大學學報，2010(6)，55-61。
  119. 嚴丹(2012)。上級辱虐管理對員工建言行為的影響―來自製造型企業的證據。管理科學，25，41-50。
被引用次数
  1. 丁玲蘭(2016)。主管馬基維利人格傾向對員工工作滿意度之影響： 探討不當督導之中介角色。淡江大學企業管理學系碩士在職專班學位論文。2016。1-46。 
  2. 李婉翠(2016)。不當督導前因後果之探討：以核心自我評價與知覺公平為干擾角色。淡江大學企業管理學系碩士班學位論文。2016。1-127。 
print cancel