性別、自我效能、工作價值、科學素養及學校層次因素對臺灣青少年學習情緒之影響：個人與情境交互作用之多層次分析

The Impact of Gender, Self-Efficacy, Task Value, Scientific Literacy, and School-Level Factors on Taiwanese Teenagers' Academic Emotions: A Multilevel Analysis of Person-Context Interactions

巫博瀚(Po-Han Wu)；賴英娟(Ying-Chuan Lai)

PISA國際評量計畫 ； 多層次模型 ； 跨層次交互作用效果 ； 聚合脈絡變數 ； 學習情緒 ； PISA ； multilevel models ； cross-level interaction effect ； aggregate context variables ； achievement/academic emotion

教育科學研究期刊

56卷3期（2011 / 09 / 01）

119 - 149

繁體中文

本研究以學習情緒的控制價值理論為基礎，探討個人與學校層次變項對學習情緒之影響。研究資料係取自PISA 2006所釋出之階層巢套資料，有效樣本為8,678名（女生4,134名、男生4,544名）來自236個不同學校的臺灣15歲青少年。本研究採多層次模型進行分析，結果顯示個人層次變項（性別、自我效能、工作價值及科學素養）與學校層次變項（學校平均科學素養、學校平均工作價值、團體效能）能正向且顯著地解釋學生的正向學習情緒，且自我效能對學習情緒的影響會受到學校平均科學素養與團體效能等脈絡變項所調節。針對上述研究發現，本研究提出未來研究與學習輔導之相關建議。

Based on control-value theory of achievement emotions, this study investigates the effects of individual- and school-level factors on academic emotions. Hierarchically nested data were obtained from 8,678 15-year-old students (4,134 girls and 4,544 boys) of 236 schools in Taiwan, who participated in the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA). The results obtained from a multilevel model reveal that individual-level factors (gender, self-efficacy, task value, and scientific literacy) and school-level factors (school mean of scientific literacy, school mean of task value, and collective efficacy) are positively and significantly related to the positive academic emotions of students. Additionally, the school mean of scientific literacy and collective efficacy moderate the effects of self-efficacy on academic emotions. This study presents a discussion on the implications and educational practices, and provides suggestions for future research.

1. 林鉦棽、彭台光(2006)。多層次管理研究：分析層次的概念、理論和方法。管理學報，23(6)，649-675。
   連結：
2. 侯雅齡(2011)。科學自我概念之大魚小池效應探究：資優生教育安置方式的思考。教育科學研究期刊，55(3)，61-87。
   連結：
3. 張郁雯(2008)。對比效應對學業自我概念之影響─發展的觀點。教育心理學報，40(1)，23-37。
   連結：
4. 陳玉樹、胡夢鯨(2008)。任務動機與組織創新氣候對成人教師創意教學表現之影響：階層線性模式分析。教育心理學報，40(2)，179-198。
   連結：
5. 溫福星、邱皓政(2009)。組織研究中的多層次調節式中介效果：以組織創新氣氛、組織承諾與工作滿意的實證研究為例。管理學報，26(2)，189-211。
   連結：
6. Pekrun, R., Goetz, T., & Perry, R. P. (2005). Academic Emotions Questionnaire (AEQ): User's manual. Munich, Germany: Department of Psychology, University of Munich..
7. Ahmed, W.,Minnaert, A.,Werf, G.,Kuyper, H.(2010).Perceived social support and early adolescents' achievement: The mediational roles of motivational beliefs and emotions.Journal of Youth & Adolescence,39(1),36-46.
8. Baker, D. F.(2001).The development of collective efficacy in small task groups.Small Group Research,32(4),451-474.
9. Bandura, A.(2001).Social cognitive theory: An agentic perspective.Annual Review of Psychology,52,1-26.
10. Bandura, A.(2001).Social cognitive theory of mass communication.Media Psychology,3(3),265-299.
11. Bandura, A.(1997).Self-efficacy: The exercise of control.New York:Freeman.
12. Bandura, A.(2000).Exercise of human agency through collective efficacy.Current Directions in Psychological Science,9(3),75-78.
13. Bernardo, A. B. I.,Ouano, J. A.,Salanga, M. G. C.(2009).What is an academic emotion? Insights from Filipino bilingual students' emotion word associated with learning.Psychological Studies,54(1),28-37.
14. Ciani, K. D.,Middleton, M. J.,Summers, J. J.,Sheldon, K. M.(2010).Buffering against performance classroom goal structures: The importance of autonomy support and classroom community.Contemporary Educational Psychology,35(1),88-99.
15. Cohen, J.,Cohen, P.,West, S. G.,Aiken, L. S.(2003).Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavioral sciences.Mahwah, NJ:Erlbaum.
16. Daniels, L. M.,Haynes, T. L.,Stupnisky, R. H.,Perry, R. P.,Newall, N. E.,Pekrun, R.(2008).Individual differences in achievement goals: A longitudinal study of cognitive, emotional , and achievement outcomes.Contemporary Educational Psychology,33(4),584-608.
17. Daniels, L. M.,Stupnisky, R. H.,Pekrun, R.,Haynes, T. L.,Perry, R. P.,Newall, N. E.(2009).A longitudinal analysis of achievement goals: From affective antecedents to emotional effects and achievement outcomes.Journal of Educational Psychology,101(4),948-963.
18. Davis, J. A.(1966).The campus as a frog pond: An application of the theory of relative deprivation to career decisions of college men.American Journal of Sociology,72(1),17-31.
19. Decuir-Gunby, J. T.,Aultman, L. P.,Schutz, P. A.(2009).Investigating transactions among motives, emotional regulation related to testing, and test emotions.Journal of Experimental Education,77(4),409-438.
20. Eccles, J. S.,Wigfield, A.(2002).Motivational beliefs, values, and goals.Annual Review of Psychology,53,109-132.
21. Eccles, J. S.,Wigfield, A.(1995).In the mind of the actor: The structure of adolescents' achievement task values and expectancy-related beliefs.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,21(3),215-225.
22. Enders, C. K.,Tofighi, D.(2007).Centering predictor variables in cross-sectional multilevel models: A new look at an old issue.Psychological Methods,12(2),121-138.
23. Forgays, D. G.(Ed.),Sosnowski, T.(Ed.),Wresniewski, K.(Ed.)(1992).Anxiety: Recent development in cognitive, psychophsysiological and health research.Washington, DC:Hemisphere.
24. Fornell, C.,Larcker, D. F.(1981).Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error.Journal of Marketing Research,18(1),39-50.
25. Frenzel, A. C.,Goetz, T.,Lüdtke, O.,Pekrun, R.,Sutton, R. E.(2009).Emotional transmission in the classroom: Exploring the relationship between teacher and student enjoyment.Journal of Educational Psychology,101(3),705-716.
26. Frenzel, A. C.,Pekrun, R.,Goetz, T.(2007).Girls and mathematics-A "hopeless" issue? A control-value approach to gender differences in emotions toward mathematics.European Journal of Psychology of Education,22(4),497-514.
27. Frenzel, A. C.,Pekrun, R.,Goetz, T.(2007).Perceived learning environment and students' emotional experiences: A Multilevel analysis of mathematics classrooms.Learning and Instruction,17(5),478-493.
28. Frenzel, A. C.,Thrash, T. M.,Pekrun, R.,Goetz, T.(2007).Achievement emotions in Germany and China: A cross-cultural validation of the academic emotions questionnaire-mathematics.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,38(3),302-309.
29. Goetz, T.,Frenzel, A. C.,Hall, N.,Pekrun, R.(2008).Antecedents of academic emotions: Testing the internal/external frame of reference model for academic enjoyment.Contemporary Educational Psychology,33(1),9-33.
30. Goetz, T.,Frenzel, A. C.,Pekrun, R.,Hall, N. C.(2006).The domain specificity of academic emotional experiences.Journal of Experimental Education,75(1),5-29.
31. Goetz, T.,Frenzel, A. C.,Stoeger, H.,Hall, N. C.(2010).Antecedents of everyday positive emotions: An experience sampling analysis.Motivation & Emotion,34(1),49-62.
32. Goetz, T.,Pekrun, R.,Hall, N.,Haag, L.(2006).Academic emotions from a social-cognitive perspective: Antecedents and domain specificity of students' affect in the context of Latin instruction.British Journal of Educational Psychology,72(2),289-308.
33. Govaerts, S.,Grogire, J.(2008).Development and construct validation of an academic emotions scale.International Journal of Testing,8(1),35-54.
34. Halvari, H.,Ulstad, S. O.,Bagøien, T. E.,Skjesol, K.(2009).Autonomy support and its links to physical activity and competitive performance: Mediations through motivation, competence, action orientation and harmonious passion, and the moderator role of autonomy support by perceived competence.Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research,53(6),355-555.
35. Heck, R. H.,Thomas, S. L.(2009).An introduction to multilevel modeling techniques.New York:Routledge.
36. Hofmann, D. A.,Gavin, M. B.(1998).Centering decisions in hierarchical linear models: Implications for research in organization.Journal of Management,24(5),623-641.
37. Hox, J. J.(2010).Multilevel analysis: Techniques and applications.New York:Routledge.
38. James, L. R.,Demaree, R. G.,Wolf, G.(1993).An assessment of within-group interrater agreement.Journal of Applied Psychology,78(2),306-309.
39. Kreft, I.,Leeuw, J. D.(1998).Introducing multilevel modeling.Thousand Oakes, CA:Sage.
40. Kreibig, S. D.,Gendolla, G. H. E.,Scherer, K. R.(2010).Psychophysiological effects of emotional responding to goal attainment.Biological Psychology,84,474-487.
41. Lau, S.,Nie, Y.(2008).Interplay between personal goals and classroom goal structures in predicting student outcomes: A multilevel analysis of person-context interactions.Journal of Educational Psychology,100(1),15-29.
42. Luke, D. A.(2004).Multilevel modeling.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
43. Maas, C. J. M.,Hox, J. J.(2005).Sufficient sample size for multilevel modeling.Methodology: European Journal of Research Methods for the Behavioral and Social Sciences,1(3),86-92.
44. Marsh, H. W.,Hau, K.-T.(2003).Big-fish-little-pond-effect on academic self-concept. A crosscultural (26 country) test of the negative effects of academically selective schools.American Psychologist,58(5),364-376.
45. Marsh, H. W.,Kong, C.-K.,Hau, K.-T.(2000).Longitudinal multilevel models of the big-fish-little-pond effect on academic self-concept: Counterbalancing contrast and reflected glory effects in Hong Kong school.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,78(2),337-349.
46. Marsh, H. W.,Seaton, M.,Trautwein, U.,Lüdtke, O.,Hau, K.-T.,O''Mara, A. J.(2008).The big-fish-little-pond-effect stands up to critical scrutiny: Implications for theory, methodology, and future research.Educational Psychology Review,20(3),319-350.
47. Mayring, P.(Ed.),Rhoeneck, C. V.(Ed.)(2003).Learning emotions: The influence of affective factors on classroom learning.Frankfurt, Germany:Peter Lang.
48. Mouratidis, A.,Vansteenkiste, M.,Lens, W.,Auweele, Y. V.(2009).Beyond positive and negative affect: Achievement goals and discrete emotions in the elementary physical education classroom.Psychology of Sport & Exercise,10(3),336-343.
49. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development(2009).PISA 2006 technical report.Paris:Author.
50. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development(2006).Assessing scientific, reading and mathematical literacy: A framework for PISA 2006.Paris:Author.
51. Pekrun, R.(2006).The control-value theory of achievement emotions: Assumptions, corollaries, and implications for educational research and practice.Educational Psychology Review,18(4),315-341.
52. Pekrun, R.(2000).A social-cognitive, control-value theory of achievement emotions: Developing motivation and motivation development.Motivational psychology of human development,Oxford, England:
53. Pekrun, R.(2005).Progress and open problem in educational emotion research.Learning and Instruction,15(5),497-506.
54. Pekrun, R.,Elliot, A. J.,Maier, M. A.(2006).Achievement goals and discrete achievement emotions: A Theoretical model and prospective test.Journal of Educational Psychology,98(3),583-597.
55. Pekrun, R.,Elliot, A. J.,Maier, M. A.(2009).Achievement goals and achievement emotions: Testing a model of their joint relations with academic performance.Journal of Educational Psychology,101(1),115-135.
56. Perkun, R.,Goetz, T.,Perry, R. P.,Kramer, K.,Hochstadt, M.,Molfenter, S.(2004).Beyond test anxiety: Development and vailidation of the Test Emotions Questionnaire(TEQ).Anxiety Stress and Coping,17(3),287-316.
57. Perkun, R.,Goetz, T.,Titz, W.,Perry, R. P.(2002).Academic emotions in students' self-regulated learning and achievement: A Program of qualitative and quantitative research.Educational Psychologist,37(2),91-105.
58. Perkun, R.,Stephens, E. J.(2009).Goals, emotions, and emotion regulation: Perspectives of the control-value theory.Human Development,52(6),357-365.
59. Pintrich, P. R.,Schunk, D. H.(2002).Motivation in education: Theory, research, and applications.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice Hall.
60. Raudenbush, S. W.,Bryk, A. S.(2002).Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
61. SAS(2009).SAS 9.2 companion for Windows.Cary, NC:SAS.
62. Schunk, D. H.(Ed.),Zimmerman, B. J.(Ed.)(1994).Self-regulation of learning and performance: Issues and educational applications.Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum.
63. Schutz, P. A.(Ed.),Pekrun, R.(Ed.)(2007).Emotion in education.San Diego:Elsevier.
64. Schutz, P. A.,Lanehart, S. L.(2002).Introducation: Emotions in education.Educational Psychologist,37(2),67-68.
65. Singer, J. D.(1998).Using SAS PROC MIXED to fit multilevel models, hierarchical models, and individual growth models.Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics,24(4),323-355.
66. Singer, J. D.,Willett, J. B.(2003).Applied longitudinal data analysis: Modeling change and event occurrence.New York:Oxford University Press.
67. Snijders, T. A. B.,Bosker, R. J.(1999).Multilevel analysis: An Introduction to basic and advanced multilevel modeling.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
68. Trautwein, U.,Schnyder, I.,Niggli, A.,Neumann, M.,Lüdtke, O.(2009).Chameleon effects in homework research: The homework-achievement association depends on the measures used and the level of analysis chosen.Contemporary Educational Psychology,34(1),77-88.
69. Turner, J. E.,Husman, J.(2008).Emotional and cognitive self-regulation following academic shame.Journal of Advanced Academics,20(1),138-173.
70. Tyson, D. F.,Linnenbrink-Garcia, L.,Hill, N. E.(2009).Regulating debilitating emotions in the context of performance: Achievement goal orientations, achievement-elicited emotions, and socialization contexts.Human Development,52(6),329-356.
71. West, B. T.,Welch, K. B.,Galecki, A. T.(2007).Linear mixed models: A practical guide using statistical software.New York:Chapman & Hall/CRC.
72. Wu, P.-H.,Luh, W.-M.,Lai, Y.-C.(2010).The effects of perceived learning environment on the achievement emotions: Analyzing clustered data by using linear mixed models.2010 annual meeting of the American Education Research Association (AERA),Denver, CO:
73. 巫博瀚、陸偉明、賴英娟(2011)。性別、自我效能及所知覺的學習環境對學習情緒之影響：線性混合模式在叢集資料之應用。教育與心理研究，34(1)，29-54。
74. 李茂能(2009)。圖解AMOS在學術研究之應用。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:五南=Wu-Nan Book。
75. 林煥祥、劉聖忠、林素微、李暉(2008)。行政院國家科學委員會專案研究報告行政院國家科學委員會專案研究報告,台北市=Taipei:行政院國家科學委員會=National Science Council。
76. 陳玉樹、莊閔喬(2010)。創意個人認定與組織認同對創意教學表現之影響： 多元組識認定的調節效果。教育政策論壇，13(3)，155-184。

1. 蔡長清、曾鈞麟、耿英蕊(2013)。教師之休閒調適、工作情緒與自我效能之關聯研究─以高雄市國民中學教師為例。運動休閒餐旅研究，8(2)，82-112。
2. 蔡心華、梁英文、林淑芳(2017)。工作—家庭助益、自我效能與滿意度之研究─以國際觀光旅館員工為例。戶外遊憩研究，30(4)，31-63。
3. 賴英娟、巫博瀚(2016)。臺灣國中生「數學學習情緒量表」之發展與現況分析。測驗學刊，63(2)，83-110。
4. 賴英娟、巫博瀚(2017)。國中生學業情緒與學習投入對學業成就之影響。課程與教學，20(3)，139-164。
5. 賴英娟、巫博瀚(2018)。國中生所知覺到的教師自主支持、自我效能及自主動機對學業情緒之影響。課程與教學，21(2)，85-110。
6. 賴英娟、張楓明、江春鳳(2016)。幼兒教保系學生之社會支持、自我效能、結果預期及興趣對職業意向之影響。中華輔導與諮商學報，45，123-148。
7. 梁英文,高崇倫,林香君(2022)。契合度與自我效能之關係：工作－休閒助益的干擾效果。戶外遊憩研究，35(4)，67-104。
8. 林淑君、王麗斐(2015)。滴水穿石：某偏鄉國中駐校心理諮商介入方案之縱貫性追蹤研究。教育科學研究期刊，60(4)，161-190。
9. 劉思彣(2021)。臺灣近20年特殊性自我效能分類架構與趨勢研究。科技與人力教育季刊，7(4)，90-108。
10. 劉玉玲,沈淑芬(2019)。國中生數學自我概念、數學學習策略與數學學業成就之模式建構。課程與教學，22(3)，187-214。
11. 劉玉玲、沈淑芬(2015)。數學自我概念、數學學習策略、數學學業情緒與數學學業成就之研究－自我提升模式觀點。教育心理學報，46(4)，491-516。
12. 錢昭萍、梁麗珍(2017)。動畫與繪本融入教學對不同學制與性別的學生學習之影響—以科技大學國文類通識課程為例。人文社會學報，13(3)，251-282。
13. 錢昭萍、梁麗珍(2017)。多元教學對不同學院與性別的學生學習態度與學習成效之影響—以科技大學大一國文課為例。人文社會學報，13(3)，219-249。
14. 蘇玲慧(2015)。國小學生學業情緒與幸福感之模式研究—以同儕互動為中介變項。教育經營與管理研究集刊，11，111-136。
15. 童惠玲,陳永褔(2019)。綁定的關係聚束－領導部屬交換關係對情感性承諾的雙路徑影響。管理研究學報，19，71-103。
16. 謝慶華、靳知勤、陳淑貞、段曉林(2016)。國中自然與生活科技學習參與量表的發展與相關因素之探討。科學教育學刊，24(3)，249-273。
17. (2019)。貧窮高職生人際關係、未來準備與生涯自我效能關係之研究。市北教育學刊，62，71-101。